Butch Pet Foods Ltd v Mac Motors Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA137/2018
 [2018] NZCA 276

BETWEEN

BUTCH PET FOODS LIMITED
Applicant

AND

MAC MOTORS LIMITED
Respondent

Hearing:

11 June 2018

Court:

Winkelmann, Clifford and Williams JJ

Counsel:

P T Finnigan for Applicant
M Wilkinson as director of Respondent

Judgment:

27 July 2018 at 4 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe application for leave to bring a second appeal is declined.

BThere is no order for costs.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Clifford J)

Introduction

  1. This is an application for leave to bring a second appeal.

Background

  1. Butch Pet Foods Ltd uses Hino trucks in its business.  Mac Motors Ltd repaired one of Butch’s Hino trucks.  Some three months later, that truck broke down again.  Butch said that breakdown was caused by Mac’s faulty repair work.  Butch sued Mac for some $32,500 in the District Court.  Butch failed.[1]  Butch appealed to the High Court, and (largely) failed again.[2]  Butch applied to that Court for leave to bring a second appeal to this Court.  That application was declined.[3]

  2. Butch now applies to this Court for leave to bring a second appeal.  Mac opposes. 

Second appeals — the law

  1. The test for leave to bring a second appeal to this Court is well established.  The proposed appeal must raise some question of law or fact capable of bona fide and serious argument, in a case involving some interest, public or private, of sufficient importance to outweigh the cost and delay of the further appeal.[4]  On a second appeal this Court is not engaged in the general correction of error.  Its primary function is to clarify the law and to determine whether it has been properly construed and applied by the Court below.  It is not every alleged error of law that is of such importance, either generally or to the parties, as to justify further pursuit of litigation which has already been twice considered and ruled upon by a court.[5]

Submissions

  1. Butch says those tests are satisfied here: the question of law involved is the way in which judges must determine conflicts of evidence between experts. 

  2. In the District Court, Butch’s experts said the breakdown was caused by the way in which Mac negligently failed to properly tighten a series of bolts forming part of the flywheel housing: the bolts had subsequently come loose, which in turn caused the flywheel and clutch housing to fail. 

  3. Mac’s experts said the cause of the flywheel and clutch assembly failing was the way a Butch employee had driven the Hino truck, regularly “stall stopping”.  Driving that way had, over…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Butch Pet Foods Ltd v Mac Motors Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZCA 276
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Butch Pet Foods Limited, the applicant, sought leave to bring a second appeal against the decision of the High Court which dismissed Butch’s appeal against the District Court’s decision. Butch had sued Mac Motors Limited for $32,500 in the District Court, alleging that a faulty repair of a Hino truck caused a breakdown some three months later. Butch failed in the District Court and on appeal to the High Court. Mac Motors opposed the application for leave to bring a second appeal to the Court of Appeal.

The question was whether the application met the test for leave to bring a second appeal, which is that the proposed appeal must raise some question of law or fact capable of bona fide and serious argument, in a case involving some interest, public or private, of sufficient importance to outweigh the cost and delay of the further appeal. The Court found that the question of law involved was the way in which judges must determine conflicts of evidence between experts. The Judge had provided a very careful assessment of the evidence of the experts, and the Court found that the Judge had given extensive reasons for preferring the respondent’s witnesses over Butch’s experts, which fulfilled her obligation to resolve that conflict of expert evidence. Butch’s appeal failed.

The Court found that there were other important reasons why a second appeal was not appropriate. The amount involved was relatively small, and the parties had already had an extensive factual inquiry before the District Court. Further inquiry into this essentially factual dispute would not be an appropriate use of this Court’s time and resources.

The application for leave to bring a second appeal was declined, and there was no order for costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Butch Pet Foods Ltd is a company that uses Hino trucks in its business operations. Mac Motors Ltd, a respondent in this case, repaired one of Butch’s Hino trucks. Approximately three months after the repair, the truck broke down again. Butch Pet Foods Ltd attributed the breakdown to Mac Motors Ltd’s faulty repair work and sued Mac for $32,500 in the District Court. Butch Pet Foods Ltd was unsuccessful in the District Court. Butch appealed the decision to the High Court, where they largely remained unsuccessful. Butch then applied to the High Court for leave to bring a second appeal to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, which was declined. Butch Pet Foods Ltd now applies to the Court of Appeal for leave to bring a second appeal, which Mac Motors Ltd opposes.

This case involves an application for leave to bring a second appeal. Butch Pet Foods Ltd, the applicant, was unsuccessful in its first appeal to the High Court. The applicant had previously appealed to the District Court, which ruled against Butch Pet Foods Ltd. The Court of Appeal of New Zealand now considers the applicant's application for leave to bring a second appeal. Mac Motors Ltd, the respondent, opposes the application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is there a question of law or fact capable of bona fide and serious argument in this case?
2. Did the Judge fail to provide adequate and cogent reasons to support the strong adverse credibility findings made against Butch Pet Foods Ltd's experts?
3. Did the Judge fail to coherently reason why one set of witnesses should be preferred to the other set of witnesses?
4. Did the Judge fail to appropriately deal with the evidence of Mr Cress that driver-abuse would not cause adequately tightened flywheel bolts to loosen and unwind?

Held
1. The application for leave to bring a second appeal is declined.
2. There is no order for costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal declined Butch Pet Foods Ltd's application for leave to bring a second appeal against the decision of the High Court. The Court found that the proposed appeal did not raise a question of law or fact capable of bona fide and serious argument, in a case involving some interest, public or private, of sufficient importance to outweigh the cost and delay of the further appeal. The Court noted that its primary function on a second appeal is to clarify the law and to determine whether it has been properly construed and applied by the Court below. The Court found that the Judge had provided adequate and cogent reasons to support the strong adverse credibility findings made against Butch Pet Foods Ltd's experts, and had coherently reasoned why one set of witnesses should be preferred to the other set of witnesses. The Court also found that the Judge had appropriately dealt with the evidence of Mr Cress that driver-abuse would not cause adequately tightened flywheel bolts to loosen and unwind. The Court held that the amount involved was relatively small and that further inquiry into this essentially factual dispute would not be an appropriate use of the Court's time and resources.

In relation to the first and third grounds of appeal, the Court found that the Judge had provided extensive reasons for preferring the respondent's witnesses over Messrs Barton and Wilcox, which fulfilled her obligation to resolve that conflict of expert evidence. The Court noted that the Judge was not required to engage directly with the technical aspects of the difference in the experts' evidence, and that her reasons for preferring certain experts' evidence over others were well explained in her judgment.

In relation to the second ground of appeal, the Court found that the Judge had engaged with and explained why she did not accept Mr Cress' evidence. The Court found that Dr Smith had given reasons for disagreeing with Mr Cress' assessment, and that the Judge had accepted Dr Smith's evidence.

The Court held that there were other important reasons why this was not a matter appropriate for a second appeal. The Court noted that the parties had already had an extensive factual inquiry before the District Court and that further inquiry into this essentially factual dispute would not be an appropriate use of the Court's time and resources.