Clear White Investments Ltd v Otis Trustee Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2016-404-2504 [2016] NZHC 2837

BETWEEN

CLEAR WHITE INVESTMENTS

LIMITED Plaintiff

AND

OTIS TRUSTEE LIMITED Defendant

On thepapers:

Appearances:

D J Chisholm QC for the Plaintiff
D W Grove for the Defendant

Judgment:

28 November 2016

SECURITY FOR COSTS JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE R M BELL

This judgment was delivered by me on  28 November 2016  at 3:00pm

pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

…………………………………………………….

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:

Carson Fox Bradley Ltd, Parnell, Auckland, for Plaintiff

Ewart & Ewart, Epsom, Auckland, for Defendant

Copy for:

David J Chisholm QC, Auckland, for Plaintiff

Daniel W Grove, Auckland, for Defendant

CLEAR WHITE INVESTMENTS LIMITED v OTIS TRUSTEE LIMITED [2016] NZHC 2837 [28 November

2016]

[1]      Otis Trustee Ltd applies for security for costs under r 5.45 of the High Court

Rules.

[2]      This is the second proceeding between the parties.  In CIV-2016-404-2295, Clear White Investments Ltd applied under s 145A of the Land Transfer Act 1952 to sustain a caveat lodged against the title to the property at 40 Te Kauwhata Road, Te Kauwhata.  In this proceeding it seeks substantive relief in terms of the caveat plus related orders.

[3]      I heard the caveat application on 15 November 2016.  At that hearing I gave case management directions for this proceeding.   The close of pleadings date is

30 January 2017.  It is to be heard for three days beginning 3 April 2017.  I gave directions for the parties to file submissions on security for costs.   I have used evidence filed in the caveat proceeding.  I am deciding the application on the papers. I set out the background facts in the caveat decision at [1]-[9] and [15]-[39].1

[4]      Clear White accepts that under r 5.45(1)(b) there is reason to believe that it will be unable to pay the costs of Otis Trustee Ltd if it is unsuccessful at trial.   I agree, given my findings as to its insolvency at [9] in my caveat decision.  A finding that one of the grounds under r 5.45(1) has been satisfied does not mean that security is ordered automatically.  Under r 5.45(2), the court has a discretion:  “if the Judge thinks it is just in all the circumstances”.  The court balances competing interests: the  defendant’s  interest  in  being  protected  from  a  barren  costs  order  and  the plaintiff’s right of access to the court.

[5]      In assessing the merits of the case, I have the advantage of having read the evidence and heard argument in the caveat application.   I assessed the claim to a caveatable interest in light of the causes of action in the statement of claim in this proceeding:   constructive trust, estoppel, and relief under Part 5 of the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act 2003.  I held that Clear White did not have a

caveatable interest in the property, because I considered that at the hearing of this

1      Clear White Investments Ltd v Otis Trustee Ltd [2016] NZHC 2823 at [1]-[9]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clear White Investments Ltd v Otis Trustee Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 2837
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Clear White Investments Limited sought relief against Otis Trustee Limited in a proceeding concerning the title to a property at 40 Te Kauwhata Road, Te Kauwhata. Otis Trustee Limited applied for security for costs under rule 5.45 of the High Court Rules, claiming Clear White Investments Limited would likely be unable to pay the costs if it was unsuccessful at trial. This was the second proceeding between the parties, with the first being a caveat application by Clear White Investments Limited. The Associate Judge, R M Bell, assessed the merits of the case based on the evidence and arguments heard in the caveat application, focusing on the constructive trust, estoppel, and relief under the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act 2003 claims.

The Associate Judge determined that Clear White Investments Limited had a triable case for monetary relief, but it was unlikely to obtain the return of the title to the property. Otis Trustee Limited was entitled to be protected against a barren order for costs due to Clear White Investments Limited's insolvency and the pending sentencing of its director. The Associate Judge fixed the security for costs at $16,000, offering some protection to Otis Trustee Limited while not setting too high a bar for Clear White Investments Limited's access to the court. If the security for costs was not paid by the close of the pleadings date (30 January 2017), the proceeding would be stayed pending payment.

There was no order for costs as the parties had divided success on the security for costs application. Clear White Investments Limited was directed to file and serve any amended statement of claim by 16 December 2016, and any statement of defence to that statement of claim was to be filed and served by 30 January 2017.