Capital + Merchant Finance Ltd v Perpetual Trust Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2012-404-4602 [2015] NZHC 1233

BETWEEN

CAPITAL + MERCHANT FINANCE

LTD Plaintiff

AND

PERPETUAL TRUST LTD Defendant

CIV-2012-404-7534

BETWEEN  CAPITAL + MERCHANT FINANCE LTD

Plaintiff

ANDSTACE HAMMOND Defendant

Hearing: 13 April 2015

Counsel:

M D Arthur and L Fraser for Plaintiff
D J Cooper and J Standage for Perpetual Trust Ltd
P J Napier for Stace Hammond

Judgment:

4 June 2015

JUDGMENT OF KATZ J [Application for further discovery]

This judgment was delivered by me on 4 June 2015 at 4:00pm

Pursuant to Rule 11.5 High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:           Chapman Tripp, Auckland

Bell Gully, Auckland

Keegan Alexander, Auckland

CAPITAL + MERCHANT FINANCE LTD v PERPETUAL TRUST LTD [2015] NZHC 1233 [4 June 2015]

Introduction

[1]      The plaintiff, Capital + Merchant Finance Ltd (“CMF”) formerly operated as a finance company.  It is now in receivership and liquidation.  With the benefit of a litigation funding arrangement, it issued proceedings against its former trustee, Perpetual Trust Ltd (“Perpetual”) and its former solicitors, Stace Hammond, alleging breach of contract and negligence.

[2]      The hearing of CMF’s claims was due to commence on 25 September 2014. As is often the case, settlement negotiations took place in the week leading up to trial.  The defendants say that those negotiations resulted in a conditional settlement agreement.   CMF disputes that, and says that no settlement was reached.   In the circumstances, the trial was adjourned.  The issue of whether or not the proceedings have conditionally settled has been set down for hearing in September 2015.

[3]      The parties have now  served  their  briefs of  evidence on  the  conditional settlement  issue.  CMF  has  served  briefs  of  evidence  from  Bruce  Stewart  QC, Michael Stiassny and Neil Jackson.   Mr Stewart was formerly CMF’s counsel and represented it in the settlement negotiations.  Messrs Stiassny and Jackson are both from KordaMentha, CMF’s receivers.  Campbell Walker, who was then counsel for Perpetual, represented the defendants in the settlement negotiations.

[4]     The parties have each provided discovery of documents relating to the conditional   settlement   issue.  The   defendants,   however,   believe   that   CMF’s discovery is incomplete.   They say that CMF is not entitled to claim privilege in documents relating to settlement, because it has referred extensively to privileged communications (primarily telephone calls and meetings) regarding settlement in its briefs of evidence.  CMF is therefore said to have waived privilege in relation to all settlement  documentation  during  the  period  18  to  24  September  2014.  The defendants also claim that CMF has improperly redacted certain names from two of the emails it has discovered.

[5]      CMF says that it has provided full and complete discovery of all relevant documents and has not waived privilege.   Further, if the contents of its briefs of evidence do potentially give rise to any waiver of privilege, it says that such waiver

would only occur when the relevant witnesses give evidence in court, not when CMF’s briefs are served.   In relation to the redacted emails, CMF says they were appropriately redacted, for reasons of relevance.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Capital + Merchant Finance Ltd v Perpetual Trust Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 1233
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Katz J considered an application for further discovery by Perpetual Trust Ltd and Stace Hammond against Capital + Merchant Finance Ltd (CMF) in relation to a conditional settlement agreement. The defendants argued that CMF had waived privilege in certain documents relating to settlement negotiations by disclosing privileged communications in its briefs of evidence. They also contended that CMF improperly redacted certain names from two emails it had discovered. CMF disputed both claims, asserting that it had provided full and complete discovery and that the redactions were justified.

The court first addressed whether CMF had waived privilege in relation to certain documents by disclosing privileged communications in its briefs of evidence. Katz J found that while CMF’s briefs did refer to privileged communications, this did not necessarily result in a waiver of privilege. The court held that a waiver of privilege would only occur when the relevant witnesses gave evidence in court, not when CMF’s briefs were served. Katz J concluded that no injustice would arise if CMF was given an opportunity to amend its briefs prior to trial.

Secondly, the court considered the scope of any potential waiver of privilege. Katz J held that CMF was required to provide discovery of any documents relating to the specific communications referred to in its briefs, but not of all documents relating to settlement during the relevant period. The court applied the principle of collateral waiver, requiring disclosure of any further privileged material relevant to the issues in question to avoid any risk of selective disclosure.

Finally, the court examined whether CMF was entitled to redact certain names from two emails it had discovered. Katz J found that the redactions were unjustified, as the names of the parties to relevant communications were generally not collateral matters that could be redacted for irrelevance. The court ordered CMF to provide unredacted copies of the two emails in question.

In conclusion, Katz J directed CMF to provide further discovery of certain documents relating to the settlement negotiations, or to amend its briefs of evidence by a specified date. CMF was also ordered to provide unredacted copies of two emails it had discovered.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established