Carolan v NZ Real Estate Credit Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2014-404-000483 [2017] NZHC 156

BETWEEN

MICHAEL JOSEPH CHRISTIAN

CAROLAN Plaintiff

AND

NZ REAL ESTATE CREDIT LIMITED First Defendant /

First Counterclaim Plaintiff

GEORGE KERR Second Defendant

Defendants continued over

Hearing: 8 February 2017

Counsel:

No Appearance by the Plaintiff (attendance excused) J K Goodall and E D R Offner for the Defendants

M A Corlett QC for the Non-Party Applicant

Judgment:

14 February 2017

JUDGMENT OF EDWARDS J

This judgment was delivered by Justice Edwards on 14 February 2017 at 4.00 pm, pursuant to

r 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar
Date:

Counsel:     M A Corlett QC, Auckland

J K Goodall, Auckland

Solicitors:    Lee Salmon Long, Auckland

Lowndes Jordan, Auckland

CAROLAN v NZ REAL ESTATE CREDIT LTD [2017] NZHC 156 [14 February 2017]

EQUITY PARTNERS CAPITAL MARKETS LIMITED

Third Defendant /
Second Counterclaim Plaintiff

EQUITY PARTNERS LIMITED Fourth Defendant /

Third Counterclaim Plaintiff

EQUITY PARTNERS ASSET MANAGEMENT LIMITED Fifth Defendant /

Fourth Counterclaim Plaintiff

CLAYMORE FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED

Sixth Defendant /
Fifth Counterclaim Plaintiff

Introduction

[1]      A  non-party,  Millinium  Asset  Services  Pty  Ltd  (Millinium),  requests permission to access the Court file to obtain information which it says is relevant to proceedings in the Cayman Islands. The defendants oppose the request.

The request

[2]      Millinium is an acting trustee of the Bear Real Opportunities Fund (Bear), although its formal status as trustee is disputed by the defendants and is currently the subject of separate proceedings in Australia.  Bear is a partner in Torchlight Fund LP (Torchlight), an exempted limited partnership domiciled in the Cayman Islands.

[3]      The general partner of the partnership is Torchlight GP Ltd (General Partner) which is wholly owned by Pyne Gould Corporation Ltd (PGC), a listed company on the  New  Zealand  Stock  Exchange.    The  second  defendant  in  this  proceeding, Mr George Kerr, is the managing director and majority shareholder of PGC.

[4]      A   number   of   partners   in   Torchlight   have   filed   a   petition   in   the Cayman Islands seeking to wind up the partnership on the grounds that they have lost trust and confidence in the General Partner and Mr Kerr.  The petitioners include Aurora Funds Management Ltd as trustee for Bear, Crown Asset Management Ltd and the Accident Corporation of New Zealand.  The trial of the winding up petition is due to commence on 20 February 2017.

[5]      A related proceeding has been commenced by the General Partner against Millinium and those partners who have filed the petition, alleging conspiracy by unlawful means to quit the partnership.

[6]      Millinium filed its request for access to the Court file by letter dated 15 July

2016.  At the time of the request, the trial of this proceeding had taken place, but the judgment had not yet been delivered.1    Although Millinium was not aware of the

nature  of  the  dispute  at  issue  in  the  proceeding  at  that  stage,  it  nevertheless

1      Fogarty J delivered judgment on 29 July 2016 in Carolan v New Zealand Real Estate Credit Ltd

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carolan v NZ Real Estate Credit Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 156
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Carolan v NZ Real Estate Credit Limited, the court was called upon to determine whether Millinium Asset Services Pty Ltd, a non-party to the proceedings, could access the Court file to obtain information relevant to proceedings in the Cayman Islands. The defendants opposed the request, arguing that the information on the Court file was irrelevant to the matters in issue in the Cayman Islands litigation and that granting access would circumvent the discovery process already in place there.

The court considered the application under the rules governing access to court files and found that while there was a presumption of access, this did not apply once an objection was made. The court had a broad discretion to determine opposed requests, taking into account the factors outlined in the rules, including the orderly and fair administration of justice, the protection of confidentiality, and the principle of open justice.

The court found that the purpose of the request was essentially private in nature, as the information was sought to assist with private litigation overseas. While the purpose was legitimate, the reasons for the request were not particularly compelling. The relevance of the material on the Court file to the issues in the winding up proceeding was far from clear, and the court found that questions of relevance were properly the domain of the Grand Court of the Cayman Islands.

The court also found that the discovery process in the Cayman Islands provided a process by which the rights and interests of all parties could be protected, and that granting access in this case would effectively circumvent those orders and undermine the protections afforded by the discovery process. For these reasons, the request for access to the Court file was declined.

The court's decision highlights the importance of considering the factors outlined in the rules when determining requests for access to court files, and the need to balance the principle of open justice with other considerations, such as the protection of confidential information and the orderly and fair administration of justice. The decision also underscores the importance of pursuing disclosure through the appropriate forum, where questions of relevance, the protection of confidential information, and the enforcement of disclosure obligations can be properly addressed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established