A v Attorney-General

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

NO PERSON OTHER THAN THE PARTIES TO THE PROCEEDING OR THEIR COUNSEL MAY HAVE ACCESS TO ANY DOCUMENTS ON THE COURT FILE WITHOUT THE PERMISSION OF A JUDGE.

ORDER PROHIBITING PUBLICATION OF THE NAME OR PARTICULARS LIKELY TO LEAD TO THE IDENTIFICATION OF THE APPLICANT UNTIL FURTHER ORDER OF THIS COURT OR THE COURT OF APPEAL.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2013-485-522 [2013] NZHC 988

UNDER  the Judicature Amendment Act 1972

IN THE MATTER OF     an investigation by Paula Rebstock into possible unauthorised disclosure of information about the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade

BETWEEN  A Applicant

ANDHER MAJESTY'S ATTORNEY- GENERAL

First Respondent

ANDPAULA REBSTOCK Second Respondent

Hearing:         30 April 2013

Counsel:         J S McHerron for applicant

U R Jagose and C I J Fleming for respondents

Reissued

Judgment:      15 May 2013 (to be read with addendum of 15 May 2013)

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF DOBSON J

A v ATTORNEY-GENERAL HC WN CIV-2013-485-522 [15 May 2013]

Contents

The factual context ............................................................................................................................ [6] First ground of challenge: report going beyond terms of reference ............................................ [29] “Suspicions” so different as to require separate authorisation? ................................................. [37] “Strong suspicion” not supported by sufficient probative evidence ........................................... [43] Breach of natural justice: inadequate disclosure.......................................................................... [70] Summary .......................................................................................................................................... [91] Scope of on-going suppression........................................................................................................ [96] Costs ............................................................................................................................................... [102]

[1]      In this proceeding, A seeks judicial review of what are presently draft conclusions  reached  by  the  second  respondent  (Ms Rebstock)  in  relation  to  an investigation Ms Rebstock has undertaken into possible unauthorised disclosure, in early May 2012, of Cabinet Committee papers (the Cabinet papers1) addressing possible  changes  at  the  Ministry  of  Foreign  Affairs  and  Trade  (MFAT).    The Attorney-General has been sued in respect of the State Services Commissioner (the

Commissioner) who appointed Ms Rebstock to report to him under s 25 of the State Sector Act 1988 (the Act) in respect of an investigation to be conducted under s 8 of the Act.

[2]      The proceedings were commenced on 10 April 2013.  A pre-commencement application on  behalf  of A resulted  in  orders,  which  were  granted  by  consent, enabling A to pursue the proceedings without disclosure of A’s identity.  Prohibition on publication of any details that might lead to A being identified have been continued and I will address the post substantive determination position at the conclusion of this judgment.

[3]      Because completion of Ms Rebstock’s report was imminent, A applied for interim orders under s 8 of the Judicature Amendment Act 1972 to preserve his position pending substantive determination.  I made such orders on 19 April 2013, in

the context of arrangements for the expedited substantive hearing.2

1      Adopting the shorthand description of the papers used by counsel.

2      A v Attorney-General [2013] NZHC 823.

[4]      The  statement  of  claim  alleged  that  the  scope  of  an  advanced  draft  of Ms Rebstock’s  proposed  report  exceeded  the  scope  of  her  task  that  had  been delineated  in  the  terms  of  reference  under  which  she  was  appointed  and  was therefore unlawful.   It was also alleged that the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read A v Attorney-General and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 988
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, A, sought a judicial review of draft conclusions reached by the second respondent (Ms Rebstock) in relation to an investigation Ms Rebstock conducted into a possible unauthorised disclosure of Cabinet Committee papers addressing possible changes at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade (MFAT). The Attorney-General was sued in respect of the State Services Commissioner who appointed Ms Rebstock to report to him in respect of the investigation. A sought interim orders to preserve his position pending substantive determination. A's grounds for challenging the draft report were: (1) the report exceeded the scope of Ms Rebstock's task; (2) the analysis of factors relied on by Ms Rebstock to justify a "strong suspicion" that A provided unauthorised disclosure was unreasonable; and (3) Ms Rebstock's refusals to provide A with greater detail of the matters likely to be taken into account in forming views adverse to him breached his entitlement to natural justice. The High Court held that Ms Rebstock would not be going beyond her terms of reference and would therefore not exceed her jurisdiction if she completed a report that referred to a strong suspicion she holds that A was responsible for unauthorised disclosure of the Cabinet papers, in the context of an analysis of the grounds for such suspicion. The reliance Ms Rebstock proposes to place on the outcome of her interviews of A, having regard to the manner in which those interviews were conducted and the analysis of other matters cited in relation to the possible identity of the person who leaked the Cabinet papers, do not lead to conclusions that are unreasonable in the administrative law sense. If the intended audience for the completed report is confined to the Commissioner, then in that context there has been no breach of the obligations to comply with the rules of natural justice in the extent of information provided to A. However, if Ms Rebstock intended to report to the Commissioner in a form intended also to be available to the Commissioner for publication, then that materially different context of her investigation and report alters the appropriate content of her natural justice obligations. In that event, the disclosure thus far provided to A would be inadequate. Ms Rebstock could not present a report that it would be lawful for the Commissioner to subsequently publish without Ms Rebstock having provided A and his advisers with the information required, affording A an opportunity to make further submissions in light of that information, and having regard to the responses received before settling the final form of the report. Accordingly, for the most part A's grounds for seeking judicial review of the manner in which Ms Rebstock proposes to complete the report cannot be made out. However, A is entitled to a declaration to the effect that if Ms Rebstock intended to present her report to the Commissioner in a form that the Commissioner would be entitled to publish, then that would involve a breach of relevant rules of natural justice because of inadequate disclosure of information relevant to A's defence of his position. The application for review was conditionally dismissed in reliance on Ms Jagose's argument that the natural justice obligations should be assessed on the basis the report is only to be made privately available to the Commissioner. In the event that either or both of the respondents hereafter form the intention to produce a report intended for publication in respect of the parts addressing the position of A, then they are promptly to give A's legal advisers notice of that intention. Thereafter, the parties will have leave to apply for the definition and argument of additional issues, as they then arise.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established