Zhao v Monlea Pty Ltd t/as Nordex Interiors

Link copied
Case Copied 57 min read

APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR
__________________________________________________________________

CITATION: Yu Cang Zhao v Monlea Pty Ltd trading as Nordex Interiors
[2003] WCC PD11
APPELLANT: Yu Cang Zhao
RESPONDENT: Monlea Pty Ltd trading as Nordex Interiors
INSURER: Allianz Australia Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited
FILE NO: WCC302 – 2002
DATE OF DECISION: 16 April, 2003
PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER: Deputy President Gary Byron
DECISION UNDER APPEAL: The Applicant did not receive an injury arising out of or in the course of his employment as he was not a worker within the meaning of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998.
DATE OF DECISION UNDER APPEAL: 30 October, 2002
HEARING: 7 March, 2003
REPRESENTATION: Appellant:
Mr. B. Sullivan instructed by Keddies Litigation Lawyers
Respondent:

Mr. D. Dickinson instructed by Dexter Healey, Solicitors

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL: The Appeal is not allowed.  The decision appealed against is confirmed.  No order is made as to costs

THE APPEAL

  1. On 29 November, 2002, the Applicant Yu Cang Zhao (‘the Appellant’) lodged an appeal with the Workers Compensation Commission (‘the Commission’) against a decision made by the Commission constituted by an Arbitrator, that he did not receive an injury arising out of or in the course of his employment with Monlea Pty Ltd trading as Nordex Interiors (‘the Respondent’) as he was not a worker within the meaning of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (‘the Act’) and consequently, the Respondent is not liable for the Applicant’s claim for weekly compensation.

  2. Having made this decision, the Arbitrator stated that it was unnecessary for her to determine the other issues in dispute, as having determined that the Applicant (Appellant) was not a worker within the meaning of the Act she lacked the jurisdiction to make the orders sought. The issues in dispute before the Arbitrator, as summarised by her, were:

    ·    Is the Applicant a worker as defined? (WIMWCA s 4)

    ·    Did the Applicant receive an injury arising out of or in the course of employment? (WCA s 9) (WCA s 10)

    ·    Was the Applicant totally or partially incapacitated for work as a result of his or her (sic) injuries? (WCA s 33)

    ·    Is the Applicant precluded from compensation because the Applicant failed to provide notice of injury to the employer as soon as possible after the injury? (WIMWCA s 254)

    ·    Is the Applicant precluded from compensation because he failed to make the claim within the 6 month limitation period?

    The reference ‘WCA’ is to  the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (‘the 1987 Act’).

THE ISSUES IN DISPUTE IN THE APPEAL

  1. The Appellant’s “grounds of appeal” were lodged with and were attached to the document, “Appeal Against Decision of Arbitrator”, received in the Commission on 29 November, 2002.  They were repeated in further documents lodged by the Appellant in the Commission on 12 December, 2002, in response to Directions issued on 3 December, 2002.  The grounds are stated as follows:

    (1)The Arbitrator erred in finding that the Applicant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Zhao v Monlea Pty Ltd t/as Nordex Interiors and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] NSWWCCPD 11
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Zhao v Monlea Pty Ltd t/as Nordex Interiors involved the applicant, Yu Cang Zhao, seeking workers' compensation against the respondent, Monlea Pty Ltd trading as Nordex Interiors. The applicant alleged that he had suffered an injury arising out of or in the course of his employment, and therefore sought compensation under the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998. The Commission constituted by an Arbitrator dismissed the applicant's claim on the basis that he was not a worker within the meaning of the Act.

The central legal issue for the Commission was whether the applicant, Yu Cang Zhao, was a worker under the Act, thereby entitling him to compensation. The Arbitrator had determined that the applicant was not a worker, and as a result, his claim for compensation was dismissed. The Commission constituted by the Arbitrator did not consider the medical reports as they were not necessary to determine the jurisdictional issue. Instead, the Arbitrator focused on whether the applicant had provided sufficient evidence of his employment status, specifically, evidence of payment.

The Commission, in its review of the Arbitrator's decision, examined the evidence presented by both parties. The Arbitrator had noted that the applicant had not provided certain documentary evidence of payment as required by the relevant rules and had not declared an intention to rely on such evidence. Consequently, the Arbitrator had decided not to consider the additional evidence submitted by the applicant, finding that allowing it would be unjust given the circumstances. The Commission upheld the Arbitrator's decision, confirming that the applicant was not a worker within the meaning of the Act and dismissing the appeal.

The final orders of the Commission were that the appeal was not allowed, and the decision of the Arbitrator was confirmed. No order was made as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Appeal is not allowed. The decision appealed against is confirmed. No order is made as to costs

Background

Background to the litigation

Yu Cang Zhao, the applicant, sought compensation under the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (WIMWCA) from Monlea Pty Ltd t/as Nordex Interiors, the respondent. The applicant claimed that he suffered an injury arising out of and in the course of his employment with the respondent. The Arbitrator found that the applicant did not receive an injury arising out of or in the course of his employment as he was not a worker within the meaning of the Act. The Arbitrator's decision was based on jurisdictional grounds, and the applicant subsequently appealed this decision.

The applicant initially filed a claim with the Commission constituted by an Arbitrator, who issued a decision on 30 October 2002. The applicant was dissatisfied with the Arbitrator's decision and sought leave to appeal, which was granted on 14 February 2003. The appeal was set down for hearing at the Commission on 7 March 2003. The appellant was represented by Mr. B. O’Sullivan, instructed by Keddies Litigation Lawyers, while the respondent was represented by Mr. D. Dickinson, instructed by Dexter Healey Solicitors. The appeal was heard and determined by the Commission.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 352 of the Act provides:352Appeal against decision of Commission constituted by Arbitrator(1)A party to a dispute in connection with a claim for compensation may, with leave of the Commission constituted by a Presidential member, appeal to the Commission as so constituted against a decision in respect of the dispute by the Commission constituted by an Arbitrator.(2)The Commission is not to grant leave to appeal unless the amount of compensation at issue on the appeal is both:(a)at least $5,000 (or such other amount as may be prescribed by the regulations), and(b)at least 20% of the amount awarded in the decision appealed against.(3)If the Commission refuses to grant leave to appeal, the Commission must state reasons for the refusal in writing to the parties.(4)An appeal can only be made within 28 days after the making of the decision appealed against.(5)An appeal under this section is to be by way of review of the decision appealed against.(6)Evidence that is fresh evidence or evidence in addition to or in substitution for the evidence received in relation to the decision appealed against may not be given on an appeal to the Commission except with the leave of the Commission.(7)On appeal, the decision may be confirmed or may be revoked and a new decision made in its place.(8)In this section, decision includes an award, interim award, order, determination, ruling and direction. Leave to appeal was granted on 14 February, 2003. The matter was set down for hearing at the Commission on 7 March, 2003. On that date, Mr. B. O’Sullivan instructed by Keddies Litigation Lawyers appeared for the Appellant and Mr. D. Dickinson instructed by Dexter Healey Solicitors appeared for the Respondent. The evidence before the Commission constituted by the Arbitrator is detailed in her ‘Statement of Reasons for Decision’ (‘reasons’) dated 30 October, 2002. A ‘Certificate of Determination’ was issued on the same date. That evidence is before me on appeal and is comprised of:For the Applicant·Statement of Yu Cang Zhao dated 19 September, 2002·Sworn oral evidence of Yu Cang Zhao taken before the Arbitrator and set out in the transcript of the proceedings which were recorded·Record of Hours – 3 May, 2000 – 30 June, 2000·Invoices for work – 15 August, 2001 and 28 September, 2001·Notes of Payment – 1 July, 2001 – 16 September, 2001The Arbitrator, in referring to the documentary evidence said:“Medical reports were in evidence however it was unnecessary to have regard to them in making the determination as the claim was determined on a jurisdictional point.The applicant sought to rely upon documentary evidence not provided in the application and for which no statement had been made pursuant to section 290 of the WIMWCA 1998 and Rule 16 of the Interim Rules of the Commission. The documents are a private record of hours worked per day for the period 3/5/00 to 30/6/00, and invoices for periods Invoices for work (sic) 15/8/01; 28/9/01 and also personal notes of payment for the period 1/7/01 to 16/9/01. The fundamental issue to be determined is whether the applicant is a worker. Evidence of payment is therefore critical to the claim. The applicant did not provide those documents, nor make any statement of an intention to rely on such documents in the application. It is therefore necessary, in special circumstances where “employment” is disputed to allow the introduction of the evidence pursuant to Interim Rule 16, sub-rule 3 in order to avoid an injustice.”For the Respondent·Statement of Roland Nilsson dated 12 June, 2002·Statement of Darren Carre dated 13 June, 2002·Individual Tax Returns for Yu Cang Zhao for the years ended 30 June, 1999, 2000 and 2001·Business Activity Statement of Yu Cang Zhao for the period 1 July, 2001 – 30 September, 2001·GIO Insurance ClaimIn relation to the documentary evidence the Arbitrator said:“The respondent sought to rely on further evidence after the close of the hearing. This evidence was not considered as it was not properly before the Commission, the hearing had closed pending legal submissions.Medical Reports were in evidence however it was unnecessary to have regard to them in making the determination as the claim was determined on a jurisdictional point.”At paragraph 38 of her reasons, the Arbitrator further stated:The respondent in turn also sought to rely upon documentary evidence not provided in the reply and for which no statement had been made declaring an intention to rely on such evidence pursuant to section 290 of the WIMWCA 1998 and Rule 27 of the Interim Rules of the Commission. The respondent sought to rely upon the applicant’s individual Tax Returns for the years ended June 30 1999/2000/2001, Business Activity Statement for the period 1/7/01 – 30/9/01 and a Personal Accident claim to GIO. As the applicant had introduced additional evidence in respect of his payment, I find that in these special circumstances, there would be an injustice if the documents were not allowed. The documents are of direct relevance to the issues in dispute.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the definition of a 'worker' under the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 to determine whether the applicant was entitled to workers' compensation. The court found that the applicant was not a worker as defined by the Act, as he did not receive an injury arising out of or in the course of his employment. This conclusion was based on the jurisdictional point that the applicant did not qualify as a worker under the Act.

Regarding the documentary evidence, the court considered whether the Commission constituted by the Arbitrator erred in refusing to consider certain documents. The court held that the Arbitrator did not err in refusing to consider the additional documentary evidence from both parties, as the evidence was not properly before the Commission and the hearing had closed pending legal submissions. The court found that it was not necessary to consider the additional evidence as the claim was determined on a jurisdictional point.

The court applied the provisions of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 and the Interim Rules of the Commission in its analysis. The court found that the decision of the Arbitrator was in accordance with the law and that there was no error in the Arbitrator's refusal to consider the additional documentary evidence. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a party cannot rely on additional documentary evidence not provided in the application and for which no statement has been made pursuant to section 290 of the WIMWCA 1998 and Rule 16 of the Interim Rules of the Commission, unless special circumstances exist to avoid an injustice.