Body Corporate 406198 v Argon Construction Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2017-404-001772

[2024] NZHC 1037

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE 406198 & ORS

Plaintiffs

AND

ARGON CONSTRUCTION LIMITED

First Defendant

AUCKLAND COUNCIL

Second Defendant

Hearing: On the papers

Counsel:

D R Bigio KC, R D Butler, S C I Jeffs, I J Stephenson, R J H Scott, H Chung and J C Wedlake for Plaintiffs

W A McCartney and D A Cowan for First Defendant
S C Price, M J Ferrier, C M Fairnie and S H Ji for Second Defendant

Judgment:

1 May 2024

Reissued:

10 May 2024


COSTS JUDGMENT OF ANDREW J


This judgment was delivered by Justice Andrew

on 1 May 2024 at 3.00 pm and re-issued on 10 May 2024 pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules 2016

Registrar / Deputy Registrar Date …………………………….

BODY CORPORATE 406198 & ORS v ARGON CONSTRUCTION LIMITED [2024] NZHC 1037 [1 May 2024]

Introduction

[1]    In my judgment on liability dated 30 October 2023,1 I found that the first and second defendants were jointly and severally liable for damages. I entered judgment for the plaintiffs in respect of both the first and second causes of action (i.e. negligence). In my damages judgment of 20 February 2024,2 I ordered that the defendants are to pay damages to the plaintiffs of $4,974,830.11 (subject to minor adjustments and determinations made in the judgment).

[2]This judgment addresses the question of costs.

[3]    The plaintiff’s primary position is that, as the successful party it is entitled to costs. They seek costs on a 3B basis in the total sum of $563,254, together with disbursement of $796,837.92.

[4]In March 2023, the defendants made a pre-trial offer to settle in the sum of

$19,230,000 (inclusive of GST) (the Calderbank offer). The position of the defendants on costs is informed both by the Calderbank offer and the submission that the plaintiffs failed in relation to issues which significantly increased their costs and are said to have contributed unnecessarily to the time and expense of the proceedings (i.e. by the plaintiffs’ pursuit of and approach to remedial scope and quantum that lacked merit).

[5]The defendants say on costs:

(a)Costs should lie where they fall from the commencement of the proceeding until 29 March 2023;

(b)From 29 March 2023 onward, the defendants should have 2B costs, with three counsel and a 50 per cent uplift. That is the date the defendants made a Calderbank offer that exceeded the judgment sum. They say the uplift is warranted because the plaintiffs’ failure to engage was unreasonable. The total sum of costs and disbursements sought by


1      Body Corporate 406198 v Argon Construction Ltd [2023] NZHC 3034.

2      Body Corporate 406198 v Argon Construction Ltd [2024] NZHC 237.

The Auckland Council is $439,417.14. The total sum of costs and disbursements sought by Argon Construction Ltd is $408,904.05.

Issues

  1. I need to address the following issues:

(a)Who was the successful party?

(b)As a matter of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 406198 v Argon Construction Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZHC 1037
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Body Corporate 406198 & Ors v Argon Construction Limited, the High Court of New Zealand addressed the issue of costs following a previous ruling on liability and damages. The plaintiffs, who were successful in their negligence claims against the defendants, sought costs on a 3B basis, totaling $563,254, and disbursements of $796,837.92. The defendants argued that the plaintiffs were not entitled to costs due to their rejection of a Calderbank offer, which exceeded the judgment sum. The Court considered the effect of the Calderbank offer, the complexity of the proceedings, and the conduct of the parties in determining the costs.

The Court found that the plaintiffs were the successful party and that the Calderbank offer did not affect the analysis of success. It was deemed unjust and unreasonable to reduce the costs on account of the Calderbank offer, as the plaintiffs had not acted unreasonably in rejecting it. The Court categorized the proceedings as category 3 due to their complexity and significance, involving technical evidence and extensive quantity surveyor evidence. The Court granted the plaintiffs additional cost allowances for discovery, preparation of briefs, and preparation for hearing. It also certified third counsel and allowed for disbursements, including expert witness fees, court fees, and photocopying expenses, after applying a discount for work on settled or abandoned defects.

Ultimately, the Court ordered that the defendants were to pay costs to the plaintiffs in the sum of $563,254 and disbursements of $579,514.73. The liability for costs and disbursements was apportioned between the defendants, with the Auckland Council liable for 65% and Argon Construction Ltd for 35%. The Court addressed the self-represented plaintiffs' submission that they were not aware of the Calderbank offer until the costs submissions process but did not find it necessary to rule on their application to avoid paying defendants’ costs as the defendants were not entitled to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.