Body Corporate 81012 v Memelink

Link copied
Case Copied 62 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE

CIV-2021-485-419

[2023] NZHC 1749

BETWEEN BODY CORPORATE 81012, BODY CORPORATE 68792, and BODY CORPORATE 378945
Plaintiffs

AND

HARRY MEMELINK and CISCA

JOHNETTE FORSTER as Trustees of the LINK TRUST NO. 1

Defendants

Hearing: 24 May 2023

Appearances:

A S Olney for the Plaintiffs in CIV-2021-485-419 H Memelink in Person

C R Vinnell for the Official Assignee

J D Haig for the Receivers for the Link Trust (No. 1) j d Dallas (Abiding)

Judgment:

31 July 2023


JUDGMENT OF GRICE J


This judgment was delivered by me on 31 July 2023 at 4.45 pm pursuant to R 11.5 of the High Court Rules

…………………..

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

BODY CORPORATE 81012 v MEMELINK [2023] NZHC 1749 [31 July 2023]

IN THE MATTER BETWEEN

CIV-2020-485-462

of the Bankruptcy of HARRY MEMELINK

THE OFFICIAL ASSISGNEE in the bankruptcy of HARRY MEMELINK
Plaintiff

AND

HARRY MEMELINK and CISCA JOHNETTE

FORSTER as Trustees of the LINK TRUST (NO. 1) First Defendants

IN THE MATTER BETWEEN

CIV-2020-485-374

of the Liquidation of LYNX TRUSTEES LIMITED LYNX TRUSTEES LIMITED (In Liquidation)

Plaintiff

AND

HARRY MEMELINK and CISCA FORSTER as

Trustees of the LINK TRUST (NO. 1) Defendants

Introduction

[1]                 Mr Memelink was adjudicated bankrupt on 28 August 2018. Receivers were appointed to Mr Memelink’s family trust, the Link Trust No 1, on 31 May 2022.

[2]                 The  receivers   appointed   to   the   Trust   are   Mr   Iain   Shephard   and  Ms Jessica Kellow of the accounting firm, BDO Wellington Ltd. They are court-appointed receivers and so are officers of the court. They are required to realise the assets of the Trust for the benefit of the creditors of the trust.

[3]                 The Official Assignee has objected to Mr Memelink’s automatic discharge from bankruptcy. But for the filing of the objection, Mr Memelink would have been eligible for automatic discharge on 6 September 2022.1 Mr Memelink opposes the Official Assignee’s application objecting to the automatic discharge. A public examination took place in April and May 2023. The decision on the Official Assignee’s application has been reserved.2

[4]                 Mr Memelink had run several businesses and owned properties through the Link Trust No 1 and his other entities. The Official Assignee had, in his preliminary investigations, determined that Mr Memelink’s personal and business affairs were so closely intertwined that they could not be separated from those of the Link No 1 Trust.

[5]                 Mr Memelink for the trustees, Ms Cisca Forster and himself, has filed a series of applications, including an interlocutory application for an injunction. The applications, in general terms, seek to revisit the appointment and/or the terms of the orders appointing the receivers. In particular, Mr Memelink seeks orders replacing the receivers, suspending the  receivership,  or  allowing  the  trustees  (in  particular,  Mr Memelink) to have control over the realisation and management of the assets, property and the businesses that are owned by the Trust which are now in the control of the receivers. One of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 81012 v Memelink and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZHC 1749
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Harry Memelink was adjudicated bankrupt on 28 August 2018 and receivers were appointed to his family trust, the Link Trust No 1, on 31 May 2022. Mr Memelink has been involved in instigating and responding to numerous proceedings. A number of those proceedings, including those the subject of the present applications, were called in a general case management conference for matters related to Mr Memelink and his entities on 6 March 2023. The present leave applications were timetabled to a hearing at that conference. Mr Memelink's amended applications, together with further evidence, were to be filed by 24 March 2023. The opposition was to be filed by 21 April 2023 and the matter was to be set down on a date after 1 May 2023 for a hearing of one day. Mr Memelink did not keep to the timetable. He filed numerous documents, including some on the day before and on the morning of the hearing. In his oral submissions, Mr Memelink referred to documents which were either not filed or on the files relating to other proceedings. The documents which had been filed and to which he referred in his oral submissions included: an amended interlocutory application to modify the terms of the receivership dated 16 December 2022, a third amended application for leave for the appointment of an alternative receiver and other orders (dated 12 February 2023), an interim application dated 28 March 2023 for leave in relation to three sets of proceedings, an on-notice interlocutory application for injunction dated 24 March 2023, an "Urgent memorandum regarding extant applications and preventing gross miscarriage of justice" by Mr Memelink dated 18 April 2023, an "Extremely urgent memorandum regarding extant applications and preventing gross miscarriage of justice" by Mr Memelink dated 19 April 2023, and an affidavit by Ms Dayna May Spence, an insurance broker, dated 22 May 2023. Mr Memelink also filed an affidavit of Ms Forster, the other trustee of the Link No 1 Trust, dated 22 May 2023. Mr Memelink finally emailed the Court this morning sending three further documents without explanation as to their relevance, being a Code of Professional Conduct of the Restructuring Insolvency and Turnaround Association of New Zealand Inc, a consent to act as receiver by Mr Scutter dated 23 May 2023 and a Wormald's fire report dated 20 April 2023. Mr Memelink's submissions were broad-ranging and difficult to follow. They included Mr Memelink's complaints concerning the actions of various parties both preceding his bankruptcy and following his bankruptcy and the Trust's receivership. He directed his complaints towards a number of people and entities, including: the Body Corporate 68792 committee and chair as well as the owners of other units in the body corporate; his former lawyers and advisers, on whom he blamed his present situation; the administrators of the body corporate; the receivers; the Official Assignee and staff; and various judges who have dealt with proceedings relating to him and his entities. The issues Mr Memelink raises in support of his application for leave to apply for various orders concerning the receivership fall under three main headings: matters leading up to the bankruptcy of Mr Memelink, relating to the proposal put together by his former solicitor Mr Haines; matters leading up to the appointment of receivers to the Link Trust No 1, which includes the long running dispute that Mr Memelink has with Body Corporate 68792 (Hutt Road), in which the Trust owned units, as to whether the levies were properly set and in fact were owed by the Trust; and matters following the appointment of the receivers, which include the arrangements for insurance over the property; the method of sale of assets and properties owned by the Trust to date; how various assets have been stored in the Hutt Road units owned by the Trust; and how Mr Memelink and his associated corporate entities have been dealt with by the receivers/Official Assignee. The receivers of the body corporate, the Official Assignee (also acting as liquidator for some of the Memelink companies and Lynx Trustees Ltd), the administrator of the Hutt Road Body Corporate (and Mr Neil for the Official Assignee as liquidator for Lynx Trustees Ltd) filed a joint memorandum dated 19 April 2023 in response to the numerous documents and applications filed by Mr Memelink for interim injunctions, stays of enforcement and replacement of the trustees. The joint memorandum notes that the documents filed amount to "an increasingly confused restatement of matters already referred to by Mr Memelink in his various applications for leave". Mr Chisnall for the Official Assignee noted that the assets and liabilities of the Trust and Mr Memelink's personal assets and liabilities could not be separated. He indicated that a substantial portion of the debts in the bankruptcy were Trust debts, and therefore the Official Assignee was looking to the Trust property as a creditor of the estate in bankruptcy. Mr Chisnall pointed out that Mr Memelink has no standing to pursue matters on behalf of the Trust while the receivers are in place. Mr Memelink is not permitted to bring proceedings personally as a bankrupt. Therefore, any scope for him to pursue proceedings in the name of the Trust or his name personally are extremely limited. Counsel indicated that liabilities exceeded assets in both the estate of Mr Memelink in bankruptcy and in the Trust. The liability position had recently been stated with the issue of a decision on 23 May 2023 by Johnston AJ directing the Official Assignee to accept a proof of debt amounting to approximately $525,000, which the Judge determined was owed by Mr Memelink/the Trust to his former lawyer, Mr Haines. The Court dismissed the applications for leave to bring the various proceedings. Mr Memelink's applications fail at the serious question to be tried stage. Mr Memelink has raised no serious question that should be the subject of his applications insofar as they are applications for interim injunctions. The balance of convenience clearly favours the stay preventing any application by Mr Memelink. The stay will enable the receivers to undertake their obligations without the interference of Mr Memelink. Mr Memelink would be unable to pay damages as he is presently in bankruptcy and the Trust is in receivership.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.