Casata Limited v Minister for Land Information

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE

CIV-2020-485-000492

[2022] NZHC 243

UNDER the Land Valuation Proceedings Act 1948

IN THE MATTER OF

a claim for compensation pursuant to the Public Works Act 1981

BETWEEN

CASATA LIMITED

Appellant

AND

MINISTER FOR LAND INFORMATION

Respondent

Hearing:

12–13 October 2021

[Further joint memorandum received 15 February 2022]

Appearances:

J E Hodder QC and L M Lincoln for Appellant M J Bryant and K F Gaskell for Respondent

Judgment:

22 February 2022


JUDGMENT OF EDWARDS J


This judgment was delivered by me on 22 February 2022 at 12.00 pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Counsel:     J E Hodder, Wellington

Solicitors:    Bell Gully, Wellington

Crown Law, Wellington

CASATA LTD v MINISTER FOR LAND INFORMATION [2022] NZHC 243 [22 February 2022]

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Relevant facts  [5]

No 27  [18]
No 7  [28]

The Tribunal decision  [33]

Approach to appeal  [43]
Casata’s claim and measure of loss  [46]

Did the shadow prevent Casata from either selling or redeveloping its land? [66]

No 7  [66]

No 27  [74]

Did Casata suffer the reinvestment loss claimed?  [80]

Does the claim fall within s 60(1)(c) of the PWA?  [85]
Does the claim fall within s 66 of the PWA?  [109]

Result  [124]

[1]    The appellant (Casata) says that a shadow cast by the announcement of a public works project impaired its ownership rights in respect of two properties owned in Pito- One Road, Petone (referred to as No 7 and No 27). Both properties were required under the Public Works Act 1981 (PWA) for the Petone-Grenada Link Road between the Hutt Valley and Porirua (the Project).

[2]    Casata claims compensation in the sum of approximately $4.2 million for losses it says were sustained in the shadow period. The shadow period commenced with the announcement of the Project on 13 February 2014 and ended with the settlement of the purchases of No 27 and No 7 on 28 February 2017 and 27 March 2017 and respectively. The losses are claimed in addition to the sums of $5,665,000 for No 27 and $990,000 for No 7 paid by the Crown for the market value of the land.

[3]    The loss claimed by Casata has been calculated using a hypothetical reinvestment model. The model assumes that Casata was able to sell its properties as at February 2014 and then four months later reinvest the proceeds of sale, together with borrowed monies, into a new property from which it would receive rental income and capital appreciation.

[4]    The Land Valuation Tribunal (Tribunal) rejected Casata’s claim on the basis that there was no evidence that that shadow interfered with Casata’s ability to deal with its properties, and no evidence to support the hypothetical investment model used to assess loss. Casata now appeals.

Relevant facts

[5]    Casata’s core business is commercial property investment. It has a focus on owning land subject to long term ground leases…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Casata Limited v Minister for Land Information and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZHC 243
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, Casata Limited sought compensation from the Minister for Land Information under the Public Works Act 1981 (PWA) for losses it claimed to have suffered due to the shadow cast by the announcement of a public works project. The appeal was dismissed. The court found that Casata had not proven that the shadow prevented it from either selling or redeveloping its land as claimed, and that there was insufficient evidence to substantiate Casata's hypothetical reinvestment model used to assess its loss. The court also found that Casata's claim did not fall within s 60(1)(c) of the PWA, as it could not prove that the shadow caused it tangible loss, and that its claim could not fall within s 66 of the PWA as its losses were intertwined with the value of the land. The court held that any compensation to be paid under s 60(1)(c) is for actual damage sustained, and in the absence of such evidence, an assessment of whether the claim would otherwise have fallen within s 60(1)(c) cannot be made. The appeal was dismissed, and the respondent was entitled to costs.