IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY
CIV-2010-441-000581 [2014] NZHC 255
BETWEEN EDWARD HENRY BAKER and WHAKAWE CHARLES RAMEKA as trustees of THE THOMAS BAKER WHANAU TRUST
Applicants
ANDWAIMAKUKU WHANAU TRUST BOARD INCORPORATED Respondent
On papers
Judgment: 24 February 2014
JUDGMENT OF DOBSON J (Costs for the Amicus)
[1] I have now had an opportunity to consider the various memoranda in relation to the application by the amicus for costs orders, as directed in [23] to [28] of my supplementary judgment of 29 October 2013. These comprise the memorandum of the amicus dated 4 November 2013, the memorandum of counsel for the applicants dated 15 November 2013 and the submissions of counsel for the respondent dated
9 December 2013. I regret that other commitments have prevented my addressing the matter before now.
[2] The amicus seeks orders under s 99A(1)(b) of the Judicature Act 1908. That section provides:
99A Costs where intervener or counsel assisting Court appears
(1) Where the Attorney-General or the Solicitor-General or any other person appears in any civil proceedings or in any proceedings on any appeal and argues any question of law or of fact arising in the proceedings, the Court may, subject to the provisions of any other Act, make such order as it thinks just—
BAKER v WAIMAKUKU WHANAU TRUST BOARD INC [2014] NZHC 255 [24 February 2014]
…
(b) As to the payment by any party to the proceedings or out of public funds of the costs incurred by any other person in so doing; or
…
[3] The amicus has suggested that different considerations apply in relation to costs incurred on interlocutory steps, and those incurred in relation to the substantive hearing.
[4] The applicant trustees had previously resisted any basis for a costs order against the fund comprising the assets of the applicants’ trust. The grounds included that the Court had recognised the appropriateness of assistance from an amicus, given the potentially diverse interests of some 380 beneficiaries in 10 branches of the extended family involved. Further, given the terms on which the Crown had reached a settlement of the relevant Waitangi Tribunal claims, the Crown ought itself to recognise an on-going responsibility reflected in the provision of services such as those provided by the amicus.
[5] In the event that either of the parties ought to contribute, it was submitted for the applicants that such burden should fall on the respondent because the scope of matters raised in the proceedings had been substantially and irrelevantly protracted by initiatives on behalf of the respondent. There was constructive dialogue between the applicants and the amicus in resolving the proceedings, and there is no justification for requiring the involvement of the amicus to be at the expense of the fund.
[6] The respondent also opposed any order that it should be liable to contribute to the costs incurred by the amicus. Mr Nee Harland’s submissions in response to the memoranda filed by the amicus and on behalf of the applicants iterated…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Baker v Waimakuku Whanau Trust Board Incorporated and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] NZHC 255
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court found that the respondent's initiatives had indeed caused the proceedings to be protracted and had increased the work required by the amicus. In relation to the interlocutory steps, the Court determined that these were not necessary had the proceedings been confined to the relevant issues concerning the trust deed. Therefore, the costs of $8,712 incurred during these steps were to be borne by the respondent. For the substantive hearing, the Court assessed that while the core work of the amicus was justified, the respondent's actions had somewhat increased the workload. Consequently, 25% of the substantive hearing costs, amounting to $9,847.50, were to be borne by the respondent. Additionally, 25% of the disbursements, totalling $920.74, were also to be paid by the respondent. The remaining costs and disbursements were to be paid by the Crown.
In light of these findings, the Court concluded that the total order in favor of the amicus against the respondent amounted to $19,480.24. The Court further noted that if the respondent lacked the capacity to meet these liabilities, it might consider attributing the costs to Mr. Nigel Baker, who was closely associated with the respondent's instructions. Finally, the Court decided that the balance of the costs not borne by the respondent should be paid out of public funds, given the Crown's role in establishing the trust fund and the need for objective guidance in resolving the beneficiaries' interests. The total liability of the Crown was quantified as $32,304.70.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi