IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
CIV-2014-404-1067 [2014] NZHC 2978
UNDER the Criminal Proceeds (Recovery) Act
2009
BETWEEN
COMMISSIONER OF POLICE Applicant
AND
MICHAEL JOSEPH CAVANAGH First Respondent
AND
VICTORIA LOUISE CAVANAGH Second Respondent
AND
LISA MARIE RYAN Third Respondent
AND
SHANNON KAY STEVENS Fourth Respondent
AND
DAVID GERALD O'CARROLL Fifth Respondent
AND
NIGEL JOHN BOWKER Sixth Respondent
Hearing: 26 November 2014 Appearances:
M R Harborow for Applicant
No appearance by G C Gotlieb for Sixth RespondentJudgment:
26 November 2014
ORAL JUDGMENT OF VENNING J
Solicitors: Crown Solicitor, Auckland
Neilsons Lawyers Ltd, Auckland
Copy to: G Gotlieb, Auckland
M Ryan, Auckland
I Koya, AucklandE Leary, Auckland
COMMISSIONER OF POLICE v CAVANAGH [2014] NZHC 2978 [26 November 2014]
[1] By way of applications, dated 15 May 2014 and 30 May 2014, the Commissioner of Police applied in respect of various property, particularly for present purposes a number of motor vehicles and a motor launch, for restraining orders and related orders, including orders directing the sale at fair market value with the Official Assignee to hold the proceeds of sale in accordance with the restraining orders.
[2] On 12 June and 24 May 2014 restraining orders were made over the property and on 3 July 2014 Lang J made sale orders in respect of eight vehicles comprising part of the property. On 3 July 2014 the Judge also set the matter down for all remaining issues to be determined at a single half day fixture to be held on 26
November 2014 at 11.45 am. The matter comes before the Court to resolve outstanding issues on that basis.
[3] There have been a number of affidavits filed in support of the Commissioner’s position, some directly relevant to the issue of restraint and some touching on the issue of sale. In considering the determination of the applications before the Court, particularly the application for sale of the identified property, I have taken into account the previous affidavits of Detective Latimer sworn on 5, 9,
12 and 29 May 2014, an affidavit of Detective Sergeant Sowter, an affidavit of Detective Latimer of 12 September 2014 in reply, and affidavits of Detective Lee and Detective Sergeant Sowter in reply sworn on 12 and 17 September 2014. In addition, for the purposes of the hearing this morning, Detective Latimer has filed a further affidavit in support of the application for sale orders.
[4] The application for sale orders follows the process of seizure of the vehicles and launch in question after the termination of a large scale police investigation known as Operation Genoa. During the course of the operation the police conducted covert surveillance and obtained mobile phone data for the respondents pursuant to production orders and search and surveillance device warrants. Following termination of the operation the police located an active clan lab in an enclosed trailer and one kilogram of methamphetamine and six kilograms of ephedrine. The police also located and seized substantial property assets including numerous
vehicles which…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of Police v Cavanagh and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] NZHC 2978
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court involved determining whether sale orders could be granted under Section 35(e)(v) of the Act to preserve the value of restrained property, given the high depreciation rates and additional costs associated with maintaining the seized assets. The court also needed to consider the impact of the sale on the potential return to the Commissioner and the benefit of holding the proceeds in an interest-bearing account. Additionally, the court had to address the informal request by Mr. Gotlieb, the solicitor for the Sixth Respondent, Nigel John Bowker, to adjourn the matter concerning the Harley motor bike.
The court found that sale orders could be appropriately made to preserve the value of the restrained property. The Commissioner's evidence demonstrated that the vehicles were depreciating assets, particularly with high depreciation rates applied by the Inland Revenue Department. The court rejected Mr. Gotlieb's request to adjourn the matter concerning the Harley motor bike, noting that Mr. Gotlieb had been informed of the correct hearing time and had failed to seek an adjournment properly. The court concluded that the sale of the seized property was necessary to prevent a loss of value and ordered the sale of the specified items, while noting that the issues of entitlement to the proceeds of sale would be determined during the forfeiture application following the conclusion of the criminal proceedings.
In summary, the court granted the Commissioner's application for sale orders over the seized property, emphasizing the necessity to preserve the value of the assets due to their high depreciation rates and storage costs. The court also declined the informal request to adjourn the matter concerning the Harley motor bike, ensuring that the sale order was made to prevent further loss of value.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi