Easton v Wellington City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA615/2009
[2009] NZCA 513

BETWEENBENJAMIN MORLAND EASTON


Appellant

ANDWELLINGTON CITY COUNCIL


Respondent

Hearing:21 October 2009

Court:Arnold, Randerson and Allan JJ

Counsel:Appellant in person


C M Stephens and K M Anderson for Respondent

Judgment:23 October 2009 at 11 am 

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

The appeal is allowed in part.  The order for security for costs is varied by substituting the sum of $8,000 for $12,000.  In all other respects, the appeal is dismissed.

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Arnold J)

Introduction

[1]       Mr Easton, who describes himself as a political busker, has brought judicial review proceedings against the Wellington City Council arising out of a proposal to open Manners Mall, a pedestrian mall in Wellington, to bus traffic.  The Council is presently undertaking a statutory consultation process in relation to the proposal, before it makes a final decision.  Mr Easton is concerned that the Council has already made up its mind to go ahead with the project, so that the current consultation is effectively meaningless.

[2]       Mr Easton sought an interim order to prevent the Council from taking further action in relation to the proposal until his proceedings have been heard.  The Council opposed this, and applied for security for costs.  Ronald Young J declined to make an interim order, and ordered that Mr Easton provide security for costs in the amount of $12,000, on the basis that if he did not do so before 5 pm on Friday 23 October 2009, his proceedings would be struck out: HC WN CIV 2009-485-1438 14 September 2009.

[3]       Mr Easton has appealed against both decisions.  As the trial is scheduled for 28 October 2009, we heard the appeal as a matter of urgency.

Factual background

[4]       The Council has been considering the question of priority for bus traffic in the inner city.  In October 2008 Council officers made proposals to the Council’s Strategy and Policy Committee (SPC), whose membership is identical to that of the Council, concerning the “Golden Mile” bus route.  These proposals involved opening up Manners Mall to two-way bus traffic.  The SPC agreed that there should be consultation on the options.  Accordingly, during late 2008/early 2009 consultation was undertaken over the proposals.  Some 722 submissions were received, with 45 submitters wishing to be heard in person.  They were heard in late February 2009.  As part of this process AC Nielsen conducted a survey of 500 Wellington residents.  After that, there was further investigation and research, including the retaining of an independent consulting firm to undertake an evaluation of the options.  Officials then put the results to the SPC, together with some recommendations, in a document referred to as Report 4, dated 4 June 2009.

[5]       Report 4 contained 11 recommendations. For present purposes, four are relevant:

Officers recommend that the Committee:

...

6.Agree to opening up Manners Mall to two-way bus traffic and a request for a New Zealand Transport Agency subsidy for this project.

7.Note that Manners Mall was established…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Easton v Wellington City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NZCA 513
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Easton v Wellington City Council involves Mr. Benjamin Morland Easton, who has initiated judicial review proceedings against the Wellington City Council regarding a proposal to open Manners Mall, a pedestrian mall in Wellington, to bus traffic. The Council is currently in the process of statutory consultation before making a final decision on the proposal. Mr. Easton argues that the Council has predetermined its decision to proceed with the project, rendering the consultation process meaningless. He sought an interim order to halt further actions on the proposal until his proceedings were heard and applied for security for costs. The Wellington City Council opposed these applications, leading to the Court of Appeal reviewing the decisions made by Ronald Young J. Mr. Easton appealed both the refusal of an interim order and the requirement for security for costs, arguing that the Council had already made up its mind about the proposal, making any subsequent consultation futile.

The Court of Appeal found that the appeal against the refusal of the interim order should be dismissed. The Court reasoned that the application for the interim order was made under section 8 of the Judicature Amendment Act 1972, which allows the Court to make an order if it is necessary to preserve the applicant's position. The Court considered that Mr. Easton's case had little or no prospect of success, and no prejudice would occur before the trial date, which was set for 28 October 2009. Furthermore, the strength or weakness of Mr. Easton's case is relevant to the exercise of the section 8 discretion. The Court held that Ronald Young J was correct to refuse to make an interim order.

Regarding the security for costs, the Court of Appeal noted that the order for security for costs should be discretionary and based on the particular circumstances of the case. The Court found that Mr. Easton's case had little or no prospect of success and that he would not be deprived of a remedy if the proceedings did not continue. Once the consultation process was completed and the Council made a final decision, Mr. Easton would have a right of appeal to the Environment Court and potentially further review proceedings. The Court of Appeal varied the amount of security for costs from $12,000 to $8,000, while dismissing the appeal in all other respects. The Court made no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established