Concrete Structures (NZ) Limited v NZ Windfarms Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV 2008-409-002301 [2014] NZHC 2818

BETWEEN

CONCRETE STRUCTURES (NZ)

LIMITED Plaintiff

AND

NZ WINDFARMS LIMITED Defendant

Judgment:                13 November 2014

COSTS JUDGMENT OF WHATA J

[1]      Concrete Structures Limited (CSL) was successful in obtaining damages in respect of three of its five claims, resulting in a damages award of about $64,000 (inclusive of interest) for underpayment on a construction contract. However, it was unsuccessful in relation to its largest claim based on an alleged variation for winter

works.1

[2]      NZ Windfarms Limited (NZWF) seeks increased costs pursuant to sub-rules

14.6(3)(b)(ii) and (v).  The main reasons for increased costs are said to be that the plaintiff:

(a)       pursued arguments that lacked merit;

(b)did not  properly plead  its  claim  resulting in  wasted  work  in  trial preparation and intensive rework during trials; and

(c)       failed without reasonable justification to accept four separate offers of

settlement made under r 14.10 (“Calderbank offers”).

1      Concrete Structures (NZ) Limited v NZ Windfarms Limited [2014] NZHC 2118.

CONCRETE STRUCTURES (NZ) LIMITED v NZ WINDFARMS LIMITED [2014] NZHC 2818 [13

November 2014]

[3]      In response the plaintiff contends that: some of the items sought for cost compensation are not appropriate;2 an uplift is not justified on the basis that CSL has been successful in part of its claim and completely successful in relation to its contractual interest claim; and that CSL acted reasonably in pursuing its claim and rejecting the NZWF’s Calderbank offers.

Principles

[4]      The principles for cost considerations are well settled, first by part 14 of the High Court Rules and then by various authorities.3     I have a broad discretion to impose costs, but the primary principle is that costs follow the event.4    Particularly relevant to the present claim is r 14.6(3) dealing with increased costs and r 14.11(3) dealing with Calderbank offers.  Together they contemplate (among other things) an increased costs award against plaintiffs that take wasteful steps, pursue meritless

arguments and/or unreasonably fail to accept an offer to settle.

Argument

[5]      The defendant’s central contention is that the primary winter variation claim had no prospect of success, was not properly pleaded and the plaintiff unreasonably rejected “four generous and reasonable Calderbank offers”.5     The final two Calderbank offers made in June and July 2014 included an offer to settle all matters for $200,000.

[6]     The plaintiff maintains that the winter claim had merit, and it was not unreasonable for the plaintiff to pursue its claims, as evidenced by its success on

some of the claims, especially the claim relating to contractual interest.

2      These include additional costs for discovery of the second defendant’s list of documents; costs of a judicial settlement conference; costs of second counsel; disbursements for electronic support; and disbursements for Mr Fletcher (the engineer under the contract).

3      Glaister v Amalgamated Dairies Ltd [2004] 2 NZLR 606 (CA) at [24] and [28]; Holdfast NZ Ltd v Selleys Pty Ltd (2005) 17 PRNZ 897 (CA); Bradbury v Westpac Banking Corp [2009]

3 NZLR…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Concrete Structures (NZ) Limited v NZ Windfarms Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 2818
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Concrete Structures (NZ) Limited (CSL) initiated proceedings against NZ Windfarms Limited (NZWF) in the High Court of New Zealand, Christchurch Registry, seeking damages for underpayment on a construction contract. The dispute centred on CSL's claims for winterworks variation and underpayment, among other issues. CSL succeeded in three of its five claims, resulting in an award of approximately $64,000, inclusive of interest. However, it failed to succeed in its largest claim regarding the winterworks variation. NZWF subsequently applied for increased costs under the High Court Rules, arguing that CSL pursued arguments that lacked merit, did not properly plead its claim, and unreasonably rejected settlement offers.

The court considered the principles governing cost considerations, particularly those outlined in Part 14 of the High Court Rules and relevant authorities. The court recognised its broad discretion to impose costs, with the primary principle being that costs follow the event. Relevant rules included Rule 14.6(3), which deals with increased costs, and Rule 14.11(3), concerning Calderbank offers. The court noted that an increased costs award could be made against plaintiffs who take wasteful steps, pursue meritless arguments, and/or unreasonably fail to accept an offer to settle.

In assessing the application, the court found that NZWF's central contention that the primary winter variation claim had no prospect of success and was not properly pleaded, and that CSL unreasonably rejected four Calderbank offers, had merit. The court allowed an uplift of 25% on the costs from 4 June 2014, and approved two counsel given the complexity of the claims. The court rejected some of the specific cost items sought by NZWF, including disbursements for electronic support and attendances on the judicial settlement conference. The court also rejected the disbursement claim for Mr Fletcher, the engineer under the contract, as he was giving evidence as a primary actor, not as an expert.

The court granted leave to file submissions, not more than two pages in length, within ten working days, in the unlikely event that it is necessary. The remaining affidavit evidence was to be filed within five working days of the date of this judgment. The court otherwise did not anticipate that further recourse to the Court would be necessary for final quantification purposes.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.