Dean v Associate Minister of Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA615/2018
 [2019] NZCA 343

BETWEEN

FARISHA FARINA DEAN
Appellant

AND

ASSOCIATE MINISTER OF IMMIGRATION
Respondent

Hearing:

23 May 2019

Court:

Stevens, Duffy and Dobson JJ

Counsel:

R J Hooker and M G P Martin for Appellant
N Butler and T Witten-Sage for Respondent

Judgment:

30 July 2019 at 1.00 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe application for leave to adduce further evidence is declined.

BThe appeal is dismissed.

CThe appellant must pay the respondent costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Duffy J)

  1. Ms Dean is unlawfully in New Zealand and is subject to a deportation order.  She asked the Associate Minister of Immigration (the Associate Minister) to intervene and take steps that would allow a fresh consideration of her immigration status, but he declined to do so.  She then sought judicial review of the Associate Minister’s decision, but the proceeding was dismissed by Churchman J.[1]  She now appeals against that decision. 

  2. In support of her appeal Ms Dean sought leave to adduce fresh evidence in the form of newspaper articles of statements made by the Minister of Immigration.  However, when her appeal was heard she did not advance this application.  Accordingly, it is declined.  Even if the application were advanced, it would still have been declined, because we were satisfied the proposed evidence was not cogent.

Facts

  1. The essential facts are not in dispute.  Ms Dean is a Fijian national who arrived in New Zealand in January 2009 and was granted a visitor’s visa for one month.  She was subsequently granted a further visitor’s visa which expired in October 2009. 

  2. In April 2009 Ms Dean met Abdul Saleem Hussein and in July 2009 they commenced a de facto relationship.  He is also a Fijian national however he has New Zealand residence.  They entered into a relationship, which led Ms Dean to apply in October 2009 for a partnership-based work permit.  Her application was refused on 5 March 2010 because Immigration New Zealand (INZ) did not accept the couples’ assertion that they were in a genuine and stable de facto relationship.  Mr Hussein was already married and there was no evidence to establish the marriage was at an end.  INZ considered the couple were not in an exclusive relationship.  Ms Dean was granted a short-term visitor’s visa valid to 5 April 2010 to allow her to leave New Zealand lawfully.  She did not do so and has since remained in New Zealand.

  3. On 21 June 2011 Ms Dean was served with a deportation liability notice[2] and a deportation order.[3]  She then began a series of procedural steps under the Immigration Act 2009 (the Act) to avoid deportation.

    [2]Issued under s 154 of the Immigration Act 2009. 

    [3]Issued under s 175 of the Immigration Act.

  4. In 2012 and 2013 Ms Dean made requests…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dean v Associate Minister of Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZCA 343
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Dean v Associate Minister of Immigration involved the applicant, Ms Dean, challenging the Minister's decision regarding her application for residence under the Partnership Category. The dispute centred around the interpretation of the "absolute discretion" clause in the relevant Act and the impact of alleged errors in a briefing paper on the Minister's decision-making process. The case was heard in the relevant Australian court.

The primary legal issue was whether the alleged factual errors or omissions in the briefing paper led to an unreasonable decision by the Associate Minister. Ms Dean argued that these errors influenced the Minister's decision, making it unreasonable. The court had to determine if the alleged inaccuracies in the briefing paper had a material impact on the decision and whether the Minister's discretion was exercised unreasonably.

The court found that the alleged errors in the briefing paper did not exist on a proper reading. Even if they did, they did not have a material impact on the decision. The court held that absolute discretion effectively limits judicial review to Wednesbury unreasonableness, meaning there was no obligation for the Minister to provide reasons or consider the application. The court concluded that the decision was not unreasonable and dismissed Ms Dean's challenge.

No further orders were made by the court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Turning to the substance of the matter, s 172(5) provides that the Minister’s decision is one of absolute discretion. Section 11 of the Act defines “absolute discretion” as follows:11 Meaning of absolute discretion of the decision maker(1) If a provision of this Act provides that a matter or decision is in the absolute discretion of the decision maker concerned, it means that—(a) the matter or decision may not be applied for; and(b)if a person purports to apply for the matter or decision, there is no obligation on the decision maker to—(i) consider the purported application; or(ii)inquire into the circumstances of the person or any other person; or(iii)make any further inquiries in respect of any information provided by, or in respect of, the person or any other person; and(c) whether the purported application is considered or not,—(i)the decision maker is not obliged to give reasons for any decision relating to the purported application, other than the reason that this section applies; and(ia)privacy principle 6 (which relates to access to personal information and is set out in section 6 of the Privacy Act 1993) does not apply to any reasons for any decision relating to the purported application; and(ii) section 27 of this Act and section 23 of the Official Information Act 1982 do not apply in respect of the purported application.(2)Subsection (1)(c)(ia) applies to any decision made in relation to a purported application, whether the decision was made before or after the commencement of that subsection. This Court has said that “absolute discretion” effectively limits judicial review to Wednesbury unreasonableness.[13] This necessarily follows from the absence of specific statutory considerations or requirements to provide reasons to support the decision. Ms Dean contends there are four factual errors or omissions in the briefing paper, which have led the Associate Minister to make an unreasonable decision. We reject this. First, we do not consider the alleged errors or omissions can exist on a proper reading of the briefing paper. Secondly, even if we were persuaded to accept there were such errors we do not view them as having a material impact on the decision. They could not therefore have led the Associate Minister to make an unreasonable decision. The first factual error is said to arise from what Ms Dean contends is a misleading or inaccurate statement in the briefing paper:If Ms Dean and Ms Hussein are able to satisfy INZ that they are in a genuine and stable relationship, Ms Dean may have a pathway to residence under the Partnership Category. No point is taken about the misuse of a female title regarding Mr Hussein. The rest of the briefing paper and the other material correctly referred to him by the appropriate male title. Rather Ms Dean contends the above passage from the briefing paper suggested the couple’s relationship was yet to be established when in fact officer Treadaway had already decided it was a genuine and stable relationship[14].[14]The Associate Minister has admitted in his statement of defence that after officer Treadaway interviewed Ms Dean he confirmed to her that he had no concerns her relationship with Mr Hussein was genuine.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established