Commissioner of Police v Evans

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV 2014-485-009652 [2015] NZHC 1240

IN THE MATTER

of an application pursuant to the Criminal

Proceeds (Recovery) Act 2009

BETWEEN

COMMISSIONER OF POLICE Applicant

AND

PETER WILLIAM EVANS Respondent

AND

CHAD WILLIAM EVANS First Interested Party

AND

CATHERINE MURA POIHIPI Second Interested Party

AND

ROBERTS CONSOLIDATED LIMITED Third Interested Party

AND

MARTIN ALLAN PINHEY Fourth Interested Party

Hearing: 20 and 28 May 2015

Counsel:

E M Light for Applicant
P H Surridge and A O'Connor (28 May only) for Respondent

Judgment:

4 June 2015

JUDGMENT OF BROWN J

COMMISSIONER OF POLICE v EVANS [2015] NZHC 1240 [4 June 2015]

[1]      On  29 September 2014  Collins J  made  restraining  orders  in  respect  of property comprising motor vehicles and several amounts of cash under the Criminal Proceeds (Recovery) Act 2009 (the Act).   The motor vehicles the subject of that order are:

(a)      A red 2012 Harley Davidson CVO Breakout motor cycle, registration HFFH1,  including  ignition  keys  registered  to  the  respondent  and under his effective control;

(b)A  gold  1970  Pontiac  GTO  motor  vehicle,  registration  7OGTO, including  ignition   keys   registered   to   the  first   interested   party (C W Evans) and under the effective control of the respondent;

(c)      A  black  2002  Holden  Monaro  GTO  motor  vehicle,  registration CSS945, including ignition keys registered to the second interested party (Poihipi) and under the effective control of the respondent;

(d)A  silver  1994  BMW  730i  motor  vehicle,  registration  ZR7030, including ignition keys registered to the respondent and under his effective control.

[2]      In the notice of application dated 28 July 2014 an order was also sought under s 35(e)(v) of the Act directing the Official Assignee to sell those vehicles in order to preserve their value.

[3]      The respondent  does  not  oppose the  application  in  respect  of  the  fourth vehicle.

[4]      In its submissions dated 14 May 2015 the applicant advised that he no longer pursued the application in respect of the second vehicle because he accepts the evidence advanced by the respondent that that vehicle appears to be relatively rare and the respondent has owned that vehicle for some time.

[5]      Consequently the present application relates only to the Harley Davidson motor cycle and the Holden Monaro GTO car.

The law

[6]      Section 35(e)(v) of the Act states:

35       Types of further order

Without limiting the generality of section 34(1), a court may, on an application under section 33(1), make 1 or more of the following further orders in relation to restrained property:

…

(e)       an order relating to the Official Assignee that–

…

(v)       directs   the   Official  Assignee   to   sell   restrained property (including, without limitation, a business) in order to preserve the value of the restrained property:

[7]      As   explained   in   Proceeds   of   Crime  Law   in   New Zealand   what   are colloquially called “immediate sale orders” are typically applied for by the Commissioner in relation to motor vehicles and houses, in the case of motor vehicles because they have a clear tendency to depreciate and cost money to store,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of Police v Evans and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 1240
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand considered an application by the Commissioner of Police under the Criminal Proceeds (Recovery) Act 2009, seeking orders for the sale of two motor vehicles restrained by a previous court order. The vehicles in question were a red 2012 Harley Davidson CVO Breakout motorcycle and a black 2002 Holden Monaro GTO car, both under the control of the respondent, Peter William Evans. The Commissioner argued that these vehicles were depreciating assets and that their sale would help preserve their value.

The legal issues before the court were whether the restrained vehicles were subject to significant depreciation, thus justifying an immediate sale, and whether such an order was appropriate under section 35(e)(v) of the Act. The court considered precedents indicating that sale orders are typically sought for assets like motor vehicles and houses due to their tendency to depreciate and the costs associated with their storage and maintenance. The Commissioner argued that the vehicles were wasting assets, while the respondent contended that the Holden car, in particular, was a rare and valuable model likely to appreciate in value.

The court examined evidence from both parties, including valuations and expert opinions on the market value and depreciation rates of the vehicles. The Commissioner presented evidence of the vehicles' declining value and the costs associated with their storage, while the respondent argued that the Holden car was a rare and valuable model. The court found that the Harley Davidson motorcycle was likely to continue decreasing in value and therefore ordered its sale to preserve its value. However, the court determined that the Holden car, due to its unique features and potential for appreciation, did not warrant an immediate sale order.

Ultimately, the court directed the Official Assignee to sell the Harley Davidson motorcycle but declined to order the sale of the Holden car. The decision highlighted the importance of preserving the value of restrained property while considering the specific circumstances and characteristics of each asset. The court's ruling balanced the need to protect the assets' value against the respondent's arguments regarding the unique value and potential appreciation of the Holden car.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established