IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE
CIV-2014-404-725
[2021] NZHC 2663
BETWEEN THE ESTATE OF MICHAEL DAVID KIDD
by its administrator BRYAN JOHN COOPER
Plaintiff
AND
ALEXANDER PIETER VAN HEEREN
Defendant
Hearing: 9, 10 and 16 September 2021 Appearances:
S J Mills QC (on 16 September 2021), B O’Callahan and EJH Morrison for the plaintiff
M D O’Brien QC and S D Williams for the defendant R C Knight for Ms van Heeren-Hermans
Judgment:
6 October 2021
JUDGMENT OF JAGOSE J
[Ancillary interim payment and other issues]
This judgment was delivered by me on 6 October 2021 at 4.00pm.
Pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.
………………………… Registrar/Deputy Registrar
Counsel/Solicitors:
S J Mills QC, Auckland
M D O’Brien QC, Auckland
B O’Callahan Barrister, Auckland S D Williams Barrister, Auckland R C Knight Barrister, Auckland
K3 Legal Limited (EJH Morrison), Auckland Fee Langstone (C Langstone), Auckland
Bell Gully (T B Fitzgerald and B J Ward), Auckland
THE ESTATE OF MICHAEL DAVID KIDD by its administrator BRYAN JOHN COOPER v VAN HEEREN [2021] NZHC 2663 [6 October 2021]
[1] This judgment is issued contemporaneously with my interim judgment partially determining the defendant’s (“Mr van Heeren”) interlocutory application for relief from disbursement to the plaintiff (for convenience, “Mr Kidd”, although in fact his estate by its administrator, Bryan Cooper) of USD 17.612 million from the USD 25 million interim payment paid into Court on Mr van Heeren’s account.1
[2] This judgment addresses outstanding issues relating to the balance of the interim payment — additional sums for disbursement under my interim substantive judgment; further sums for payment or disbursement; and if further disbursement to Mr Kidd should be stayed on grounds of my interim disbursement judgment — and formulation of separate questions for determination.
Background
[3]My interim substantive judgment found:2
… subject to adjustments for cash and interest, the partnership’s value as a whole at 18 January 1991 is USD 50.895 million, for allocation in equal shares of USD 25.448 million to each Mr Kidd and Mr van Heeren.
Noting Mr Kidd already to have the benefit of USD 7.836 million, “I would allow disbursement to him now on that account of USD 17.612 million from the USD 25 million interim payment”,3 the latter being a sum paid into Court on Mr van Heeren’s account,4 and I ordered accordingly “as an advance on a final accounting yet to be concluded”.5 As my interim disbursement judgment recounts,6 that disbursement was made. My judgment is subject to appeal and cross-appeal.
Additional sums for disbursement
[4] My interim substantive judgment invited Mr Kidd to seek additional disbursement of up to the balance of the interim payment,7 by reference to an interest
1 Kidd v van Heeren [2021] NZHC 2661 [Interim disbursement judgment].
2 Kidd v van Heeren [2021] NZHC 1414 at [201] [Interim substantive judgment].
3 At [203].
4 At [15].
5 At [242].
6 Interim disbursement judgment, above n 1, at [5].
7…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Estate of Kidd v Van Heeren and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] NZHC 2663
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court first addressed the issue of additional sums for disbursement. It found that the partnership assets' value at a specific date had increased due to agreed interest calculations on certain non-cash values. However, the court declined to adjust other line items as requested by the plaintiff, reasoning that any errors were for appeal, not adjustment. Consequently, the court allowed an additional disbursement to the plaintiff from the interim payment.
Next, the court considered requests for further sums from both parties. The plaintiff sought disbursement of the balance of the interim payment, while the defendant sought payment of litigation expenses. The court opted not to disburse the balance to the plaintiff, emphasizing the importance of maintaining the fund for the proceeding's conclusion. Instead, it allowed for the disbursement of litigation expenses for both parties, subject to certification by their solicitors.
The court also addressed the defendant's request for a stay on further disbursement to the plaintiff. While acknowledging the defendant’s right to seek relief, the court determined that a stay was not warranted, given the plaintiff's relative certainty of uplift and the defendant’s delay in complying with the court’s order. Instead, the court ordered an undertaking that the disbursed sum would be repaid if the defendant succeeded on appeal.
Finally, the court dealt with the formulation of separate questions for determination, as proposed by the plaintiff. The court rejected the plaintiff's proposed questions, finding they sought to advance the plaintiff’s position beyond the pleadings and the court’s previous determinations. However, it agreed to separately determine if, under South African law, the defendant had wrongfully retained partnership assets or was required to account for gains made on such assets.
The court ordered the disbursement of an additional USD 218,275 to the plaintiff, subject to a personal undertaking to repay if the defendant succeeded on appeal. It also allowed for the payment of certified litigation expenses to both parties and directed a one-day hearing to decide if the defendant had wrongfully retained partnership assets under South African law. Costs were reserved pending the outcome of the defendant’s appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi