IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY
CIV-2010-441-000581 [2014] NZHC 686
BETWEEN EDWARD HENRY BAKER and
WHAKAWE CHARLES RAMEKA as trustees of THE THOMAS BAKER WHANAU TRUST
Applicants
AND
WAIMAKUKU WHANAU TRUST BOARD INCORPORATED Respondent
On papers Judgment:
7 April 2014
RESERVED JUDGMENT OF DOBSON J (Costs)
[1] This judgment addresses an outstanding application on behalf of the applicants for a costs order in relation to the substantive hearing against the respondent. I regret the delay in being able to address the matter.
[2] In the substantive judgment dated 27 September 2013, I confirmed the entitlement of the present trustees to recover the cost of the proceedings out of the fund.1 I dismissed the prospect of any order that the fund make a contribution to the costs incurred on behalf of the respondent.
[3] I have dealt separately with an application for costs by the amicus.2
[4] Costs as between the applicant and the respondent for numerous interlocutory steps were determined in a judgment of Associate Judge Gendall on 13 October
1 Baker v Waimakuku Whanau Trust Board Inc [2013] NZHC 2530 at [120]–[123].
BAKER v WAIMAKUKU WHANAU TRUST BOARD INC [2014] NZHC 686 [7 April 2014]
2011.3 That judgment ordered costs against the respondent and Mr Nigel Baker, with a 50 per cent uplift on category 2B costs.
[5] In respect of the substantive aspect of the proceedings, the applicants seek an order for increased costs against the respondent and Mr Nigel Baker jointly and severally. The application is made on the basis that the respondent advanced arguments that were not constructive to the process of settling a trust deed, and that wide-ranging, repetitive and irrelevant material was filed that contributed unnecessarily to the time and expense of the proceedings. Ultimately, the applicants blame the respondent’s conduct for unnecessarily delaying the adoption of an appropriate trust deed for three years, and having imposed unnecessary financial burden on the trust fund.
[6] In submissions on various post-judgment issues, Mr Nee Harland’s stance on behalf of the respondent and Mr Nigel Baker remains the same as it has been throughout: namely, that the respondent and Mr Nigel Baker ought not to have been removed from control of the trust fund as they were by Durie J’s decisions,4 and that the class of beneficiaries has been interpreted too widely to the extent that it includes at least some of those supporting the trust’s present administration. In addition, Mr Nee Harland used these proceedings as a forum in which to attack the competence of one of the interim trustees, and the lineage of another as not qualifying within the whanau of Thomas Baker. In short, there should not be any
costs liability ordered against the respondent, because it is in the right.
[7] I do not accept Mr Bate’s submission as to the application of the usual presumption that a party that “fails” with respect to a proceeding should…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Baker v Waimakuku Whanau Trust Board Incorporated and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] NZHC 686
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Dobson J held that the usual presumption of costs following a "success" or "failure" did not comfortably apply in this context. The court acknowledged the constructive role contradictors often serve in trust disputes. However, the judge found that the respondent's meritless and irrelevant arguments significantly increased the work required on behalf of the applicants. The court ordered that the total costs of the proceedings thus far defrayed out of the fund would be reimbursed to the extent that they were unnecessarily incurred because of the respondent's initiatives, setting that sum at $20,000. The court also noted that while the primary order for costs was against the respondent, there would be an opportunity to extend liability to Mr Nigel Baker if the amount was not paid by the respondent.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi