| For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link |
| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND |
| CA244/2014 [2014] NZCA 571 |
| BETWEEN | BRIDGECORP LIMITED (IN RECEIVERSHIP AND IN LIQUIDATION) |
| AND | CERTAIN LLOYD’S UNDERWRITERS UNDER POLICY NO B0701LS05809 |
| Hearing: | 8 October 2014 |
Court: | Harrison, French and Goddard JJ |
Counsel: | M J Tingey and W D Hofer for Appellant |
Judgment: | 27 November 2014 at 3.30 pm |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
AThe appeal is dismissed.
BThe appellant is ordered to pay the respondent costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis together with usual disbursements.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Harrison J)
Introduction
Section 9 of the Law Reform Act 1936 introduced a significant statutory modification of contractual rights of indemnity and of priorities on insolvency by allowing a third party to claim a charge against insurance moneys payable by an insurer to an insured but insolvent party. On this appeal the question is whether a New Zealand court has jurisdiction to determine a New Zealand company’s application for an order under s 9 charging moneys payable under a policy issued by London underwriters.
Facts
Bridgecorp was a New Zealand finance company which raised funds from the public. The company in turn loaned moneys to various property development entities. Bridgecorp failed in 2008 owing large sums of money. Through its New Zealand broker, Herbert Insurance Group Limited (HIGL), the company had arranged insurance against losses suffered on realisation of securities given by borrowers over various properties. Its insurers have declined liability on Bridgecorp’s claims for indemnity on a number of grounds.
Bridgecorp’s receivers have since issued a proceeding against the insurers in the High Court at Auckland and joined HIGL as well, alleging that, if the insurers’ defences are upheld, the broker is liable for breach of its professional duties to arrange suitable insurance.
HIGL, which is itself now in liquidation, has entered into a policy of professional indemnity insurance against its liability for breaches of duty with a syndicate of Lloyd’s Underwriters in London. MSI Corporate Capital Ltd is the syndicate’s only member. The policy’s terms are the centrepiece of Mr Tingey’s argument on appeal for Bridgecorp and we shall return more fully to them. It is sufficient to note now that, in reliance principally on the facts of HIGL’s insolvency and the existence and terms of its policy, Bridgecorp has applied for leave under s 9 to charge the proceeds against the contingency that its claim against HIGL succeeds.
HIGL’s underwriters (which we will refer to as the Underwriters) filed an appearance under protest to the Court’s jurisdiction to hear Bridgecorp’s proceeding on the ground that s 9 does not have extraterritorial effect. In reliance on the Supreme Court’s decision in Ludgater Holdings Ltd v Gerling Australia Insurance Co Pty Ltd,[1] Gilbert J dismissed Bridgecorp’s application to set aside Underwriters’ protest.[2] He was satisfied that any debt payable by HIGL’s insurers under…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Bridgecorp Ltd (in rec and liq) v Certain Lloyd's Underwrite... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] NZCA 571
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues the court was required to decide were whether section 9 has extraterritorial application, and if the New Zealand courts had subject matter jurisdiction over any debt payable by underwriters under a policy. The court found that section 9 does not have extraterritorial effect, and that the jurisdiction of New Zealand courts will not be conferred if the debt is situated outside New Zealand. The court held that the situs of the debt is determined by the residence of the debtor, and in this case, the Lloyd’s syndicate resides in London. The court rejected Bridgecorp’s argument that the policy’s provisions for payment of the amount insured in New Zealand and the governing law of New Zealand courts should determine the situs of the debt.
The court concluded that the appeal was dismissed, and Bridgecorp was ordered to pay the respondents’ costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis together with usual disbursements. The court found that there was no risk of conflict with an actual or likely determination of a court in another country, as the risk of conflict arises whenever one sovereign state trespasses upon the authority of another by exercising its own authority to make an order relating to property in a foreign state. The court held that the principle against extraterritoriality is absolute and cannot apply in some cases but not others, or mandate an inquiry into the risk of conflict on a case by case basis.
Background
Background to the litigation
Bridgecorp's application to set aside the Underwriters' protest was dismissed by the High Court. Bridgecorp appealed this decision to the Court of Appeal.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does Section 9 of the Law Reform Act 1936 have extraterritorial effect?
2. If Section 9 does not have extraterritorial effect, what determines whether a New Zealand court has subject matter jurisdiction over a debt payable by an insurer under a policy?
3. Does the fact that the insured party is a New Zealand company and its liquidation is in New Zealand mean that Section 9 applies in this case?
Held
1. The court held that Section 9 of the Law Reform Act 1936 does not have extraterritorial effect.
2. The court held that a New Zealand court has subject matter jurisdiction over a debt payable by an insurer under a policy if the debt is situated in New Zealand, which is where the debtor resides.
3. The court held that the fact that the insured party is a New Zealand company and its liquidation is in New Zealand does not mean that Section 9 applies in this case because the insurer resides in London.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by noting that Section 9 of the Law Reform Act 1936 creates a statutory charge on insurance moneys payable by an insurer to an insured party who has entered into a contract of insurance. The court emphasized that the statutory charge attaches to the debt itself, which is enforceable by an action or claim against the insurer. The court further clarified that Section 9 does not have extraterritorial effect, and therefore, a New Zealand court cannot adjudicate on a direct claim against an insurer located outside New Zealand.
To determine whether a New Zealand court has subject matter jurisdiction over a debt payable by an insurer, the court looked to the situs or situation of the debt, which is typically where the debtor resides. In this case, the insurer resides in London, and therefore, the debt is situated in England. The court rejected the argument that the policy's provision for payment of the amount insured in New Zealand could establish the situs of the debt in New Zealand. The court held that the place of payment is only relevant to the situation of the debt where the debtor has multiple places of business, which was not the case here.
The court also rejected the argument that the fact that the insured party is a New Zealand company and its liquidation is in New Zealand means that Section 9 applies in this case. The court held that if Section 9 does not have extraterritorial effect, it does not form part of the New Zealand insolvency regime, and therefore, the ordinary pari passu rule applies. The court concluded that Bridgecorp has no entitlement to override the ordinary pari passu rule to secure a prior claim to the insurance moneys ahead of HIGL's other creditors.
In summary, the court held that Section 9 of the Law Reform Act 1936 does not have extraterritorial effect, and therefore, a New Zealand court cannot adjudicate on a direct claim against an insurer located outside New Zealand. The situs or situation of the debt is where the debtor resides, and in this case, the insurer resides in London, and therefore, the debt is situated in England. The fact that the insured party is a New Zealand company and its liquidation is in New Zealand does not mean that Section 9 applies in this case because the insurer resides in London.