East Coast Aluminium Limited (in liquidation) v Perry

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND ROTORUA REGISTRY

CIV-2014-463-184 [2016] NZHC 2019

UNDER the Companies Act 1993

IN THE MATTER OF

the liquidation of East Coast Aluminium
Limited (In Liquidation)

BETWEEN

EAST COAST ALUMINIUM LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)

First Plaintiff

VIVIEN-JUDITH MADSEN-RIES AND HENRY DAVID LEVIN AS LIQUIDATORS OF EAST COAST ALUMINIUM LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)

Second Plaintiffs

AND

PATRICIA MERTLE PERRY First Defendant

DONALD GRAEME PERRY Second Defendant

ANTONY DAVID SANDFORD FLEMING

Third Defendant

Hearing: 26 August 2016

Appearances:

N Malarao and C P Eason for the Plaintiff
WJC Wynyard for the First and Second Defendants
No appearance for Third Defendant

Judgment:

26 August 2016

ORAL JUDGMENT OF MUIR J

Counsel/Solicitors:

N Malarao & C P Eason, Meredith Connell, Auckland

WJC Wynyard, Holland Beckett, Tauranga

EAST COAST ALUMINIUM LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) v PERRY [2016] NZHC 2019 [26 August 2016]

Introduction

[1]      In response to an application for formal proof by the plaintiffs, the first and second defendants apply for leave to file a statement of defence out of time.

[2]      They  have  now  filed  evidence  in  support  of  their  application  and  draft statements of defence.   Although this was not in compliance with orders made by Heath J, the first and second defendants have complied with subsequent orders made by me and paid the costs I ordered against them.

[3]      On receipt of such evidence the plaintiffs confirmed, in my view responsibly, that they did not oppose the application for leave, albeit that they sought terms, particularly as to wasted costs, which were not acceptable to the first and second defendants.

[4]      After the expression of some provisional views by me as to how I considered the matter best approached, the plaintiffs elected not to make submissions in opposition to the application to leave and invited consequential orders.

The application for leave

[5]      I am satisfied that this is a case where leave is appropriately granted.  I have reviewed the affidavits of the defendants and Mr Farrell.  They establish in my view the requisite substantial grounds of defence.   I am particularly influenced in that conclusion by the fact that on the second cause of action there is evidence that some part at least of the residential mortgage serviced by the company related to borrowings made with the specific purpose of the company’s recapitalisation.   It seems to me that if that is the factual position ultimately established, there are substantial grounds for suggesting that there was no breach of fiduciary duty by the directors servicing the loan from company funds.

[6]      In relation to other causes of action, the affidavits of Mr Farrell and the defendants present in my view responsible defence arguments.

[7]      As to whether the delays are adequately explained, this case has had  an unusual procedural history.  Because the third defendant filed a defence this resulted in standard case management procedures including the allocation of conferences from time to time.  The first and second defendants did not file a defence with the result that formal proof was sought against…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read East Coast Aluminium Limited (in liquidation) v Perry and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 2019
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of East Coast Aluminium Limited (In Liquidation) v Perry involves an application for leave to file a statement of defence out of time by Patricia Merle Perry and Donald Graeme Perry, the first and second defendants, against the plaintiffs, who are the liquidators of East Coast Aluminium Limited. The plaintiffs had applied for formal proof against the defendants, which led to the defendants applying for leave to file their defence late. The court was required to determine whether the defendants had substantial grounds for their defence, whether the delay in filing the defence was adequately explained, and whether granting leave would cause irreparable injury to the plaintiffs.

The court granted leave to the defendants to file their defence out of time. The court was satisfied that the defendants had substantial grounds for their defence based on the affidavits provided. The court found that the delay was adequately explained by the unusual procedural history of the case and the health issues faced by the second defendant. The court also found that granting leave would not cause irreparable injury to the plaintiffs, as they were protected by a caveat over the defendants' property and the property values were stable. The court granted leave on terms, including an order for the defendants to pay wasted costs of $6,690 and to file their defences by a specified date. The court also made several other orders, including an order for the defendants to undertake not to plead the Statute of Limitations in their defence and an order for the parties to complete discovery by a specified date.

In summary, the court granted leave to the defendants to file their defence out of time on terms, including an order for the defendants to pay wasted costs and to file their defences by a specified date. The court made several other orders to manage the proceedings, including an order for the defendants to undertake not to plead the Statute of Limitations in their defence and an order for the parties to complete discovery by a specified date.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established