IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NEW PLYMOUTH REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA NGĀMOTU ROHE
CRI-2024-443-000033
[2024] NZHC 3064
BETWEEN GARY STEPHEN SHRAMKA
Appellant
AND
SOUTH TARANAKI DISTRICT COUNCIL
Respondent
Hearing: 1 October 2024 Counsel:
H W Fairey for Appellant J E Bourke for Respondent
Judgment:
18 October 2024
JUDGMENT OF BOLDT J
[1] This case is about a black labrador/ridgeback cross named Dexter. Dexter belongs to the Shramka family, who live at a rural property near Ōpunake. The appellant, Gary Shramka, is Dexter’s registered owner.
[2] This appeal arises because, on 20 February this year, Dexter bit a courier driver. The respondent, the South Taranaki District Council, prosecuted Mr Shramka, as Dexter’s owner, on a charge of owning a dog that attacked a person.1 Mr Shramka pleaded guilty, and on 20 August 2024 Judge Greig convicted him, fined him $500 and made an order for Dexter’s destruction.2
1 Dog Control Act 1996, ss 57(2) and (3). Maximum penalty of $3,000 fine. The court must also make an order for the destruction of the dog unless “the circumstances of the offence were exception and do not warrant destruction of the dog.”
2 South Taranaki District Council v Shramka [2024] NZDC 20161 [Decision under appeal].
SHRAMKA v SOUTH TARANAKI DISTRICT COUNCIL [2024] NZHC 3064 [18 October 2024]
[3] Mr Shramka appeals against his sentence, arguing the circumstances of the attack were exceptional, and that an order for Dexter’s destruction was not warranted. As discussed in more detail below, at the hearing of the appeal, Mr Fairey, on behalf of Mr Shramka, made an oral application for leave to appeal out of time against Mr Shramka’s conviction.
Background
[4] Dexter is 13 years old. He is a beloved family dog. Despite being relatively elderly, as dogs go, there is no record of his having attacked anyone before.
[5] On 20 February 2024, the victim arrived at Mr Shramka’s address to deliver a parcel. The parcel was too big to fit into the letterbox, so it had to be physically delivered to the house. The victim drove her van up the track to Mr Shramka’s address, stopped at the gate and tooted the horn. Dexter was in the front section and began barking.
[6] Mr Shramka’s property is fully fenced, and at the time of the attack Mr Shramka himself was out. But a member of his family opened the gate and walked towards the victim’s vehicle. The victim wound the window down. Dexter came running out the gate. He leapt up and bit the victim on the arm as she handed the parcel over. She received bite wounds to her right forearm.
[7] Dexter ran back inside. The victim treated herself with a first aid kit she had in the van, and later saw a doctor who dressed the wound and gave her a tetanus shot and antibiotics. The victim reported the attack to the Council, and the next day an Animal Control Officer went to Mr Shramka’s address…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read GARY STEPHEN SHRAMKA AND SOUTH TARANAKI DISTRICT COUNCIL and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NZHC 3064
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court first addressed the argument that the attack was exceptional. Given that there was no history of aggressive behavior from Dexter, the court noted that a single unprovoked attack does not necessarily qualify as an exceptional circumstance. The court also dismissed the argument that the victim provoked the attack, finding that her actions were ordinary and not provocative. The court then considered the recent Court of Appeal decision in Solicitor-General’s Reference, which clarified that a conviction is necessary for a destruction order under section 57(3). This decision introduced the possibility of a discharge without conviction, even if the circumstances were not exceptional.
The court found that the direct and indirect consequences of a conviction, including the destruction of Dexter, were disproportionate to the gravity of the offence. The attack, while serious, was not severe enough to warrant such a significant consequence, particularly given Dexter’s generally good behavior and the family’s responsible ownership. The court also considered the impact on Mr Shramka, who would lose a beloved pet and face additional consequences of a conviction, such as the need to declare it on job applications. These factors led the court to conclude that a discharge without conviction was appropriate.
The appeal against conviction was allowed, and Mr Shramka was discharged without conviction. The order for Dexter’s destruction was quashed, and in lieu of the fine, Mr Shramka was ordered to pay $500 to the victim in recognition of the emotional harm suffered.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi