Commissioner of Police v Dotcom

Link copied
Case Copied 61 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2012-404-33 [2012] NZHC 2190

IN THE MATTER OF     an application pursuant to the Criminal

Proceeds (Recovery) Act 2009

AND IN THE MATTER OF the Mutual Assistance in Criminal

Matters Act 1992

BETWEEN  THE COMMISSIONER OF POLICE Applicant

ANDKIM DOTCOM First Respondent

ANDBRAM VAN DER KOLK Second Respondent

ANDMEGASTUFF LIMITED Third Respondent

ANDMONA DOTCOM Interested Party

Hearing:         16 August 2012

Counsel:         A Toohey and R Hearn for the Applicant W Akel and R Gapes for First Respondent A Lloyd for Interested Party

Judgment:      29 August 2012

JUDGMENT OF POTTER J

on application by first respondent for variation

of restraining order

In accordance with r 11.5 High Court Rules

I direct the Registrar to endorse this judgment with a delivery time of 1 p.m. on 29 August 2012.

THE COMMISSIONER OF POLICE V KIM DOTCOM HC AK CIV-2012-404-33 [29 August 2012]

Solicitors:           Simpson Grierson, Auckland –  william.akel@simpsongrierson.com and robert.gapes@simpsongrierson.com

Crown Law Office, Wellington –  anne.toohey@crownlaw.govt.nz and richard.hearn@crownlaw.govt.nz

Minter Ellison Rudd Watts, Auckland –  aaron.lloyd@minterellison.co.nz

Copy to:            P Davison QC, Auckland  paul.davison@davison.co.nz

Table of Contents

Introduction  [1] Background [4] Court order dated 18 April 2012  [6] The application  [10] Mr Dotcom’s assets and liabilities  [12] Statutory framework  [19] Legal expenses  [26]

Submissions  [27] Issues  [29] Case law  [31] Application  [41] Section 28(3) of the CPRA  [49] Appointment of an independent

Queen’s Counsel  [54] Criteria  [61] Costs of supervising Queen’s Counsel  [62] Legal expenses of co-defendants  [63] Legal expenses of Mrs Dotcom  [73]

Provision for Mr Dotcom’s future legal expenses      [79]

Expenses relating to 186 Mahoenui Valley Road, Coatesville

The lease  [85] Lease variation  [91] Option deed  [93] Mr Dotcom’s application  [97] The Commissioner’s opposition  [99] Evaluation [103] Conclusions re property expenses  [125]

Other expenses

Rothken Law Firm  [128] Megastuff Limited creditors  [132] Diggory Brooke  [135] Tax  [136]

Sale of cars  [138] Summary of conclusions  [148] Orders  [149] Leave reserved  [150] Costs  [151]

Schedule 1 – Unrestrained assets of Mr Dotcom
Schedule 2 – Cars to be sold
Schedule 3 – Lawyers: Conduct and Client Care Rules

Introduction

[1]      By application dated 26 July 2012 the first respondent, Kim Dotcom (Mr

Dotcom) seeks:

(a)      An order varying the order for registration of the foreign restraining orders made on 18 April 2012 so as to exclude Mr Dotcom’s investment of $10m in New Zealand Government bonds from the properties and assets which are subject to that restraining order; and

(b)An order for the sale of motor vehicles subject to the restraining order except the seven vehicles listed in a schedule attached to the application.

Because of concerns about the market generally and the Official Assignee’s report dated 2 August 2012 filed as an attachment to the notice of opposition of the Commissioner of Police (the Commissioner)   this   application   was   varied   in   the   course   of submissions to seek an order for sale “on a gradual basis” of nine specified vehicles only (but not their number plates).

[2]      The Commissioner opposes the order sought under [1](a) on various…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of Police v Dotcom and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 2190
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, the Commissioner of Police brought an application against Kim Dotcom, who was under investigation for criminal copyright infringement and money laundering. The Commissioner sought the registration of two foreign restraining orders made in the United States in relation to Dotcom's assets in New Zealand. Dotcom opposed the application and sought various orders, including the release of $10m in New Zealand Government bonds from the restraining order to pay for his legal expenses, property expenses, and other debts. The Commissioner opposed the release of the funds, arguing that the expenses were excessive and evidentially deficient. The Court considered the statutory framework governing the registration of foreign restraining orders and the jurisdiction to impose conditions on and vary the restraining orders. The Court concluded that the omission of the word "reasonable" from the relevant provision did not exclude a reasonableness requirement, and that a reasonableness requirement should be read into the provision in the context of legal costs. The Court also considered the principles of natural justice, the right to access counsel of one's choice, and the importance of a professionally conducted defence in the adversarial criminal justice system. The Court appointed an independent Queen's Counsel to review the fees and disbursements charged to Dotcom and to report the result of his or her assessment to the Official Assignee, Dotcom, and the Commissioner. The Court also ordered the sale of nine motor vehicles listed by Dotcom on a gradual basis in accordance with a marketing strategy to be developed to achieve the best prices reasonably available for the vehicles and the most cost-effective basis for sale.