BETWEEN MANU HORI IONGI Appellant AND THE KING Respondent

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA151/2024
 [2024] NZCA 522

BETWEEN

MANU HORI IONGI
Appellant

AND

THE KING
Respondent

CA162/2024

BETWEEN

FALALA’ANGA OMOOMI IONGI
Appellant

AND

THE KING
Respondent

Hearing:

4 September 2024

Court:

Cooke, Collins and Grice JJ

Counsel:

K E Hogan and T Hu for Appellant in CA151/2024
B J Meyer for Appellant in CA162/2024
N E Walker and S E Arnerich for Respondent

Judgment:

16 October 2024 at 11 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal against conviction and sentence by Manu Iongi is dismissed.

B    The appeal against sentence by Falala’anga Iongi is allowed.  The minimum period of imprisonment of 17 years is quashed and substituted with a minimum period of imprisonment of 15 years. 

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Collins J)

Introduction

  1. Meliame Fisi’ihoi lived at 73 Calthorp Close in Māngere with members of her family, including her son, Stephen Fisi’ihoi, who lived in a portable cabin (Portacom) on the front lawn of the family’s property.  On the night of 14 January 2020, Mrs Fisi’ihoi was in the lounge of her home.  At about 2.45 am on 15 January 2020, her attention was drawn to sounds outside the front of her house.  When Mrs Fisi’ihoi pulled back the curtains, she was shot in the head by a person firing a shotgun through the window, no further than two metres from the window.  She died instantly.  Following a fifteen-month investigation, police arrested Falala’anga (known as Falala) Iongi, his younger brother Viliami Iongi, and their cousin, Manu Iongi, for the murder of Mrs Fisi’ihoi.

  2. Falala and Viliami Iongi were found guilty of having murdered Mrs Fisi’ihoi while Manu Iongi was found guilty of manslaughter.  In the same trial, Falala and Viliami Iongi were also found guilty of reckless discharge of a firearm with intent to cause grievous bodily harm and wounding with intent to cause grievous bodily harm.

  3. The charges of reckless discharge of a firearm with intent to cause grievous bodily harm and wounding with intent to cause grievous bodily harm related to events that occurred on 4 December 2019 when Falala and Viliami Iongi went to 73 Calthorp Close with shotguns to confront Stephen Fisi’ihoi.  Viliami Iongi fired two shots, one of which was aimed at Stephen Fisi’ihoi who escaped injury.  George Vuna, an associate of Stephen Fisi’ihoi, was shot in his lower abdomen.  He suffered severe injuries but survived.

  4. The defendants were sentenced on 23 February 2024 by Powell J:[1]

    (a)Falala Iongi was sentenced to life imprisonment with a requirement that he serve a minimum period of imprisonment (MPI) of 17 years before he is eligible to apply for parole for the murder of Mrs Fisi’ihoi.[2]  He was also sentenced to concurrent sentences of eight years’ imprisonment for discharge of a firearm with intent to cause grievous bodily harm and 10 years’ imprisonment for wounding with intent to cause grievous bodily harm.[3]

    (b)Viliami Iongi was sentenced to life imprisonment with an MPI of 15…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BETWEEN MANU HORI IONGI Appellant AND THE KING Respondent and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZCA 522
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between Manu Hori Iongi and the King involved a ruling on the admissibility of evidence obtained from Havea Iongi under Section 30 of the Evidence Act. The appellant challenged the admissibility of a principal statement made by Havea Iongi to the police. The court was required to determine whether the statement was improperly obtained and, if so, whether its exclusion was proportionate to the impropriety. The primary legal issue was whether the statement was improperly obtained in breach of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 or otherwise obtained unfairly, and if so, whether its exclusion was proportionate to the impropriety.

The court's reasoning began with an assessment of whether the evidence was improperly obtained. The judge found that the statement was not obtained in breach of any enactment or rule of law, nor was it obtained unfairly according to the Chief Justice’s Practice Note. Therefore, the statement was not improperly obtained. Consequently, there was no need for a balancing exercise under Section 30(2)(b) of the Evidence Act. Given the ruling that the evidence was not improperly obtained, the court did not need to consider whether its exclusion was proportionate to the impropriety.

The court concluded that the principal statement made by Havea Iongi to the police was admissible as it was not improperly obtained. The court did not find it necessary to conduct a balancing exercise to determine whether excluding the evidence was proportionate to the impropriety. The ruling allowed the statement to be admitted as evidence in the proceedings. The final orders would follow from the court's determination of the admissibility of the statement, allowing the case to proceed with the use of this evidence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As we have noted, Powell J ruled that the principal statement made by Havea Iongi to the police was admissible.[12] That ruling was made pursuant to s 30(2)(b) of the Evidence Act. The relevant parts of s 30 of the Evidence Act state:[12]Admissibility judgment, above n 10.30 Improperly obtained evidence(1)This section applies to a criminal proceeding in which the prosecution offers or proposes to offer evidence if—(a)the defendant or, if applicable, a co-defendant against whom the evidence is offered raises, on the basis of an evidential foundation, the issue of whether the evidence was improperly obtained and informs the prosecution of the grounds for raising the issue; or(b)the Judge raises the issue of whether the evidence was improperly obtained and informs the prosecution of the grounds for raising the issue.(2) The Judge must—(a)find, on the balance of probabilities, whether or not the evidence was improperly obtained; and(b)if the Judge finds that the evidence has been improperly obtained, determine whether or not the exclusion of the evidence is proportionate to the impropriety by means of a balancing process that gives appropriate weight to the impropriety and takes proper account of the need for an effective and credible system of justice.(3)For the purposes of subsection (2), the court may, among any other matters, have regard to the following:(a)the importance of any right breached by the impropriety and the seriousness of the intrusion on it:(b)the nature of the impropriety, in particular, whether it was deliberate, reckless, or done in bad faith:(c) the nature and quality of the improperly obtained evidence:(d)the seriousness of the offence with which the defendant is charged:(e)whether there were any other investigatory techniques not involving any breach of the rights that were known to be available but were not used:(f)whether there are alternative remedies to exclusion of the evidence that can adequately provide redress to the defendant:(g)whether the impropriety was necessary to avoid apprehended physical danger to the Police or others:(h)whether there was any urgency in obtaining the improperly obtained evidence.(4)The Judge must exclude any improperly obtained evidence if, in accordance with subsection (2), the Judge determines that its exclusion is proportionate to the impropriety.(5)For the purposes of this section, evidence is improperly obtained if it is obtained—(a)in consequence of a breach of any enactment or rule of law by a person to whom section 3 of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 applies; or…(c) unfairly.(6)Without limiting subsection (5)(c), in deciding whether a statement obtained by a member of the Police has been obtained unfairly for the purposes of that provision, the Judge must take into account guidelines set out in practice notes on that subject issued by the Chief Justice. Section 30 of the Evidence Act sets out the sequential steps required to determine whether or not evidence has been improperly obtained, and if it has been improperly obtained, whether or not it is nevertheless admissible. It is a two-step process:(a)First, Powell J was required to determine on the balance of probabilities whether or not the principal statement made by Havea Iongi was improperly obtained.[13] In this case, evidence of a witness could be improperly obtained if it was gathered in breach of the witness’ rights under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 (NZBORA) or otherwise obtained unfairly having regard to the Chief Justice’s Practice Note concerning the making of statements to the police.[14] (b)Secondly, if the statement was improperly obtained, Powell J was then required to undertake a balancing exercise to determine whether or not excluding the statement was proportionate to the impropriety.[15] The balancing exercise requires appropriate weight to be given to the impropriety and for proper account to be taken of the need for an effective and credible system of justice. The matters set out in s 30(3) may be relevant to the balancing exercise undertaken pursuant to s 30(2)(b).[13]Evidence Act 2006, s 30(2)(a).[14]Section 30(5)(a) and (c).[15]Section 30(2)(b).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established