IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
CIV-2013-404-4646 [2015] NZHC 128
IN THE MATTER of Imperial Gardens Apartments BETWEEN
BODY CORPORATE 348047
First Plaintiff………………../Second plaintiffs listed over
AND
AUCKLAND COUNCIL First Defendant
WATTS & HUGHES LIMITED Second Defendant
DOWNER NEW ZEALAND LIMITED Third Defendant
..................../Third Parties listed over
On the papers Counsel:
PR Grimshaw and RF Harvey for plaintiffs
SC Price and JK Wilson for first defendantJudgment:
11 February 2015
JUDGMENT OF FAIRE J
This judgment was delivered by me on 11 February 2015 at 4 pm, pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.
Registrar/Deputy Registrar
Date……………
Solicitors: Grimshaw & Co, Auckland
MinterEllisonRuddWatts, Auckland
Body Corporate 348047 v Auckland Council [2015] NZHC 128 [11 February 2015]
Second plaintiffs
ANDCHRISTIAN WAN, ZHENG WANG, LINE LINE FAILLOUX (1/2 share) and THIERRY SILLOUX (1/2 share); LI-WEI SUN; JAMES ERNEST STEWART and ELIZABETH MARY BAYNE; HORTENSE FAILLOUX; MEI MEI
LUO; FLORA WANG; LEON FAILLOUX and SOLANGE CHENGUE FAILLOUX; AGATHE FAILLOUX; RALPH MATAPO and BLANCHE NIVA MATAPO; EMMANUEL RAUNUI ROLAND PAIN (1/3 share), MYRIAM HAIMANU DANNIELLE PAIN (1/3 share) and ANGELIQUE HITIATUA MARIE PAIN (1/3 share); YUAN- CHUNG WANG and SHENG-PAO CHANG WANG; SHANE LAVELLE MCDUFFIE; HOUSING NEW ZEALAND LIMITED; PL AND SONS INVESTMENTS LIMITED; FANG XIA; ROSE JOANNA LIM; HENRI MOU and THERESE TERIRIATUA MOU; DEALEX LIMITED; PHYLLIS LAI; CHANG MEI-YU CHIU and ABNER
YU-RAY CHIU; TSAI-YU LO and TONY YU CHUAN WANG; ALAN MICHAEL BIRD and DIANE MAREE BIRD; XUFENG LI; ROTA ANDREE; FINMEI FAN; ALAN ROLAND; LIQIAN TONG; YUEHUA HE; JUNLING QI and QI
SUN; MIAOSHAN LIU; XIANGHONG CAO; MIKI GIORDANI; IRENE MARDIONO; MINGZHU YANG and PINGQI WEI; HUIJIE XIN; ZHENG HE; HLY LIMITED; MASANOBU ESUMI; HENG LI; DEQIANG SHI and JIA ZHOU; XUELAN PANG; PEIYAN MA, QIANG WANG and WILLIAM WANG MA; DONALD HARTLEY KAYES; CHOONG HUAT LAI and LUAN JOO TAN; KANG XU; MING LI; LIANG ZHU and XIAOSHU CHEN; TREVOR DENIS ALLISON; GEN BAO IN; SYLVIAN LIAO; LI MA; JUNYU QIANG; XUI XU PRODUCTIONS PARADISE NZ LIMITED; KIM HA TRAN; GANG XU; FEN GU; JIANHAO XU; NIEVES RUBIO CAMBERO; SCATS INVESTMENTS LIMITED; EN-
CHIN TENG and MAN-JUNG HSIEH; AZANO PROPERTIES LIMITED; ROGER DESPOIR and GHISLANE WONG KIN HING; JOHN WILLIAM BLUNDEN and FOOTES TRUSTEES LIMITED, BETTERKIWI LIMITED; PAUL ERNEST WHITE; JOHN PATTERSON; PAUL JOHN FOLWELL and PAULINE ANN FOLWELL; JIANHUI HUANG; TAG JEONG HAM and EUN JEONG JANG; HUI GU and QI YANG; GORDON LEONARD WIGG
and HEATHER ANNE WIGG; YUET WO FUNG and BOSTON TRUSTEES 6303
LIMITED; GRIGG-CRAIG INVESTMENTS LIMITED; ACADACA INVESTMENTS LIMITED; XIANJUN SUN; QIJUN XIE; MANAKO NAKAKIMA; LITTLE ENTERPRISES (2003) LIMITED; COLIN MCKENZIE DOUGLAS and LYNN HEATHER DOUGLAS (1/2 share) and KIRSTY LORNA TSOI (1/2 share); GUIYEN REN and MINGXIANG GU; OSCAR LOO and PHUI YEE WONG; OSCAR LOO, PHUI YEE WONG and EDDY LOO; NIKHITA
& NIKHL INVESTMENTS LIMITED; JIAJUA LU; ROHIT KUMAR; FREDERICK MCSKIMMING HACKETT; HOCK SENG HARRY LOH and SIEW GEOK ANNETTE CHONG; ; ANTHONY JOHN PATTERSON; SEON JANG; DANEIL LECOMTE and ALICE…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 348047 v Auckland Council and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] NZHC 128
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue was whether the plaintiffs' initial statement of claim was so deficient that the proceedings should be struck out, or if an opportunity should be given to the plaintiffs to file an amended statement of claim that complies with the High Court Rules. The court also had to determine the appropriate allocation of costs between the parties.
The court ruled that while the initial statement of claim was indeed deficient and issued with an improper motive, the plaintiffs were granted an opportunity to file an amended statement of claim. The court found that the amended statement of claim had sufficient information to identify a potential cause of action, and thus, the proceedings should not be struck out entirely. The court ordered the plaintiffs to file an amended statement of claim that complies with the High Court Rules within a specified timeframe.
Regarding costs, the court found that the Auckland Council was entitled to costs for the interlocutory application. The court determined that the plaintiffs' conduct warranted an award of costs based on Category 2 Band B of the High Court Rules, amounting to $8,059.50, plus a filing fee of $500. The court declined to make an allowance for the memoranda filed by the plaintiffs.
In summary, the court allowed the plaintiffs to proceed with an amended statement of claim, while ordering them to pay the Auckland Council's costs for the interlocutory application. The court's decision balanced the procedural failings of the plaintiffs with the potential merits of their claims, ensuring that justice was served while also addressing the procedural missteps.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi