Body Corporate S73368 v Otway

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND TAURANGA REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TAURANGA MOANA ROHE

CIV-2015-470-000146

[2018] NZHC 1095

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE S73368

Plaintiff

AND

ROSALIND KAY OTWAY (NOW ROSALIND KAY WRIGHT) AND OLPHERT SANDFORD TRUSTEE SERVICE COMPANY LIMITED

First Defendant

PHILLIP HERBERT DORR, SHARON LESLEY DORR AND DONALD RAYMOND PILBROW

Second Defendant

Hearing: On the papers

Counsel:

S Price, I Stephenson and J Scoberg-Evans for Plaintiff G Brittain QC and J Delaney for Defendants

Judgment:

17 May 2018


JUDGMENT OF WOOLFORD J


This judgment was delivered by me on Thursday, 17 May 2018 at 4:45 pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Counsel:            G Brittain QC, Tauranga

Solicitors:           Minter, Ellison, Rudd & Watts, Solicitors, Auckland

BODY CORPORATE S73368 v OTWAY [2018] NZHC 1095 [17 May 2018]

Introduction

[1]    A tower block in Mt Maunganui suffered damage because of water ingress. The body corporate sought to recover repair costs from two first-floor apartment owners. In my judgment of 20 December 2017, I ordered each defendant to pay

$44,344.75 to the body corporate as their share of expenses incurred in the joinery work undertaken in their apartments.1 The body corporate had sought a significantly larger award.

[2]    I also granted the declaration the body corporate sought, namely, that the location of the legal boundaries between unit floors at the property was the top of the concrete floor slab of that unit.

[3]Each party now seeks costs.

The claims for costs

[4]    The body corporate seeks costs on the basis it succeeded against the defendants. It acknowledges, however, its success was partial and makes a 50 per cent reduction to its costs claim to reflect that. It seeks:

(a)Costs of $31,220.00. This comprises scale costs of $62,440.00 on a 2B basis with a 50 per cent reduction.

(b)Expert disbursements of $47,914.39. This comprises $110,488.32 less expert disbursements that relate to causes of action that did not succeed and a 33 per cent reduction to all other disbursements, to reflect partial success.

(c)Procedural disbursements of $17,350.00.

[5]    The defendants acknowledge the body corporate achieved some success. They say, however, they are entitled to costs, primarily because the body corporate failed to


1      Body Corporate S73368 v Otway [2017] NZHC 3265.

accept settlement offers without reasonable justification. The defendants seek costs and disbursements as follows:

(a)Costs of $83,638,38. This comprises scale costs of $62,886.00 on a 2B basis increased by 33 per cent because of the body corporate’s failure to accept settlement offers.

(b)$220.00 for filing fees.

[6]    This judgment addresses three key issues. First, I address the effect of the body corporate’s partial success (or failure) on its costs claim. Second, I determine the effect, if any, of the settlement offers. Third, I turn to disbursements.

Effect of partial success on costs claim

[7]    Rule 14.1 of the High Court Rules 2016 provides costs matters are at the discretion of the court. Rule 14.2(1) sets out general principles that apply to the determination of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate S73368 v Otway and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZHC 1095
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Body Corporate S73368 initiated legal action against the first-floor apartment owners, Rosalind Kay Otway and Olphert Sandford Trustee Service Company Limited, to recover repair costs for water ingress damage in a tower block in Mt Maunganui. The body corporate also sought a declaration regarding the legal boundaries between unit floors at the property. The case was heard in the High Court of New Zealand Tauranga Registry, with the judgment delivered on 17 May 2018. The court ordered each defendant to pay $44,344.75 as their share of expenses incurred in the joinery work undertaken in their apartments. The body corporate had sought a significantly larger award. The court also granted the declaration sought by the body corporate, establishing that the location of the legal boundaries between unit floors at the property was the top of the concrete floor slab of that unit.

The court addressed three key issues in the case. Firstly, the effect of the body corporate's partial success (or failure) on its costs claim was considered. The court determined that the body corporate was entitled to scale costs on a 2B basis for steps taken in the proceeding until 7 August 2017, with a 50 per cent reduction to reflect its partial success. Secondly, the effect of the settlement offers made during the proceedings was examined. The court found that the defendants were entitled to scale costs on a 2B basis for steps taken in the proceeding after 7 August 2017. Thirdly, the court turned to disbursements and determined that the body corporate was entitled to disbursements incurred before 7 August 2017, with certain adjustments, while the defendants were entitled to reasonable disbursements incurred after that date.

In summary, the court ordered that the body corporate was entitled to partial costs and disbursements, while the defendants were entitled to costs and disbursements incurred after a specific settlement offer was made. The parties were encouraged to agree on costs between themselves based on this judgment, with the option to file brief memoranda if an agreement could not be reached.