IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
CIV-2013-404-4646 [2014] NZHC 2971
IN THE MATTER of "Imperial Gardens Apartments" BETWEEN
BODY CORPORATE 348047
First Plaintiff[Second plaintiffs continued over]
AND
AUCKLAND COUNCIL First Defendant
WATTS & HUGHES Second Defendant
DOWNER NEW ZEALAND LIMITED Third Defendant
AND
ALUMINIUM TECHNOLOGY LIMITED
First Third Party
[Third parties continued over]
Hearing: 21 November 2014 Counsel:
PR Grimshaw and RF Harvey for plaintiffs SC Price and JK Wilson for first defendant SJP Ladd for third defendant
Judgment:
26 November 2014
JUDGMENT OF FAIRE J
Solicitors: Grimshaw & Company, Auckland MinterEllisonRuddWatts, Auckland Bell Gully, Auckland
Body Corporate 348047 v Auckland Council [2014] NZHC 2971 [26 November 2014]
Second plaintiffs, continued
AND CHRISTIAN WAN, ZHENG WANG,
LINE LINE FAILLOUX (1/2 share) and THIERRY SILLOUX (1/2 share); LI-WEI SUN; JAMES ERNEST STEWART and ELIZABETH MARY BAYNE; HORTENSE FAILLOUX; MEI MEI
LUO; FLORA WANG; LEON FAILLOUX and SOLANGE CHENGUE FAILLOUX; AGATHE FAILLOUX; RALPH MATAPO and BLANCHE NIVA MATAPO; EMMANUEL RAUNUI ROLAND PAIN (1/3 share), MYRIAM HAIMANU DANNIELLE PAIN (1/3 share) and ANGELIQUE HITIATUA MARIE PAIN (1/3 share); YUAN- CHUNG WANG and SHENG-PAO CHANG WANG; SHANE LAVELLE MCDUFFIE; HOUSING NEW ZEALAND LIMITED; PL AND SONS INVESTMENTS LIMITED; FANG XIA; ROSE JOANNA LIM; HENRI MOU and THERESE TERIRIATUA MOU; DEALEX LIMITED; PHYLLIS LAI; CHANG MEI-YU CHIU and ABNER
YU-RAY CHIU; TSAI-YU LO and TONY YU CHUAN WANG; ALAN MICHAEL BIRD and DIANE MAREE BIRD; XUFENG LI; ROTA ANDREE; FINMEI FAN; ALAN ROLAND; LIQIAN TONG; YUEHUA HE; JUNLING QI and QI
SUN; MIAOSHAN LIU; XIANGHONG CAO; MIKI GIORDANI; IRENE MARDIONO; MINGZHU YANG and PINGQI WEI; HUIJIE XIN; ZHENG HE; HLY LIMITED; MASANOBU ESUMI; HENG LI; DEQIANG SHI and JIA ZHOU; XUELAN PANG; PEIYAN MA, QIANG WANG and WILLIAM WANG MA; DONALD HARTLEY KAYES; CHOONG HUAT LAI and LUAN JOO TAN; KANG XU; MING LI; LIANG ZHU and XIAOSHU CHEN; TREVOR DENIS ALLISON; GEN BAO IN; SYLVIAN LIAO; LI MA; JUNYU QIANG; XUI XU PRODUCTIONS PARADISE NZ LIMITED; KIM HA TRAN; GANG XU; FEN GU; JIANHAO XU; NIEVES RUBIO CAMBERO; SCATS INVESTMENTS LIMITED; EN-
CHIN TENG and MAN-JUNG HSIEH; AZANO PROPERTIES LIMITED; ROGER DESPOIR and GHISLANE WONG KIN HING; JOHN WILLIAM BLUNDEN and FOOTES TRUSTEES LIMITED, BETTERKIWI LIMITED; PAUL ERNEST WHITE; JOHN PATTERSON; PAUL JOHN FOLWELL and PAULINE ANN FOLWELL; JIANHUI HUANG; TAG JEONG HAM and EUN JEONG JANG; HUI GU and QI YANG; GORDON LEONARD WIGG
and HEATHER ANNE WIGG; YUET WO FUNG and BOSTON TRUSTEES 6303
LIMITED; GRIGG-CRAIG INVESTMENTS LIMITED; ACADACA INVESTMENTS LIMITED; XIANJUN SUN; QIJUN XIE; MANAKO NAKAKIMA; LITTLE ENTERPRISES (2003) LIMITED; COLIN MCKENZIE DOUGLAS and LYNN HEATHER DOUGLAS (1/2 share) and KIRSTY LORNA TSOI (1/2 share); GUIYEN REN and MINGXIANG GU; OSCAR LOO and PHUI YEE WONG; OSCAR LOO, PHUI YEE WONG and EDDY LOO; NIKHITA
& NIKHL INVESTMENTS LIMITED; JIAJUA LU; ROHIT KUMAR; FREDERICK MCSKIMMING HACKETT; HOCK SENG HARRY LOH and SIEW GEOK ANNETTE CHONG; ; ANTHONY JOHN PATTERSON; SEON JANG; DANEIL LECOMTE and ALICE LECOMTE; PETER TIMOTHY MOORE and ANDREW MARIE MOORE;…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 348047 v Auckland Council and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] NZHC 2971
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi