| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA |
| CA262/2020 CA374/2020 [2021] NZCA 228 |
| BETWEEN | LANCE DAVIS |
| AND | PLUMBERS, GASFITTERS AND DRAINLAYERS BOARD |
| Hearing: | 30 March 2021 |
Court: | French, Brown and Clifford JJ |
Counsel: | J W Maassen for Appellant |
Judgment: | 3 June 2021 at 10.30 am |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
AThe appeals against the judicial review and the costs decisions are dismissed.
B The appellant must pay the respondent costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Clifford J)
Introduction
The appellant, Lance Davis, is a registered plumber, gasfitter and drainlayer. The respondent, the Plumbers, Gasfitters and Drainlayers Board (the Board) is the registration and disciplinary body for those trades. The Board is established by the Plumbers, Gasfitters, and Drainlayers Act 2006 (the Act).
In July 2017 the Board received a complaint from a Mr Russ relating to work allegedly done by Mr Davis in 2010.
As part of the preliminary investigation of that complaint, Mr Davis was interviewed. At the conclusion of that interview Mr Davis signed a written record of the interview in which he is said to have admitted responsibility for the allegedly defective work.
Mr Davis subsequently challenged the lawfulness of that interview, and the admissibility of that signed written record, by way of judicial review proceedings in the High Court. That challenge was dismissed.[1] Mr Davis was subsequently ordered to pay costs to the Board.[2]
[1]Davis v Plumbers, Gasfitters and Drainlayers Board [2020] NZHC 782 [Judicial review decision].
[2]Davis v Plumbers, Gasfitters and Drainlayers Board [2020] NZHC 1523 [Costs decision].
Mr Davis now appeals both those decisions.
Background
In 2010 Mr Davis and his firm Star Plumbing Ltd carried out work associated with the installation of a hot water system (solar heating and a wetback) in a property Mr Russ owned. Mr Davis was contacted by Mr Russ in May 2017. The hot water system was not working properly. Mr Davis visited the property and inspected the work. Whilst Mr Davis could see the fault in the installation, he was of the view that it was not work for which he had been responsible. Following Mr Russ making the complaint Mr Davis, without admitting liability, fixed the problem at his own expense. That work was completed sometime in July 2018.
In the meantime, the Board responded to Mr Russ’s complaint against Mr Davis in accordance with the provisions of the Act.
Having satisfied itself the complaint was neither frivolous nor vexatious, the Board appointed an investigator, a Mr Thomas, to carry out a preliminary investigation.[3] Under the Act, the investigator’s task is to determine whether the complaint should be considered by the Board.[4]
[3]Plumbers, Gasfitters and Drainlayers Act 2006, s 91(1).
[4]Section 92(2)(a).
On 26 June 2018 a Mr Costelloe, who had been appointed to assist Mr Thomas, telephoned Mr Davis to discuss the complaint. Mr Costelloe visited Mr…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Davis v Plumbers, Gasfitters and Drainlayers Board and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] NZCA 228
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Davis argued that his signed written statement had been unlawfully obtained and hence inadmissible. The Board argued that Davis's challenge was premature and that any question of admissibility would properly be dealt with before the Board, on the assumption it investigated the complaint. The Court found that the investigator was not required to comply with the requirements of the Act before meeting with Davis and asking him to sign the note of the meeting. The appeal was dismissed. The Board argued that it had succeeded and that Davis should pay increased or indemnity costs. Davis argued that the Board had only had a partial success and that no weight should be put on the Board’s Calderbank offer. The Court found that the outcome of the judicial review proceeding did not represent any success on the legal points that were not adjudicated on.
The appeals against the judicial review and the costs decisions are dismissed. Davis must pay the respondent costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.
Background
Background to the litigation
Mr Davis first challenged the decision to investigate the complaint and lay charges in the District Court, but later withdrew the appeal and commenced judicial review proceedings in the High Court. The High Court dismissed the judicial review application, and Mr Davis appealed this decision. The appeal was heard in the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, which also dismissed the appeal. Mr Davis also appealed the costs decision, which was also dismissed by the Court of Appeal.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the statement signed by Mr Davis during the interview with Mr Costelloe was unlawfully obtained and therefore inadmissible.
2. Whether Mr Costelloe was lawfully delegated to conduct the investigation.
3. Whether there was a failure by Mr Costelloe to advise Mr Davis of his rights to obtain legal advice.
4. Whether the Board's decision to withdraw the initial charges and commence a fresh investigation represented a partial success for Mr Davis in the judicial review proceedings, entitling him to costs up to that point.
Held
1. The Court held that the statement signed by Mr Davis during the interview with Mr Costelloe was not unlawfully obtained and therefore admissible. The appeal against the judicial review decision was dismissed.
2. The Court held that Mr Costelloe was not lawfully delegated to conduct the investigation. However, this did not impact the admissibility of the statement or the outcome of the appeal against the judicial review decision.
3. The Court held that there was no failure by Mr Costelloe to advise Mr Davis of his rights to obtain legal advice. This was not a ground for the appeal against the judicial review decision to succeed.
4. The Court held that the Board's decision to withdraw the initial charges and commence a fresh investigation did not represent a partial success for Mr Davis in the judicial review proceedings, and therefore, he was not entitled to costs up to that point. The appeal against the costs decision was dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal considered the appeal against the judicial review and costs decisions made by the High Court. The central issue was whether the statement signed by Mr Davis during the interview with Mr Costelloe was lawfully obtained and admissible. The Court noted that under section 92(4)(b) of the Plumbers, Gasfitters and Drainlayers Act 2006, an investigator must provide the subject of a complaint with a reasonable opportunity to respond to allegations in writing before recommending to the Board to lay charges. The Court rejected the argument that this provision must be strictly complied with at every stage of the investigation. It found that the legislative scheme provided adequate procedural protections at various stages, including the opportunity for judicial review and appeal. Therefore, the Court concluded that the statement was lawfully obtained and admissible.
Regarding the delegation of Mr Costelloe to conduct the investigation, the Court accepted that he was not lawfully delegated. However, this did not affect the admissibility of the statement or the outcome of the appeal against the judicial review decision, as the Court found the statement was lawfully obtained.
The Court also dismissed the argument that there was a failure by Mr Costelloe to advise Mr Davis of his rights to obtain legal advice. It held that this did not impact the admissibility of the statement or the outcome of the appeal against the judicial review decision.
Finally, the Court addressed the issue of costs. It rejected Mr Davis's contention that the Board's decision to withdraw the initial charges and commence a fresh investigation represented a partial success entitling him to costs up to that point. The Court held that the outcome of the judicial review proceeding did not represent any success on the legal points that were not adjudicated on, and thus, the Board was entitled to scale costs as awarded by the High Court. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the statutory requirement to provide a reasonable opportunity to respond to allegations in writing must be interpreted in the context of the overall legislative scheme, which provides adequate procedural protections at various stages of the investigation process.