Commerce Commission v Kuehne + Nagel International AG

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

AUCKLAND REGISTRY

COMMERCIAL LIST

CIV-2010-404-005479

[2014] NZHC 705

UNDER Sections 27, 30 and 80 of the Commerce
Act 1986
BETWEEN COMMERCE COMMISSION
Plaintiff
AND KUEHNE + NAGEL INTERNATIONAL
AG
Defendant
Hearing:  4 April 2014
Appearances:  N F Flanagan and F Cuncannon for Plaintiff
I Thain and C Stacey for Defendant
Introduction 

[1]        Following an investigation the Commerce Commission (the Commission)

commenced proceedings against a number of freight forwarders, including Kuehne +

Nagel International AG (KNI) for breaches of the Commerce Act 1986 (the Act). In

its third amended statement of claim the Commission alleges KNI participated in

anti-competitive agreements with a number of other freight forwarders in relation to

various fees imposed on their customers.

[2]        KNI has filed a notice of admission that records it admits:

(a) that it contravened s 27(2) via s 30 of the Act by giving effect to what

is known as the UK NES agreement (sixth cause of action); and

(b) that it contravened s 27(2) of the Act by giving effect to the UK NES

agreement (eighth cause of action).

[3]        The parties have reached the position that if the Court approves the proposed

penalty for those breaches the Commission will discontinue the remaining causes of

action against KNI relating to other surcharges. A similar approach has been taken

by the Commission and approved by the Court in relation to each of the other

defendants to this litigation.

Background

[4]        KNI is incorporated in Switzerland. It is the ultimate parent of the other

companies in the Kuehne + Nagel Group (KN Group). The KN Group is a global

provider of freight forwarding services. It has over a thousand offices worldwide

(including New Zealand) and approximately 63,000 employees. KNI is the sole

shareholder of the New Zealand entity Kuehne + Nagel Ltd (KN NZ). KN NZ

carries on business in New Zealand as part of the KN Group. The KN Group is one

of the largest freight forwarding groups operating in New Zealand. It has a

significant market presence in both air and sea freight.

[5]        The international air freight industry involves all facets of the logistical

arrangements for the movement of goods by air from origin to destination. It

facilitates the efficient transportation of cargo to and from New Zealand. In 2009 the

freight forwarding industry processed 0.18 million tonnes of cargo into and out of

New Zealand generating revenue of approximately NZD$600 million.

[6]        Importers and exporters are the source of demand for freight forwarding

services. The quality and cost of freight forwarding services impacts throughout the

New Zealand economy.

[7]        Freight forwarders compete with each other to provide services to exporters

and importers. Freight forwarding rates are typically expressed as a price per

kilogram in the currency at the point of origin. The price is structured as:

(a) a flat rate per kilogram; or
(b) a flat rate per kilogram plus various surcharges and/or origin and

destination charges and/or third party costs; or

(c)
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commerce Commission v Kuehne + Nagel International AG and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 705
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the High Court of New Zealand involves the Commerce Commission prosecuting Kuehne + Nagel International AG (KNI) for breaching the Commerce Act 1986. KNI, a major player in the freight forwarding industry, admitted to participating in anti-competitive agreements with other freight forwarders that imposed fees on customers, specifically the UK NES agreement. The Commission alleged that KNI and other companies formed a covert cartel, the "Gardening Club," to set fees for security measures imposed by the UK's HM Customs and Excise. The Court had to decide the appropriate penalty for these breaches, with both parties proposing a specific penalty amount contingent upon the Court's approval.

The legal issues centered on determining the appropriate penalty for the breaches of the Commerce Act. This involved calculating the maximum penalty under the statute, establishing a starting point for the penalty considering the need for deterrence, and adjusting the starting point based on specific mitigating factors. The court had to balance the objectives of deterrence and specific deterrence with mitigating factors such as KNI's admission of guilt and its compliance efforts post-investigation.

In its reasoning, the Court first established the maximum penalty for each breach as $10 million, given the unquantifiable commercial gain and KNI's turnover. It then set the starting point for the penalty at $3.5 to $4 million, considering the nature and seriousness of the contravening conduct, the importance of the market affected, and the seniority of the employee involved. The Court noted the conduct was a sustained, covert cartel agreement that operated for five years, significantly impacting the market. After considering mitigating factors such as KNI's early admission and its global compliance program, the Court accepted a 20% discount on the starting penalty point. Consequently, the Court ordered KNI to pay a penalty of $3.1 million and contribute $100,000 towards the Commission's costs.