Ellwood v Accident Compensation Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2012-485-1317 [2012] NZHC 2887

IN THE MATTER OF     an intended appeal under section 162 of the

Accident Compensation Act 2001

BETWEEN  MICHAEL ERNEST ELLWOOD Applicant

ANDACCIDENT COMPENSATION CORPORATION

Respondent

Hearing:         20 September 2012

Counsel:         A C Beck for applicant

C Hlavac for respondent

Judgment:      1 November 2012

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF DOBSON J

[1]      The applicant in this proceeding (Mr Ellwood) seeks special leave to appeal from a decision of the District Court in which Judge M J Beattie found that the respondent (ACC) was entitled to suspend Mr Ellwood’s entitlements in respect of an accident he suffered in 1998.[1]

[1] Ellwood v ACC [2011] NZACC 145 (DC).

[2]      Mr Ellwood  received  ACC  cover  for  injuries  sustained  to  his  neck  and shoulder after two accidents in 1993 and 1995.  Medical treatment for those injuries included  two  surgical  interventions  which  achieved  nerve  root  decompression,

resolved neuropathic pain and allowed Mr Ellwood to return to work.

ELLWOOD v ACCIDENT COMPENSATION CORPORATION HC WN CIV-2012-485-1317 [1 November

2012]

[3]      Then Mr Ellwood was involved in a third accident in November 1998.   It appears that he was at the front of a barbecue trolley, sharing the load of carrying it down some stairs with another person, when he was struck by the trolley in his lower back at waist level.  The impact caused what Mr Beck has described as “significant and on-going pain in his neck”.   Mr Ellwood’s general practitioner described the injury as “a muscle strain, left shoulder  girdle and possible neck injury”.   The neurosurgeon who had previously operated on him, Mr Bishara, advised that any further surgery would be of no benefit as there appeared to be no nerve root damage in the relevant area.  Mr Ellwood was granted cover for a physical injury.

[4]      Subsequently,  ACC  sought  an  opinion  from  an  occupational  medicine specialist, Dr Drewry, whose opinion was that Mr Ellwood’s symptoms were not caused  by the  1998  accident,  but  were  a  result  of  degenerative  changes  in  his cervical spine.  Relying on that opinion, ACC suspended entitlements for the 1998 injury in October 1999.

[5]      Mr Ellwood challenged ACC’s decision to suspend his entitlements, first by way of review of ACC’s decision.  That was unsuccessful and Mr Ellwood appealed to the District Court.

[6]      In the first hearing in the District Court in August 2001, Judge Beattie heard a range of views on the cause of Mr Ellwood’s on-going pain.  In a decision delivered in April 2002, the Judge attributed an onus of proof to Mr Ellwood in linking the on-going pain to a physical injury, which he found had not been discharged on the balance of probabilities.

[7]      Leave to appeal having been granted, Mr Ellwood had partial success in this Court, when a re-hearing was directed on terms contemplating that further medical evidence would be obtained.[2]     Mallon J was concerned that decisions to suspend entitlements might be made inappropriately if resolved against claimants on the basis of  their  inability  to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ellwood v Accident Compensation Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 2887
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Ellwood v Accident Compensation Corporation, Michael Ernest Ellwood sought special leave to appeal against the District Court's decision to affirm the Accident Compensation Corporation's (ACC) decision to suspend his entitlements following a 1998 accident. The legal issues before the High Court were whether the District Court judge applied an incorrect test in focusing on the need for a continuing physical injury caused by the accident, whether the District Court judge's approach failed to follow earlier case law in requiring a positive finding on the causes of ongoing pain, whether the District Court judge made material findings that were contrary to the evidence, whether the District Court judge failed to take into account relevant evidence, and whether the District Court judge applied an incorrect approach to causation. The Court found that the law on these issues was settled and that the District Court judge's approach was not inconsistent with that law. The Court also found that the District Court judge was entitled to prefer the opinion of one of the medical experts over the other and that the absence of more detailed analysis of prior medical evidence did not constitute an appropriate question of law. Accordingly, the Court dismissed the application for special leave.

This case highlights the importance of ensuring that the principles adopted by a District Court judge are well settled, and that no arguable question of law can arise on a further appeal. The Court also emphasised the need for the District Court judge to take into account the potentially fraught issue of the causative link between an accident and pain in a claimant who also suffers a pre-existing degenerative condition, and the nature of a "trigger" for that condition to cause pain. This case serves as a reminder that the "but for" test of causation is not sufficient to confirm entitlement for cover in relation to symptoms in these circumstances, and instead the accident must cause its own injury which continues to contribute to the incapacity.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.