Body Corporate 325261 v McDonough

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2011-404-008000 [2014] NZHC 1152

IN THE MATTER known as C-Vu Apartments

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE 325261
First Plaintiff

RODNEY WILLIAM COOKE AND OTHERS

Second Plaintiffs

AND

JAY MCDONOUGH First Defendant

Continued over/...

Hearing: On the papers

Appearances:

S Mills QC/B O'Callahan, Sixth and Seventh
Defendants/Applicants
G J Kohler QC and C Baker for the Plaintiffs/Respondents

Judgment:

28 May 2014

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE CHRISTIANSEN

This judgment was delivered by me on

28.05.14 at 4:30pm, pursuant to

Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date……………

BODY CORPORATE 325261 & ORS v J MCDONOUGH & ORS [2014] NZHC 1152 [28 May 2014]

MAUNGA REI NZ LIMITED Second Defendant

AUCKLAND COUNCIL Third Defendant

GARY BICKERTON Fourth Defendant

RACHEL VENABLES Fifth Defendant

STEPHEN MITCHELL ENGINEERS LIMITED

Sixth Defendant

STEPHEN ROBERT MITCHELL Seventh Defendant

MACDONALD BARNETT PARTNERS LIMITED

Eighth Defendant

MICHAEL SIMPSON Ninth Defendant

JAY MCDONOUGH First Defendant

[1]      This judgment deals with the sixth and seventh defendants’ application for the recall  of  my judgment  dated  3  March  2014  which  dismissed  the  sixth  and seventh defendants’ applications for strike out.

The recall application

[2]      It claims that my judgment failed to determine issues which were put to me, including:

(a) failing to determine the act or omission and the date of that act or omission for the purpose of s 393(2) of the Building Act 2004;

(b)      misapprehending the submissions of counsel;

(c)       not addressing the affidavit of Murray Jacobs; and

(d)concluding  there  would  be  no  relevant  damage  until  cracking occurred.

[3]      The application then identifies a number of elements of the judgment which it is claimed incorrectly described the submissions made on behalf of the sixth and seventh defendants on the strike out application.  Claims include:

(a)      that the defendants’ case was mischaracterised as one identifying their structural plans as being so defective that anyone could have seen those defects;

(b)that I recorded the evidence as having submitted that the focus of the pleadings shifted from column floor diagrams to shear wall connections and their capacity to transfer earthquake forces;

(c)      that I misstated the significance of the producer statement provided by the defendants;

(d)that I incorrectly recorded the defendants’ submissions as being that defects should have been discovered by the Council at the time the drawings were submitted for approval and consent.

(e)      that I omitted to address the evidence contained in a further affidavit of a Mr Jacobs or to give any consideration to submissions made in relation thereto; and

(f)      that I have misapprehended counsels’ submissions because I conflated “damage relevant to observing weather tightness defects with those relevant to observing alleged seismic capacity defects”.

Hearing upon the recall application

[4]      Initially the hearing scheduled for 28 April 2014 was vacated because both senior counsel could not be present on that date.

[5]      I then arranged for a telephone conference to speak to counsel regarding the possibility of  my dealing  with  the  matter  on  the  basis  of  submissions  filed  by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 325261 v McDonough and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 1152
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The judgment concerns an application by the sixth and seventh defendants, Mac Donald Barnett Partners Limited and Stephen Robert Mitchell, for the recall of an earlier judgment dismissing their application for strike out. The plaintiffs are the body corporate for C-Vu Apartments, Rodney William Cooke, and others. The defendants are contesting the plaintiffs' claims that the structural design of the apartments was defective, leading to significant damages. The court was required to determine whether the earlier judgment contained errors significant enough to warrant a recall under the rules of the High Court of New Zealand. These errors included the court's failure to determine the act or omission and its date for the purposes of the Building Act 2004, misapprehending the defendants' submissions, not addressing the affidavit of Murray Jacobs, and concluding that there would be no relevant damage until cracking occurred. The defendants also argued that the judgment incorrectly described the significance of their submissions.

The court considered the principles governing recall applications, noting that a judgment should generally stand unless there is a new authoritative decision, counsel failed to direct the court’s attention to a relevant decision, or some other very special reason justifies recall. The court examined whether the defendants' reliance on Westland District Council v York & Alpine Glacier Motel Limited as a new authoritative decision warranted a recall. While Westland suggested that the loss occurs when a negligently prepared land information memorandum (LIM) is provided, the court found it questionable whether the provision of building designs is sufficiently similar to the provision of a LIM to warrant a recall. The court also reviewed the defendants' claims of misapprehending their submissions and concluded that while some errors in the characterization of the defendants' arguments existed, they did not materially affect the outcome. The court found that the most substantial issue was the failure to adequately address the relevant act or omission for the purposes of the Building Act. However, the court determined that this was a factual issue more appropriately resolved at trial rather than on a strike out application. Therefore, the application for recall was refused.

The court's final orders were that the application for recall was refused and costs were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.