Freshmax NZ Limited v Santa Rosa Orchards Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CIV-2014-441-000043 [2014] NZHC 2277

BETWEEN

FRESHMAX NZ LIMITED

Appellant

AND

SANTA ROSA ORCHARDS LIMITED First Respondent

OLIVER THOMAS RYAN Second Respondent

Hearing: 13 August 2014

Appearances:

M Keall for appellant
D Kerr for respondent

Judgment:

19 September 2014

JUDGMENT OF CLIFFORD J

Introduction

[1]      The appellant, Freshmax NZ Ltd (Freshmax), is a large-scale fruit exporter. Freshmax supplies seasonal loans to growers who supply fruit to it to provide liquidity  before  that  fruit  is  sold.    The  loan  and  supply  agreements  between Freshmax and those growers provide for the loans to be deducted from grower payments.  The supply agreements provide for deduction of commission and a range of other costs before the balance is paid to the grower.

[2]      The first respondent, Santa Rosa Orchards Ltd (Santa Rosa), had a loan and supply agreement with Freshmax between 2007 and 2010.

[3]      The second respondent, Mr Ryan, guaranteed Santa Rosa’s repayment of the loans from Freshmax.

FRESHMAX NZ LTD v SANTA ROSA ORCHARDS LTD [2014] NZHC 2277 [19 September 2014]

[4]      Freshmax  is  suing  Santa  Rosa  in  the  District  Court  for  the  outstanding balance  of  the  2010  seasonal  advances.    The  amount  claimed  is  approximately

$53,000.

[5]      By way of set-off and counterclaim Santa Rosa alleges that Freshmax failed to fully account for the sale proceeds of the fruit it supplied and that Freshmax deducted amounts for costs it had not incurred or amounts in excess of costs it incurred (the Counterclaim) between 2007 and 2009.

[6]      Santa Rosa filed a third amended statement of defence and counterclaim on

29 November 2013.  Freshmax subsequently applied to strike out the parts of that statement dealing with the Counterclaim.   In a reserved decision of 7 March 2014

Judge Rea declined that application.1

[7]      Freshmax now appeals against that decision.

Background

[8]      To consider this appeal, it is necessary to record the procedural background in some detail.

The initial pleadings and discovery

[9]      Freshmax commenced proceedings in the High Court in Napier against Santa Rosa in December 2011, and sought summary judgment.  Santa Rosa opposed and a hearing  was  set  for  16  March  2012.     Before  that  hearing  took  place,  those proceedings were transferred by agreement to the District Court.   Consent orders were then made for discovery on wide terms.

[10]     A  short  while  later,  Santa  Rosa  filed  its  statement  of  defence  and counterclaim.  As relevant, Santa Rosa counterclaimed that Freshmax had deducted

excess commission2 and had made deductions for other costs it had not incurred.

1      Freshmax New Zealand Ltd v Santa Rosa Orchards Ltd DC Hastings CIV-2011-041-000825,

7 March 2014.

2      Santa Rosa no longer pursues the allegation that commission was deducted otherwise than at the agreed rate.   Santa Rose has replaced that allegation with its assertion that Freshmax has not fully accounted for sale proceeds.

[11]    Santa Rosa also pleaded that it had asked Freshmax to substantiate the commission and cost deductions claimed, and that it had failed to do so.

[12]     In August 2012 each…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Freshmax NZ Limited v Santa Rosa Orchards Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 2277
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Freshmax NZ Limited, a large-scale fruit exporter, is suing Santa Rosa Orchards Limited, a fruit grower, for the outstanding balance of the 2010 seasonal advances. Santa Rosa counterclaims that Freshmax failed to fully account for the sale proceeds of the fruit it supplied and that Freshmax deducted amounts for costs it had not incurred or amounts in excess of costs it incurred. Freshmax appealed the decision of the District Court which declined to strike out Santa Rosa's counterclaim. The appeal raises questions about the scope of the counterclaim and the adequacy of the pleadings. The Court considered whether the counterclaim complied with the previous decision and whether it was inherently speculative and untenable. The Court found that the counterclaim did comply with the previous decision and was not inherently speculative and untenable. The Court dismissed the appeal and suggested that the parties consider mediation. The costs of the appeal were awarded to Santa Rosa.