Capital Construction Limited v Prime Commercial Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2013-485-000879 [2013] NZHC 1941

UNDER  the Companies Act 1993

IN THE MATTER OF       the liquidation of Prime Commercial

Limited

BETWEEN  CAPITAL CONSTRUCTION LIMITED Plaintiff

ANDPRIME COMMERCIAL LIMITED Defendant

Hearing:                   31 July 2013

Counsel:                  A G Hazelton for Plaintiff

K B Johnston for Defendant

Judgment:                5 August 2013

JUDGMENT OF COLLINS J

Introduction

[1]      The question I have to answer is:

Should Capital Construction Ltd (Capital) be restrained from taking further steps to have Prime Commercial Ltd (Prime) placed into liquidation?

[2]      This question raises the following sub-questions:

(1)Can Prime rely on a counterclaim or set-off1 to prevent Capital from taking further steps to have Prime placed into liquidation?

1      A counterclaim usually arises out of a claim that is separate from the debt.  A set-off generally arises out of the same transaction as the debt:  Brookers Insolvency Law and Practice (online looseleaf ed, Thomson Reuters) at [CA290.04].

CAPITAL CONSTRUCTION LIMITED v PRIME COMMERCIAL LIMITED [2013] NZHC 1941 [5 August

2013]

(2)       Should I restrain Capital from continuing with proceeding to place

Prime into liquidation because:

(a)       Prime says there is a genuine dispute as to whether it owes the money claimed by Capital;  and/or

(b)allowing Capital to proceed with its application to have Prime placed into liquidation is oppressive or unfair.

Context

[3]      Prime was incorporated in June 1997.   Its director is Mr Garnham, who is also a trustee of a shareholder of Prime.

[4]      Prime is a commercial property company and the owner of a 15-storey office, car park and residential building in Customhouse Quay called Craig Investment Partners  House  (the  building).    In  December  2012  the  building  was  valued  at

$17.45 million.

[5]      Capital  is  a  construction  company.    Its  directors  are  Mr  Wickens  and

Mr Witkowski.

[6]      For approximately 12 years Prime and associated companies have engaged Capital to undertake building and renovation work.  In February 2010 Prime engaged Capital to undertake earthquake strengthening, reinstatement and refurbishing works in  the  building.    This  agreement  was  not  recorded  in  writing.    It  is  accepted, however, that Capital would render invoices to Prime calculated on the basis of invoices received by Capital from subcontractors and Capital’s margin.

[7]      From 28 February 2010 to 28 February 2013 Capital rendered invoices to

Prime  that  totalled  $1,442,933.50.    By  18  April  2013  Prime  had  paid  Capital

$960,227.32.  Since 1 April 2013 Capital has sent a further four invoices to Prime totalling $32,337.14.

[8]      On  10  February 2013  Capital  gave  Prime  notice  that  it  was  suspending further work on the building.2

[9]      On 18 April 2013 Capital issued a statutory demand under s  289 of the Companies Act 1993 in which it sought immediate payment of $482,720.67 being the difference between the total amount of the invoices rendered by Capital to Prime up until 28 February 2013 and the amount paid by Prime to Capital by 18 April

2013.  Prime did not pay Capital any of the sum specified in the statutory demand until 26 July 2013.

[10]     On…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Capital Construction Limited v Prime Commercial Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 1941
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Capital Construction Limited brought proceedings to have Prime Commercial Limited placed into liquidation. Prime filed a defence and counterclaim and sought orders to stay the proceedings and prevent Capital from advertising the proceedings. The court had to determine if Prime could rely on a counterclaim or set-off to prevent Capital from continuing with its liquidation proceedings, and if there were other grounds to stay the proceedings. The court held that Prime could not rely on a counterclaim or set-off at that stage in the liquidation process. Prime had also failed to establish a genuine dispute over the debt or that the proceedings were oppressive or unfair. Prime's conduct was considered to be a classic example of the type of commercial behaviour that motivated Parliament to pass the Construction Contracts Act 2002. Prime should pay now and argue later if it believed it had a legitimate dispute. The court refused to stay the liquidation proceedings. Costs were to follow the event and be awarded to Capital on a scale 2B basis.