121 Limited (in rec) v AAL Holdings Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA682/2022
 [2024] NZCA 271

BETWEEN

121 LIMITED (IN REC)
Appellant

AND

AAL HOLDINGS LIMITED
First Respondent

AND

PETER JOHN FESLTEAD AITKEN AND PETER LOUIS FELSTEAD
Second Respondents

AND

XIAOLI DAI
Third Respondent

Counsel:

B Hudson (Applicant) in person
I McLennan, Receiver of Appellant
D J Chisholm KC and M J W Lenihan for First Respondent
No appearances for Second and Third Respondents

Judgment:
(On the papers)

26 June 2024 at 11.30 am

JUDGMENT OF COURTNEY J
(Review of Registrar’s Decision)

The application for review is granted.  The amount held as security for costs plus interest is to be returned to the payer, City Ltd.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

Introduction

  1. The appeal in this case was not properly commenced and is not being pursued.  The security for costs was paid by a non-party.  There is a dispute over who is entitled to repayment of the funds.

  2. In December 2021, 121 Ltd filed a notice of appeal against a decision of Jagose J making orders under s 339(1) of the Property Law Act 2007 in respect of a property owned jointly by 121 Ltd, AAL Holdings Ltd (AAL) and the other respondents in this case.[1]  In the High Court, AAL was one of four defendants but the notice of appeal in this Court named AAL as the sole respondent.

  3. Security for costs of $7,060.01 were paid by a non-party, City Ltd.

  4. 121 Ltd did not file the case on appeal within the prescribed time.  It sought an extension of time to do so on the grounds that the second and third respondents had only just been served (although it appeared from a later memorandum filed on behalf of 121 Ltd that they might not, in fact, have been served).  AAL neither consented to nor opposed the application.

  5. The matter was referred to Goddard J, who concluded that because the second and third respondents had not been served at the outset, the appeal had not been brought within time, nor properly brought at all in the absence of confirmation that service on the second and third respondents had been completed.[2]  In May 2023, the Judge directed that no further steps be taken until an extension of time for bringing the appeal had been obtained.  No application for an extension of time was sought.  In August 2023, 121 Ltd went into receivership.

    [2]Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005, r 31.

  6. In September 2023, a Deputy Registrar sought instructions from 121 Ltd and AAL regarding payment out of the money held as security for costs.  The receivers of 121 Ltd and counsel for AAL filed a joint memorandum seeking to have the funds paid to them equally.[3]  In December 2023, the Deputy Registrar confirmed that payment would be made on that basis. 

    [3]The receivers of the 121 Ltd did not engage counsel.  The general rule is that a company…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 121 Limited (in rec) v AAL Holdings Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZCA 271
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

121 Limited (in rec) v AAL Holdings Limited involves a dispute over the disposition of security for costs paid in relation to an appeal that was not properly brought. The appeal in question was filed by 121 Limited against a decision of the High Court regarding a property jointly owned with AAL Holdings Limited and two other respondents. The appeal was filed by 121 Limited, but the notice of appeal incorrectly named AAL Holdings Limited as the sole respondent. Moreover, the appeal was not filed within the prescribed time, and the second and third respondents were not served at the outset. The security for costs of $7,060.01 was paid by a non-party, City Ltd. In September 2023, a Deputy Registrar sought instructions from 121 Limited and AAL Holdings Limited regarding the payment out of the money held as security for costs. The receivers of 121 Limited and counsel for AAL Holdings Limited filed a joint memorandum seeking to have the funds paid to them equally. However, Mr Hudson, a director of 121 Limited, sought a review of the decision, claiming that the funds should be returned to City Ltd as they were paid in trust pending the appeal proceedings.
The legal issues before the Court were whether the security for costs should be returned to the payer, City Ltd, or if it should be divided between the receivers of 121 Limited and AAL Holdings Limited. The Court of Appeal considered the status of security for costs paid by a third party in respect of an appeal that was not properly brought. The Court noted that security for costs is held and disposed of at the direction of the Court in accordance with the rule or statutory provisions under which it has been paid. Since the appeal was not properly commenced, the purpose for which City Ltd paid the security for costs no longer exists. Therefore, the funds are correctly viewed as being held by the Court for the benefit of City Ltd and should be paid to it.

The Court granted the application for review and ordered that the amount held as security for costs plus interest be returned to the payer, City Ltd. The Court noted that Mr Hudson, who sought the review, was not represented, so no issue as to costs arises. This decision highlights the importance of properly commencing an appeal and the Court's discretion in the disposition of security for costs in such circumstances.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established