Concrete Structures (NZ) Limited v NZ Windfarms Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV 2008-409-002301 [2014] NZHC 2118

BETWEEN

CONCRETE STRUCTURES (NZ)

LIMITED Plaintiff

AND

NZ WINDFARMS LIMITED Defendant

Hearing: 21-24 July 2014

Counsel:

G P Blanchard for Plaintiff
J Smith QC and R G Smedley for Defendant

Judgment:

3 September 2014

JUDGMENT OF WHATA J

Introduction

[1]      Concrete  Structures  (NZ)  Limited  (CSL)  and  NZ  Windfarms  Limited  (NZ Windfarms) entered into a construction contract under which CSL was engaged to assist in the construction of a wind farm.   The wind farm was duly constructed, but there were several problems along the way.   CSL seeks to recover about $250,000 plus interest for variations that were not approved by NZ Windfarms’ engineer.  The critical issue before me therefore is whether or not the sought after variations should have been approved.

Background facts

[2]      In March 2006 CSL entered into a contract with NZ Windfarms to carry out civil engineering   and   construction   work   at   NZ   Windfarms’  Te   Rere   Hau   Windfarm Development, Palmerston North.  There were two key aspects of the contract namely to upgrade and maintain roads to enable access to the various tower locations and to construct

the bases for the towers.

CONCRETE STRUCTURES (NZ) LIMITED v NZ WINDFARMS LIMITED [2014] NZHC 2118 [3 September

2014]

The contract

[3]      The contract included the following particulars:

(a)       The contract was a measure and value contract that included a schedule of quantities and prices;

(b)The contract price was $832,218.30 including GST or such other or lesser sum shall become payable under the contract;

(c)       NZS 3910:2003 (“3910”) was incorporated into the contract as the general

conditions of contract except as where modified by the special conditions;

(d)Murray Fletcher was appointed by the defendant as the engineer to the contract;

(e)       Clause 5.11.3 of the contract contained provisions concerning the obtaining of licences and consents under the contract:

5.11.3  The Principal shall at the Principal’s expense obtain all licences,  which  may  be  required  for  the  construction  of  the Contract Works and for the use of the Contract Works when constructed except as otherwise provided for in 5.11.4.

(f)       Clause 5.11.6 of the contract provided that:

5.11.6  If licences, obtained by the Principal or by the Contractor are subject to conditions affecting the carrying out of the Contract Works, those conditions shall be notified to the other party and to the Engineer.   If the compliance with these conditions causes delay in the completion of the Contract Works or additional Cost to the Contractor which in either case the Contractor could not reasonably have foreseen when tendering the compliance will be treated as if it was a Variation.

(g)Clause 6.2.1 of the contract provided that the dual role of the engineer in the administration of the contract was:

i.         As an expert adviser to and representative of the defendant; and

ii.To independently of the contracting parties, fairly and impartially make decisions entrusted to him under the contract, to the value of the work and to issue certificates.

(h)Clause 6.7.1 of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Concrete Structures (NZ) Limited v NZ Windfarms Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 2118
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Concrete Structures (NZ) Limited v NZ Windfarms Limited, Concrete Structures (CSL) sued NZ Windfarms for a total of about $250,000 plus interest for variations that were not approved by the defendant's engineer. CSL entered into a contract with NZ Windfarms in March 2006 to carry out civil engineering and construction work at NZ Windfarms' Te Rere Hau Windfarm Development, Palmerston North. The contract included a schedule of quantities and prices, and the contract price was $832,218.30 including GST. CSL claims it made various progress payment claims concerning the above matters in the period March 2006 to February 2007. The main claim relates to winter work. CSL contends that there was unusually inclement weather in the period April 2006 to July 2006 affecting the way that CSL could carry out its contractual obligations. CSL says that it advised the engineer that it was impossible to perform the work due to the extraordinary inclement weather conditions and sought a suspension of the works. It claims that the engineer failed or refused to suspend the works, and instead issued variations to enable work to continue. The primary variation is said to be the relaxation of the compaction standard which then enabled CSL to work through winter instead of seeking an extension of time. Overall CSL submits that the duration of the earthworks was significantly extended and the earthworks were significantly disrupted due to NZ Windfarms' requirement for CSL to work through winter. The central factual issue was whether NZ Windfarms agreed to modify the works programme so that CSL could undertake the construction of the tower bases in March 2006. The court found that CSL did not have the requisite permission to commence the tower works and must bear the cost of the delay caused by the first suspension. In relation to the suspension of road works, the court found that the reason for the stoppage arose from NZ Windfarms' failure to respond to a Council letter. In relation to the further tower work delay, the court found that the primary and major reason for the stoppage was the failure to obtain building consent. The court found that the engineer was not required to approve a variation claim for the winter works. The court found that the contract apportioned the risk of inclement weather to CSL for the purpose of time extensions and claims based on unforeseen weather conditions. The court found that CSL bore the risk of inclement weather. The court found that contractual interest is payable on all proven claims. The court left it to the parties to resolve quantum and revert to the court if necessary within 15 working days. The parties have 15 working days to seek costs if they cannot be agreed. Submissions on costs must not be greater than five pages in length.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.