Body Corporate 406198 v Argon Construction Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2017-404-001772

[2024] NZHC 237

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE 406198 & ORS

Plaintiffs

AND

ARGON CONSTRUCTION LIMITED

First Defendant

AUCKLAND COUNCIL

Second Defendant

Hearing: On the papers

Appearances:

D R Bigio KC, R D Butler, S C I Jeffs, I J Stephenson, R J H Scott, H Chung and J C Wedlake for Plaintiffs

W A McCartney and D A Cowan for First Defendant
S C Price, M J Ferrier, C M Fairnie and S H Ji for Second Defendant
K J Sheehan for self-represented plaintiffs and others

Judgment:

20 February 2024


JUDGMENT OF ANDREW J

[Damages]


This judgment was delivered by Justice Andrew on 20 February 2024 at 4.00 pm

pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules 2016 Registrar / Deputy Registrar

Date …………………………

BODY CORPORATE 406198 & ORS v ARGON CONSTRUCTION LIMITED [2024] NZHC 237 [20 February 2024]

Introduction

[1]                 In my judgment on liability dated 30 October 2023, I found that the two defendants were jointly and severally liable for damages. I directed that the damages are to be calculated as follows:

(a)Based on the factual findings made in my judgment; and

(b)Upon receipt of further submissions (if necessary) from the parties addressing the quantification of such damages, based on the starting point of Mr Brock’s estimate, based on Mr Alexander’s scope of repairs.1

[2]                 The Court has received further submissions from the parties addressing the issue of quantification of damages. This judgment addresses that issue and is being determined on the papers without the need for any further hearing.2

[3]The plaintiffs contend for a remedial quantum totalling $4,974,830.11.3

[4]                 The defendants contend for a remedial quantum of $3,218,696. They say that there should be no allowance for any moving out costs.

[5]The issues I need to address are as follows:

(a)Preliminary and general (P & G) and scaffolding;

(b)Construction duration – the effect of removing defect 7 (settled);

(c)Construction duration – whether there should be an adjustment;


1      Body Corporate 406198 v Argon Construction Ltd [2023] NZHC 3034 at [353].

2      The Court has received the following submissions from the parties on the question of quantification of damages: plaintiffs’ submissions dated 24 November 2023, second defendant’s submissions dated 1 December 2023, first defendant’s submissions dated 1 December 2023 and plaintiffs’ reply submissions on damages dated 13 December 2023.

3      Plaintiffs’ reply submissions dated 13 December 2023. In their original submissions dated 24 November 2023, the calculation was $4,685,891.54 (the amended quantum appears to relate to escalation). The amount claimed by the plaintiffs includes a moving out contingency of $350,000.

(d)Weathertightness detail;

(e)Escalation;

(f)Consultant costs;

(g)Costs of moving out.

Analysis and decision

[6]I address each of the issues in turn.

[7]                 I accept in principle that it is, of course, for the plaintiff to establish the quantum of loss and on the balance of probabilities. However, it is important also to acknowledge that in some cases the following approach…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 406198 v Argon Construction Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZHC 237
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Body Corporate 406198 & Ors v Argon Construction Limited, the High Court of New Zealand was tasked with determining the amount of damages to be awarded to the plaintiffs following a finding of liability for construction defects. The primary dispute centred on the quantum of damages, with the plaintiffs seeking a total of $4,974,830.11 and the defendants contending for $3,218,696. The court had to address several issues, including the preliminary and general (P&G) costs, construction duration, weathertightness details, escalation, consultant costs, and moving out costs.

Justice Andrew meticulously evaluated each component, considering submissions from both parties. The court accepted the plaintiffs' approach for certain items, such as the overlapping P&G costs, and made specific adjustments to the initial estimates. For instance, the court deducted $20,000 from the P&G costs and allowed for a weathertightness detail of $40,000. The court also ruled on the appropriate escalation period, consultant costs, and moving out costs, arriving at a total award of $4,974,830.11 with specified deductions and adjustments. In terms of general damages, the court confirmed the agreed amount of $779,500, excluding unrepresented plaintiffs, and clarified that certain unit owners were not entitled to general damages. The court directed the plaintiffs to submit an amended schedule reflecting the adjustments and ordered that costs be determined according to a pre-set timetable.

The final orders included the award of remedial damages of $4,974,830.11 to the plaintiffs, subject to specified deductions and adjustments, and the confirmation of general damages amounting to $779,500, excluding unrepresented plaintiffs. The court also clarified that certain unit owners were not beneficiaries of the general damages award. Costs were to be determined in accordance with the previously established timetable.