Carolan v NZ Real Estate Credit Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2015-404-000483

[2017] NZHC 630

BETWEEN MICHAEL JOSEPH CHRISTIAN CAROLAN
Plaintiff

AND

NZ REAL ESTATE CREDIT LIMITED

First Defendant/
First Counterclaim Plaintiff

GEORGE KERR
Second Defendant

Defendants continued over

Hearing: [On the Papers]

Counsel:

No Appearance of, or for the Plaintiff

J K Goodall and E D R Offner for the Defendants M A Corlett QC for the Non-Party Applicant

Judgment:

4 April 2017


JUDGMENT OF EDWARDS J

[re Costs]


This judgment was delivered by Justice Edwards on 4 April 2017 at 11.30 am, pursuant to

r 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date:

CAROLAN v NZ REAL ESTATE CREDIT LTD [2017] NZHC 630 [4 April 2017]

EQUITY PARTNERS CAPITAL MARKETS LIMITED

Third Defendant/
Second Counterclaim Plaintiff

EQUITY PARTNERS LIMITED
Fourth Defendant/
Third Counterclaim Plaintiff

EQUITY PARTNERS ASSET MANAGEMENTS LIMITED

Fifth Defendant/
Fourth Counterclaim Plaintiff

CLAYMORE FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED

Sixth Defendant/
Fifth Counterclaim Plaintiff

Introduction

[1]                 The respondents successfully opposed an application by a non-party (Millinium) for access to the Court file.1 They now seek costs in the sum of $12,097 plus disbursements. That sum is calculated on a schedule 2B basis with the exception of costs for the opposition to the application which are calculated on a schedule 2C basis.

[2]                 Millinium accepts that an award of costs on a 2B basis is appropriate, but it disputes the respondents’ calculations and submits that costs in the sum of $2,502.67 should be awarded instead.

Categorisation

[3]                 The parties are agreed that the application was of average complexity and accordingly category 2B is appropriate for most of the steps in the proceeding. However, the respondents seek costs on a 2C basis for preparing the opposition to the application on the grounds that a 2B categorisation does not accurately reflect the time and cost involved for that step.

[4]                 Although the application for access was made informally, I consider it appropriate to calculate scale costs as if the request was an interlocutory application. Treating the respondents’ memorandum dated 30 August 2016 as the respondents’ notice of opposition is a fair reflection of the reasonable costs incurred for that step.

[5]                 However, whilst I accept that preparing the opposition involved considerable time and effort in liaising with overseas counsel and Torchlight representatives, I do not consider that a 2C categorisation for that step is warranted.

[6]                 The second respondent was intimately involved in the Cayman Islands proceedings and was able to provide instructions accordingly. Furthermore, the status of Millinium as a trustee of the Bear Real Opportunities Fund was not an issue of


1      Carolan v NZ Real Estate Credit Ltd [2017] NZHC 156.

central importance to the respondents’ opposition to access, and nor did it feature as a factor in declining the request.

Written submissions

[7]                 The respondents claim for the memorandum of 2 February 2017, and also claim costs for the preparation of written submissions, despite the fact that no written submissions were filed and served.

[8]                 The two memoranda…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carolan v NZ Real Estate Credit Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 630
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Auckland Registry, the case of Carolan v NZ Real Estate Credit Limited involved a dispute where Michael Joseph Christian Carolan sought costs from the defendants, including NZ Real Estate Credit Limited and several other defendants. The case was heard on the papers, with no appearance by the plaintiff. The primary legal issue before the court was the calculation of costs incurred by the respondents in opposing an application by a non-party (Millinium) for access to the court file. The respondents sought costs in the sum of $12,097 plus disbursements, calculated on a schedule 2B basis, except for the costs related to opposing the application, which were calculated on a schedule 2C basis. Millinium disputed the respondents' calculations and argued for a lower amount of $2,502.67.

The court considered the nature and complexity of the application, agreeing that the proceedings were of average complexity, thus categorising most steps under schedule 2B. However, the court found that preparing the opposition to the application involved significant time and effort, justifying a 2C categorisation for that step. Despite this, the court ruled that a 2C categorisation for the opposition was not warranted, as the status of Millinium as a trustee was not central to the opposition. The court also addressed various aspects of the respondents' written submissions, the appearance before the judge, and the engagement of second counsel. Ultimately, the court awarded the respondents costs totaling $7,191 and disbursements of $249.67, finding that the respondents' calculations were largely appropriate but required some adjustments.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established