Alpine Energy Limited v Human Rights Review Tribunal

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND TIMARU REGISTRY

CIV-2014-476-000016 [2014] NZHC 2792

BETWEEN

ALPINE ENERGY LIMITED

Applicant

AND

THE HUMAN RIGHTS REVIEW TRIBUNAL

First Respondent

KEVIN MURRAY WATERS Second Respondent

THE HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSIONER

First Intervener

THE PRIVACY COMMISSIONER Second Intervener

Hearing: 3 October 2014

Appearances:

A Keir for Applicant
Second Respondent K M Waters Appears in Person
MSR Palmer for Human Rights Commissioner
K Evans for Privacy Commissioner

Judgment:

11 November 2014

JUDGMENT OF GENDALL J

ALPINE ENERGY LIMITED v THE HUMAN RIGHTS REVIEW TRIBUNAL [2014] NZHC 2792 [11

November 2014]

Introduction

[1]      The  second  respondent,  Mr Waters,  has  brought  proceedings  against  the applicant, Alpine Energy Ltd (Alpine Energy).1   The basis for the proceeding is that Mr Waters claims Alpine Energy unlawfully discriminated against him on employment applications he had made on the basis of age in contravention of s 22 of the Human Rights Act 1993 (HRA).

[2]      As  part  of  that  proceeding  in  the  Human  Rights  Review  Tribunal  (the Tribunal) Mr Waters had applied for orders that Alpine Energy make further and better discovery.   The information Mr Waters  sought to be discovered  included material   which  Alpine   Energy  claimed   was   confidential.      Nonetheless,   the application was successful before the Tribunal, with Alpine Energy being ordered to disclose various documents.2

[3]      Alpine  Energy now  seeks  judicial  review  of  that  decision.    It  seeks  the following declaratory relief:

(a)       a declaration that the orders of the Tribunal were unlawful; (b)          an order setting aside the orders of the Tribunal;

(c)       a declaration that the applicant’s discovery obligations have been met

in full; and

(d)      costs.

Background

[4]      Previously, Mr Waters was employed by Alpine Energy from 1975 to 2008, when he resigned.    In  2012, he applied for two positions advertised  by Alpine

Energy, these being for an Engineering Officer and a Maintenance Engineer.  At that

1      I note that the Privacy Commissioner was granted leave to intervene by Dunningham J in a minute dated 15 May 2014.   In the  same minute it  was recorded that the Human Rights Commission was permitted to intervene as of right by operation of s 92H Human Rights Act

1993.

2      Waters v Alpine Energy Ltd [2014] NZHRRT 8.

time he was 62 years old.  Both applications were unsuccessful.  He claims his lack of success is age related.

[5]      Mr  Waters,  feeling  aggrieved,  issued  proceedings  in  the  Tribunal.    A preliminary step in such proceedings is for each party to discover documents in its possession or control, on which it intends to rely, which support the opposing party’s case, or which are adverse to its or the opposing party’s case. A list of the documents initially discovered is attached in Annexure A.

[6]      Dissatisfied, Mr Waters applied for further and better discovery, and also for a direction under s 69 of the Evidence Act 2006 requiring disclosure of documents in respect of which Alpine Energy had claimed confidentiality.   Alpine Energy later filed an amended list of documents which identified several relevant documents

which were either released…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Alpine Energy Limited v Human Rights Review Tribunal and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 2792
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Alpine Energy Limited brought an application for judicial review against the Human Rights Review Tribunal's decision to compel it to make further and better discovery to Kevin Murray Waters, who had alleged age discrimination in his unsuccessful applications for two positions at Alpine Energy. The primary issue for the court was whether the Tribunal had the authority to order the disclosure of confidential information under the Human Rights Act 1993 and the Evidence Act 2006. The court found that the Tribunal did have the authority to order the disclosure of confidential information, but the Tribunal had erred in adjudicating on the admissibility of the documents without assessing their precise nature and content.

The court determined that the Tribunal's decision was flawed because it had not properly considered the relevance and probative value of the documents in question. The court held that the principles of fairness and natural justice required proper access to the evidence in order to make a proper decision. Consequently, the application for review succeeded, and the court set aside the Tribunal's orders, remitting the matter back to the Tribunal to be considered afresh. The court provided additional directions for the Tribunal to follow, including provisionally admitting the withheld and redacted documents "in caucus" to permit an informed decision as to admissibility to be made, considering whether it was necessary for Alpine Energy to discover any information regarding unsuccessful applicants, and exploring options to best preserve privacy and confidentiality while ensuring compliance with any order for discovery. The court decided not to make an order as to costs, considering the proceeding to be of public interest and Mr Waters to be self-represented.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established