Commerce Commission v Lodge Real Estate Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2015-404-003045 [2016] NZHC 1494

UNDER

Sections 27, 30 and 80 of the Commerce

Act 1986

BETWEEN

COMMERCE COMMISSION Plaintiff

AND

LODGE REAL ESTATE LIMITED First Defendant

LUGTON'S LIMITED Second Defendant

MONARCH REAL ESTATE LIMITED Third Defendant

ONLINE REALTY LIMITED Fourth Defendant

SUCCESS REALTY LIMITED Fifth Defendant

BRIAN KING Sixth Defendant

JEREMY O'ROURKE Seventh Defendant

Hearing: 10 June 2016

Appearances:

J C L Dixon and L C A Farmer for Plaintiff
T D Smith and R M Dixon for Defendant

Judgment:

1 July 2016

JUDGMENT OF COURTNEY J

This judgment was delivered by Justice Courtney

on1 July 2016 at 4.00 pm pursuant to R 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar / Deputy Registrar

Date……………………….

COMMERCE COMMISSION v LODGE REAL ESTATE LTD & ORS [2016] NZHC 1494 [1 July 2016]

Introduction

[1]      Success Realty Limited  is a real estate agency trading under the Bayley brand.1   It operates in the Hamilton region, as do four of the other defendants in this proceeding (Lodge Real Estate Limited, Lugton’s Limited, Monarch Real Estate Limited and Online Realty Limited).  These companies are the five largest real estate agents in the Hamilton region.   Of them, Success is the smallest, holding approximately five per cent of the residential real estate market in that area.

[2]      Success has admitted conduct that constitutes a breach of s 27, via s 30, of the Commerce Act  1986.    The  conduct  related  to  an  anti-competitive  price  fixing agreement with the four other real estate agents.  The Commission and Success have agreed to recommend to the Court that a penalty of $900,000 would be appropriate to be imposed in respect of the conduct and the Commission asks the Court to make a  declaration  as  to  the  contravening  conduct  and  to  impose  the  recommended penalty.

The anti-competitive conduct

[3]      The price fixing agreement related to the use of the Trade Me website for advertising real estate listings.  The defendants in this case all used Trade Me for this purpose.  Prior to 2013 Trade Me charged a standard capped fee per office per month for an unlimited number of standard listings, though some agencies had negotiated better rates.  Bayleys Realty Group (BRG) had negotiated a preferential rate of $799 (plus  GST)  per  month  with Trade  Me  for  members  of  the  Bayleys  Group  and Success adopted that rate.  Under the subscription pricing model operated by Trade Me and the preferential rate negotiated by BRG, Success typically passed on a charge of $30 plus GST to vendors for each standard Trade Me listing.

[4]      In mid-2013 Trade Me signalled a change to its pricing model.   In early September 2013 members of the New Zealand Realtors Network (NZRN), which included the managing director of Lodge, Mr O’Rourke, attended a meeting at which

Trade   Me’s   proposed   new   pricing   regime   was   discussed.      Subsequently,

1      Success is a franchisee of Bayley Realty Group Limited (BRG), which is wholly owned by

Bayley Corporation Limited.

Mr O’Rourke contacted representatives of various Hamilton real estate…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commerce Commission v Lodge Real Estate Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 1494
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Commerce Commission brought proceedings against Success Realty Limited and five other real estate agencies for contravening s 27 of the Commerce Act 1986. This provision prohibits anti-competitive conduct. Success, which holds a small share of the real estate market in Hamilton, admitted that it had entered into and given effect to an agreement with the other agencies to remove their residential property listings from the Trade Me website and to charge their vendors the full Trade Me per-listing fee. The Commission and Success agreed that a penalty of $900,000 would be appropriate and asked the Court to make a declaration of contravention and to impose that penalty.

The Court considered the starting point for the penalty, which is based on the nature and seriousness of the conduct, the deliberateness of the conduct, the duration of the conduct, the seniority of the employees or officers involved, the extent of any benefit derived, the extent of any loss or damage suffered, the market share/degree of market power held by the defendant, the defendant’s role in the impugned conduct and the size and resources of the defendant. The Court found that the conduct was serious, deliberate and at a senior level in the company. It accepted that the duration was relatively short but found that the agreement had a residual effect in changing the status quo in the market. The Court found that there was potential commercial gain and harm caused to vendors. The Court considered the case of Unique Realty Limited, which was factually similar, and determined that the appropriate starting point for the penalty was between $1.4m – $1.7m. The Court found that a 45 per cent discount was appropriate given the mitigating factors of no previous contravening conduct, early cooperation with the Commission and an early admission of liability. The final penalty of $900,000 was within the range the Court had determined and was appropriate.

The Court made a declaration that Success’ conduct contravened s 27, via s 30, of the Commerce Act 1986 and imposed the recommended penalty of $900,000. By consent, costs were to lie where they fell.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.