Zurich Australian Insurance Limited v Mestric

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Zurich Australian Insurance Limited v Mestric [2016] NSWSC 187
Hearing dates:17 July 2015
Decision date: 08 March 2016
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Adams J
Decision:

(1) Summons dismissed.

 (2) Plaintiff to pay the first defendant’s costs.
Catchwords: Motor accidents claim – assessor’s certificate that neck injury not caused by accident because of lack of contemporaneous complaint – issue not brought to claimant’s attention – whether breach of procedural fairness – whether unfair – referred for reassessment – whether affected by legal error
Legislation Cited: Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 (NSW), ss 62, 62(1)(b)
Cases Cited: Allianz Australia Insurance Limited v Motor Accidents Authority of NSW [2006] NSWSC 1096
Frost v Kourouche [2014] NSWCA 39; 86 NSWLR 214
Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang [1996] HCA 6; 185 CLR 259
NRMA Insurance Limited v Ainsworth [2011] NSWSC 344; 58 MVR 187
Trazivuk v Motor Accidents Authority of New South Wales & Ors [2010] NSWCA 287
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Zurich Australian Insurance Limited (plaintiff)
Natali Mestric (first defendant)
Motor Accidents Authority of New South Wales (second defendant)
John Turnbull, in his capacity as a claims assessor of the Motor Accidents Authority of New South Wales (third defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
M Robinson SC/ R O’Keffe (plaintiff)
K Rewell SC/ J Gumbert (first defendant)

  Solicitors:
Vardanega Roberts (plaintiff)
Stacks Gouldkamp (first defendant)
Crown Solicitor for NSW – submitting appearance (second and third defendants)
File Number(s):2015/5796

Judgment

Introduction

  1. Ms Natali Mestric claimed damages from Zurich Australian Insurance Limited under the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 (NSW) for injuries suffered by her as a result of a motor car accident on 5 August 2008. There was a dispute as to the extent of her permanent impairment, so the matter was referred to the Motor Accidents Authority of New South Wales for medical assessment. The latest assessment of Ms Mestric’s injuries was that of Dr Fearnside who saw her on 24 May 2013 and issued a certificate with reasons on 4 June 2013 concluding that injuries claimed to have been suffered by Ms Mestric in respect of her neck and left leg were not caused by the accident. The primary basis for this conclusion was the “lack of contemporaneous evidence for a neck injury”. At Ms Mestric’s request, Mr John Turnbull, a claims assessor, considered whether the matter should be referred back to the Medical Assessment Service for reassessment. Mr Turnbull decided that Ms Mestric had not been afforded procedural fairness and that the matter should be referred for reassessment. The insurer, Zurich Australian Insurance Limited, commenced proceedings in this Court for prerogative relief on the basis that Mr Turnbull’s decision was affected by a jurisdictional error and/or errors of law on the face of the record. The Motor Accidents Authority and Mr Turnbull, who were joined respectively as second and third defendants, have filed submitting appearances.

  2. Section 62 of the Act provides, so far as is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Zurich Australian Insurance Limited v Mestric and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NSWSC 187
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Zurich Australian Insurance Limited sought to recover payments made in relation to a motor accident claim from the insured, Mr Mestric. The insurer argued that an assessor’s certificate stating that Mr Mestric’s neck injury was not caused by the accident, because of the lack of a contemporaneous complaint, meant that the insurer was not liable for the payments. The insurer claimed that the assessor’s certificate was not unfair or unreasonable, and that there was no breach of procedural fairness. Mr Mestric responded that the issue of the contemporaneous complaint was not brought to his attention, and that the certificate was unfair and unreasonable. He argued that there was a breach of procedural fairness, and that the certificate was affected by a legal error. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The legal issues in the case were whether the assessor’s certificate was unfair or unreasonable, whether there was a breach of procedural fairness, and whether the certificate was affected by a legal error. The court found that the issue of the contemporaneous complaint was not brought to Mr Mestric’s attention, and that the certificate was therefore unfair and unreasonable. The court held that there was a breach of procedural fairness, and that the certificate was affected by a legal error. The court referred the matter back to the insurer for reassessment.

The court held that the assessor’s certificate was unfair and unreasonable because the issue of the contemporaneous complaint was not brought to Mr Mestric’s attention. The court found that the insurer had a duty to ensure that the claimant was aware of the basis for the assessor’s certificate, and that this duty was not fulfilled in this case. The court held that there was a breach of procedural fairness, because Mr Mestric was not given an opportunity to respond to the issue of the contemporaneous complaint. The court found that the certificate was affected by a legal error, because the assessor did not have the power to make a finding about the causation of the injury based on the lack of a contemporaneous complaint. The court referred the matter back to the insurer for reassessment, so that the issue of the contemporaneous complaint could be properly considered.

The court ordered that the matter be referred back to the insurer for reassessment, and that the insurer bear the costs of the proceedings. The court did not make any orders in relation to the liability of the insurer for the payments made in relation to the motor accident claim.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established