A v Attorney-General

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

NOTE: HIGH COURT ORDER PROHIBITING PUBLICATION OF THE NAME OR PARTICULARS LIKELY TO LEAD TO THE IDENTIFICATION OF THE APPELLANT, INCLUDING WHERE HE WORKED AT THE TIME AND HAD PREVIOUSLY WORKED, UNTIL FURTHER ORDER OF THE HIGH COURT OR THIS COURT CONTINUES IN EFFECT.

ORDER THAT NO PERSON OTHER THAN THE PARTIES TO THE APPEAL OR THEIR COUNSEL MAY HAVE ACCESS TO ANY DOCUMENTS ON THIS COURT'S FILE WITHOUT THE PERMISSION OF A JUDGE.  ORDER TO CONTINUE IN FORCE UNTIL FURTHER NOTICE OF THIS COURT OR THE HIGH COURT.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA294/2013 [2013] NZCA 289

BETWEEN

A

Appellant

AND

THE ATTORNEY-GENERAL First Respondent

PAULA REBSTOCK Second Respondent

Hearing: 18 June 2013

Court:

O'Regan P, Ellen France and Harrison JJ

Counsel:

J S McHerron for Appellant
U R Jagose and C I J Fleming for Respondents

Judgment:

8 July 2013 at 10 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The appeal is dismissed.

BThe cross-appeal is allowed.  The orders made in the High Court (set out at [8] of the Reasons of the Court) are set aside.

C        We make no order for costs.

A V THE ATTORNEY-GENERAL & ANOR CA294/2013 [2013] NZCA 289 [8 July 2013]

DAn order is made that no person other than the parties to the appeal or their counsel may have access to any documents on this Court’s file without the permission of a Judge.   This order is to continue in force

until further order of this Court or the High Court.

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by O’Regan P)

Table of contents

Para No

Introduction  [1] Issues for determination  [10] Factual background  [13] Terms of reference: “strong suspicion”  [14] Was there probative evidence supporting the finding of

“strong suspicion”  [32]

Natural justice: has adequate disclosure been made to the appellant?            [45] What disclosure has been made?  [47] What additional disclosure is sought?  [49] What is the entitlement?  [58] The appellant’s disclosure requests  [62]

Suppression  [71] Result  [75] Costs  [76]

Introduction

[1]      In May 2012, the opposition spokesperson on Foreign Affairs and Trade, the Hon Phil Goff, asked a question in Parliament that suggested he had obtained information from a Cabinet Committee paper that had been prepared about changes at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade (MFAT).   The State Services Commissioner (the Commissioner), concerned that there appeared to have been an unauthorised  disclosure  of  Cabinet  papers,  appointed  the  second  respondent, Ms Rebstock, to “investigate and  report on the relevant facts  around a possible unauthorised disclosure” of the papers.

[2]      Ms Rebstock has undertaken that investigation and her draft report includes a

statement that she finds that there is a “strong suspicion” that the appellant may have

leaked the Cabinet papers.  She disclosed relevant extracts from the draft report to the appellant for comment.  The appellant then applied to the High Court for judicial review of the draft conclusions reached by Ms Rebstock.  The Attorney-General is sued in respect of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read A v Attorney-General and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZCA 289
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Court of Appeal dismissed an appeal by A against findings of the High Court that the investigation into A’s possible unauthorised disclosure of Cabinet papers was properly conducted and that the draft findings of that investigation were properly based on probative evidence. The Court allowed a cross-appeal by the respondents that there was no requirement to make further disclosure to A before the report was published. The substantive orders of the High Court were set aside. The Court made no order for costs.

The appellant, A, was a clerical assistant in the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade (MFAT). He was interviewed by Ms Paula Rebstock, who had been appointed by the State Services Commissioner to investigate the unauthorised disclosure of three Cabinet papers. Ms Rebstock formed the view that there was a proper basis for strong suspicion that A was responsible for the unauthorised disclosure. She drafted a report containing this view and disclosed extracts from the report to A for comment. A then applied to the High Court for judicial review of the draft report. The Attorney-General was sued in respect of the Commissioner under s 14 of the Crown Proceedings Act 1950. The practical position was that the judicial review application was directed against the Commissioner as the appointer of Ms Rebstock and intended recipient of her report and Ms Rebstock herself.

A appealed against the findings of the High Court that the terms of reference for Ms Rebstock’s investigation allowed her to report that there was a proper basis for strong suspicion that A may have been responsible for the unauthorised disclosure of the Cabinet papers, that Ms Rebstock’s proposed finding was supported by probative evidence and that adequate disclosure had been made to A. The respondents cross-appealed against the finding that further disclosure would be necessary if the report was to be published.

The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal and allowed the cross-appeal. The Court was satisfied that in light of its conclusions the substantive orders of the High Court should be set aside. It made an order to that effect. The Court made no order for costs.

The Court of Appeal found that the terms of reference for Ms Rebstock’s investigation did not limit her to reporting only on proven facts. It found that the finding that there was a proper basis for strong suspicion that A may have leaked the Cabinet papers was supported by probative evidence. It found that adequate disclosure had been made to A, and that there was no requirement to make further disclosure before the report was published.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established