Body Corporate 95035 v Chang

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2011-404-002361 [2014] NZHC 1051

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE 95035

Applicant

AND

RONG YU CHANG, KAN HSIN HUNG CHANG and KENNETH AH KEN KOO First Respondents

CBD INVESTMENTS (NZ) LIMITED Second Respondents

MARK DANIEL WATSON Third Respondent

(intituling cont'd over …)

Judgment:                19 May 2014

JUDGMENT OF COURTNEY J

This judgment was delivered by Justice Courtney on 19  May 2014 at 4.00 pm

pursuant to R 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registar / Deputy Registrar

Date………………………..

BODY CORPORATE 95035 v CHANG & ORS [2014] NZHC 1051 [19 May 2014]

ANDREW MILLWARD PAYNE and

JULIE MARGARET PAYNE Fourth Respondents

ROGER HAMILTON STEWART Fifth Respondent

SUE CROCKFORD GALLERY LIMITED

Sixth Respondent

PATRICK JAMES LOO Seventh Respondent

JING GANG WANG Eighth Respondent

BARRY MARSH Ninth Respondent

CLAYTON JOHN HILLS AND MICHELLE YVETTE WILSON Tenth Respondents

LLOYD MARK GILMORE AND GRANT JAMES FOX

Eleventh Respondents

RICHARD FRED ACKE Twelfth Respondent

MARILYN LOIS REYNOLDS Thirteenth Respondent

PROPERT-ABILITY LIMITED Fourteenth Respondent

MUHAMMAD SHAHRIR BIN MUHAMMAD ARIFF and GEOK LEE YEO

Fifteenth Respondents

JONOTHAN NORRIS BRISCOE and

PATRICIA ANNE BRISCOE Sixteenth Respondents

IAN ASHLEY PAUL MILL and ANNETTE JOAN MILLS Seventeenth Respondents

VANESSA JEANNE JEANDIN Eighteenth Respondent

HARRY ROY LAW and SUK CHING LIAUW

Nineteenth Respondents

ANNE ELIZABETH MOLLOY and

BRIEN HERBERT CREE Twentieth Respondents

LINDA MARGARET BRADY and

BARRY MARSH

Twenty-first Respondents

PETER IAN HILMER and BEVERLY JOY KOHN

Twenty-second Respondents

NOEL ALLAN PLAYLE and MARGARET PLAYLE Twenty-third Respondents

PATRICIA ANNE NELSON Twenty-fourth Respondents

FLOTSAM LIMITED Twenty-fifth Respondents

MICHELLE JOY O’HALLORAN and

KELVIN HILL

Twenty-sixth Respondents

MALCOLM CRAIG SMELLIE, ROBERT PHILIP SMELLIE and LYNDSAY ANNE SMELLIE Twenty-seventh Respondents

TAN CORPORATE TRUSTEE LIMITED

Twenty-eighth Respondent

GABRIELLE THERESE WILSON, MICHAEL ERIC MARRIS and TRUSTS SB LIMITED

Twenty-ninth Respondents

ROSS NEVIN JOHNSON Thirtieth Respondent

Introduction

[1]      In  my decision  of  29  June  2012  I determined  a  number  of  applications affecting the Body Corporate of the Endeans Building in Queen Street, Auckland.1   I now consider the issue of costs.

[2]      The substantive proceeding was triggered by a Notice to Fix (NTF) issued by the Auckland City Council.   The work that was required related mainly to water- tightness issues in the roof.  In addition, cracks had been discovered in the façade of the building.  It was an unusual feature of the Endeans Building unit title and Body Corporate rules that the roof and exterior walls were private property but the responsibility for repairing them fell on the Body Corporate.  At the heart of all the

applications was the dispute over whether the 28th and 29th respondents, who owned

the penthouse apartments (and therefore most of the roof), should be liable for the majority of the cost of repairing the roof or whether that cost should be shared among all the unit holders through the Body Corporate.

[3]      The  Body  Corporate  sought  eight  declarations.     Some  related  to  the construction and validity of certain of the Body Corporate rules.  The others were for declarations as to the liability of the unit holders for the work…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 95035 v Chang and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 1051
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand considered an application concerning the Endeans Building in Queen Street, Auckland, focusing on disputes over water-tightness and façade repairs, and the financial responsibility of the Body Corporate versus individual unit holders. The key issue was whether the penthouse unit owners should bear the majority of the repair costs or if these costs should be shared among all unit holders. The court had to decide on the validity of certain Body Corporate rules, orders under sections 37(12) and 48 of the Unit Titles Act, and the liability of the unit holders for the repairs.

The court found that the Body Corporate's claim for declaratory relief was subject to the Declaratory Judgments Act 1908, which allows the court discretion in awarding costs. The applications for a scheme under section 48 were governed by the Unit Titles Act, which similarly grants the court discretion in ordering costs. The court exercised its discretion to determine costs based on fairness to all unit holders, considering the unique circumstances of the building's configuration and rules. The court found that while some positions taken by the parties were unreasonable, the overall litigation was reasonable and necessary. The court decided to pool the costs of all represented parties and treat them as costs in the scheme, apportioned according to the scheme percentages.

The court ordered that the post-judgment costs be shared according to the scheme percentages, and the pre-judgment costs of the represented parties be treated as costs in the scheme, also apportioned according to the scheme percentages. Disbursements, including expert witness costs, were to be treated similarly, except for those related to the unsuccessful application for a new title plan. This decision aimed to ensure that the costs were fairly distributed among all unit holders, reflecting the benefits they received from the scheme.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.