Burden v Debonaire Furniture Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2014-485-11179

[2017] NZHC 1553

UNDER the Copyright Act 1994 and the Fair Trading Act 1986

IN THE MATTER

of infringement of copyright and breach of the Fair Trading Act 1986

BETWEEN

IAN JAMES BURDEN

First Plaintiff

PLANTATION GROWN TIMBERS (INTERNATIONAL) LIMITED

Second Plaintiff

PLANTATION GROWN TIMBERS (VIETNAM) LIMITED

Third Plaintiff

AND

DEBONAIRE FURNITURE LIMITED

First Defendant

BURDEN FURNITURE
(INTERNATIONAL) LIMITED
Second Defendant

BURDEN FURNITURE CO LIMITED
Third Defendant

LINDSAY JOHN BURDEN
Fourth Defendant

JEREMY DAVID SMITH
Fifth Defendant

ROBERT WAYNE SMITH

Sixth Defendant

Hearing: 21 June 2017

Counsel:

G Hazel and J R Wach for Plaintiffs

G F Arthur for First, Fifth and Sixth Defendants

BURDEN v DEBONAIRE FURNITURE LIMITED [2017] NZHC 1553 [6 July 2017]

Judgment: 6 July 2017

JUDGMENT OF THOMAS J


Introduction

[1]    The  plaintiffs  allege  furniture  imported  by  the  first   defendant   into  New Zealand infringes copyright owned by the plaintiffs and constitutes a breach of the Fair Trading Act 1986. The first, fifth and sixth defendants deny the claim and counterclaim against the plaintiffs. The second, third and fourth defendants deny the claim, but do not appear to be taking any steps in the proceeding at this stage.1

[2]    The first, fifth and sixth defendants have applied for two witnesses to give evidence by audio-visual link (AVL). Affidavits in support of the application from the two witnesses have been filed. The plaintiffs oppose the application and have filed affidavits in support of that opposition.

Application

[3]    The application concerns two witnesses, Edwin Elting and Craig Morrow. Both witnesses have signed briefs of evidence which have been served on the plaintiffs. The application is on the basis the evidence is essential for a fair proceeding to enable the defendants to present their defence.

[4]    Mr Elting resides in Kentucky, United States of America. Mr Morrow spends most of his time in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam. It is proposed the witnesses give evidence by AVL and the defendants say they will ensure the technology will provide a high-quality transmission. They propose a protocol to cover the requirements and practical arrangements for the giving of evidence by AVL.

[5]    The defendants say evidence by AVL is now routine and does not adversely affect the ability to assess the credibility of witnesses or the reliability of the evidence.


1      By a Minute of 15 December 2014, Brown J noted the one page documents which purport to be statements of defence by the second, third and fourth defendants do not provide an address for service. It is unclear whether this omission has been rectified.

[6]    The plaintiffs say the balance of convenience does not favour the witnesses giving their evidence by AVL and neither witness has given good reason for absence from New Zealand for the trial. The plaintiffs maintain the inconvenience suffered by the witnesses would be modest.

[7]    Furthermore, the plaintiffs question the credibility of the witnesses, saying Mr Morrow has attempted to interfere with and disrupt evidence processes…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Burden v Debonaire Furniture Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 1553
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Burden v Debonaire Furniture Ltd concerns allegations of copyright infringement and breach of the Fair Trading Act 1986, with the plaintiffs, Ian James Burden and others, claiming that furniture imported by Debonaire Furniture Limited infringes their copyright and breaches the Fair Trading Act. The defendants, including Debonaire Furniture Limited, deny the allegations and have counterclaimed against the plaintiffs. The second, third, and fourth defendants deny the claim but do not appear to be taking active steps in the proceeding. The first, fifth, and sixth defendants applied for two witnesses, Edwin Elting and Craig Morrow, to give evidence via audio-visual link (AVL) from the United States and Vietnam respectively. The plaintiffs opposed the application, arguing that the balance of convenience did not favour AVL and questioning the credibility of the witnesses.

The court considered several issues, including the nature of the proceeding, the availability and quality of technology, the potential impact of AVL on the assessment of credibility, the availability of sanctions for perjury, and the views of the witnesses. The court found that the evidence of Elting and Morrow was critical to the defendants' case, and their absence would likely result in the loss of important evidence. The court noted that AVL was now a routine and accepted feature of litigation, and there was no indication of technical problems. The court also found that the credibility of the witnesses could still be assessed despite the use of AVL, and the lack of sanctions for perjury in Vietnam did not materially alter the position.

The court concluded that it was appropriate for both witnesses to give evidence by AVL, taking into account the fairness of the proceeding, the views of the witnesses, and their ability to assess the credibility of the evidence. The court granted the application and directed that the draft protocol for the use of AVL should apply, subject to certain conditions.

The final orders included granting the application for the witnesses to give evidence by AVL, directing the inclusion of specific conditions in the protocol, and addressing any issues as to costs within a specified timeframe.