Zhang v The Age Company Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
COURT OF APPEAL

Case Title:

Zhang v The Age Company Pty Ltd

Citation:

[2023] ACTCA 10

Hearing Date:

11 November 2022

DecisionDate:

21 February 2023

Before:

McCallum CJ, Mossop and Kennett JJ

Decision:

1.   Appeal dismissed with costs.

2.   The pseudonym orders made by McCallum CJ on 28 September 2022 are discharged.

Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – ACCESS TO AFFIDAVITS READ IN CLOSED COURT – Appeal against decision allowing a media organisation access to affidavits read in closed court – where court closed by application of the Director of Public Prosecutions under s 243(5) of the Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act 2003 (ACT) – where access sought in circumstances where substantive proceedings resolved by consent – where access not opposed by Director or Commissioner of the AFP – whether primary judge erred in application of the open justice principle – whether primary judge failed to consider relevant matters – consideration of the open justice principle – appeal dismissed with costs – pseudonym orders discharged

Legislation Cited:

Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act 2003 (ACT), ss 35, 36, 98D, 191, 243, 252, Div 4.2,

Constitution (Cth), s 77(iii)
Court Procedures Act 2004 (ACT), ss 5A, 72
Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT), r 2903
Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth), s 93.2
Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT), ss 50, 73, 74, 111
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth)
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), ss 37AE, 37AF
National Security Information (Criminal and Civil Proceedings) Act 2004 (Cth)

Supreme Court Act 1933 (ACT), s 37E(4)

Cases Cited:

Appleroth v Ferrari Australasia Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 756

Application of Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd; NSW Crime Commission v Yucel [2017] NSWSC 1779
ASIC v Rich [2001] NSWSC 496; 51 NSWLR 643
ASIC v Rich [2002] NSWSC 198
Attorney‑General v Leveller Magazine [1979] AC 440
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v ABB Transmission and Distribution Limited (No 3) [2002] FCA 609
Baptist Union of Queensland – Carinity v Roberts [2015] FCA 1068; 241 FCR 135
Cargill Australia Ltd v Viterra Malt Pty Ltd (No 23) [2019] VSC 417; 58 VR 611
Daubney v Cooper (1829) 10 B & C 237; 109 ER 438
Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Lee [2022] FCA 1307
Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Shi (No 2) [2019] FCA 503
Dickason v Dickason (1913) 17 CLR 50
Director of Public Prosecutions (ACT) v Shui (a pseudonym) (No 2) [2022] ACTSC 260
Dring v Cape Intermediate Holdings Ltd [2020] AC 629
Hogan v Australian Crime Commission [2010] HCA 21; 240 CLR 651
Hogan v Hinch [2011] HCA 4; 243 CLR 506
House v The King (1937) 55 CLR 499
John Fairfax & Sons Ltd v The Police Tribunal of New South Wales (1986) 5 NSWLR 465
John Fairfax Publications Pty Ltd v Ryde Local Court [2005] NSWCA 101; 62 NSWLR 512
Kenyon v Eastwood (1888) 57 LJQB 455
Llewellyn v Nine Network [2006] FCA 836; 154 FCR…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Zhang v The Age Company Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ACTCA 10
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Grace Zhang appealed to the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory against a decision of a single judge who granted The Age Company Pty Ltd access to two affidavits that had been read in closed court in support of an application for a restraining order under the *Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act 2003* (ACT). The underlying proceedings had been resolved by consent orders made on a without admissions basis. The appellant contended that the primary judge erred in granting access and sought to have the application dismissed. The appeal was heard by McCallum CJ, Mossop and Kennett JJ.

The central legal issues before the Full Court were whether the primary judge erred in applying the principle of open justice when granting access to the affidavits, and whether the primary judge failed to consider all relevant matters in reaching that decision. The court also considered the implications of the proceedings having been conducted in closed court pursuant to an application under s 243(5) of the *Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act 2003* (ACT), and the effect of the subsequent resolution of the substantive proceedings by consent orders. The court also addressed the discharge of pseudonym orders that had been made to protect the appellant's identity during the pendency of the appeal.

The Full Court dismissed the appeal, upholding the primary judge's decision to grant access to the affidavits. The court reasoned that the principle of open justice, a cornerstone of the administration of justice, generally favours public access to court documents, even those initially filed in closed proceedings, particularly once the substantive matters have been resolved. The court found that the primary judge had correctly balanced the competing interests, including the public interest in transparency and the need for confidentiality in certain circumstances, and had not failed to consider relevant matters. The court concluded that the pseudonym orders were no longer warranted given the dismissal of the appeal and ordered their discharge.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 26 March 2021, the Director of Public Prosecutions (ACT) applied to the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory for a restraining order in relation to certain property of Grace Zhang and three other persons. The application was supported by an affidavit of Constable James Johnston affirmed 24 March 2021 which was read in support of the application. The proceedings were brought ex parte, being conducted as "restricted access proceedings" under the Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act 2003 (ACT). As a result of an application under s 243(5) of the Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act, the proceedings took place in closed court. A further restraining order was made on 10 May 2021 in relation to certain property interests of another person and a company associated with Ms Zhang. The supporting affidavit for this application was another affidavit of Constable Johnston affirmed 5 May 2021. The proceedings were heard ex parte and, as a result of an application under s 243(5) of the Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act the application was heard in closed court. On 17 September 2021 a journalist employed by the respondent sought access, by email to the court registry, to the affidavit relied upon for the purposes of the hearing on 10 May 2021. On 28 September 2021 the substantive proceedings were resolved by consent orders made pursuant to s 252 of the Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act. The orders were made on a "without admissions" basis. They included an order that Ms Zhang’s interests in an ACT property be forfeited to the Territory and the making of an "unexplained wealth order" in the sum of $2,250,000 pursuant to s 98D of the Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act. On 14 October 2021 the respondent made a formal application to the court seeking that leave be granted to uplift and copy the affidavit relied upon at the hearing on 10 May 2021. The application was subsequently amended to seek access to both of the Johnston affidavits. After that, evidence and written submissions were filed on behalf of Ms Zhang, the respondent, the Director and the Commissioner of the Australian Federal Police (AFP). The Director neither consented to nor opposed the granting of access. The Commissioner of the AFP did not object to the provision of access so long as it was to versions of the affidavits with certain personal information redacted. The application was heard before the primary judge on 10 and 17 December 2021. An order was made granting access to the redacted versions of the two affidavits of Constable Johnston on 24 March 2022. Reasons for that order were published on 6 April 2022. Ms Zhang appealed against that decision. The appeal was dismissed with costs. The pseudonym orders made by McCallum CJ on 28 September 2022 were discharged.

This is an appeal from a decision of Loukas-Karlsson J in the ACT Supreme Court, which allowed The Age Company Pty Ltd, a media organisation, to access two affidavits that had been read in support of an ex parte application for a restraining order under the Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act 2003 (ACT). The appeal was heard by McCallum CJ, Mossop, and Kennett JJ in the ACT Court of Appeal. The appellant, Grace Zhang, contended that the primary judge erred in applying the open justice principle and allowing access to the affidavits. The appeal was dismissed with costs, and the pseudonym orders were discharged.

The proceedings began when the Director of Public Prosecutions (ACT) applied for a restraining order under the Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act 2003 (ACT) in relation to certain property of Grace Zhang and three other persons. The application was supported by two affidavits of Constable James Johnston, which were read in closed court. The proceedings were conducted as "restricted access proceedings" under the Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act 2003 (ACT), which allowed the proceedings to take place in closed court at the request of the Director. The substantive proceedings were later resolved by consent orders made on a "without admissions" basis.

In October 2021, The Age Company Pty Ltd made a formal application to the court seeking access to the two Johnston affidavits. The application was subsequently amended to seek access to both affidavits. After evidence and written submissions were filed on behalf of the appellant, the respondent, the Director, and the Commissioner of the Australian Federal Police (AFP), the application was heard before the primary judge on 10 and 17 December 2021. An order was made granting access to the redacted versions of the two affidavits of Constable Johnston on 24 March 2022. Reasons for that order were published on 6 April 2022.

The appeal was heard on 11 November 2022, and the decision was handed down on 21 February 2023. The appeal was dismissed with costs, and the pseudonym orders were discharged. The Court of Appeal found that the primary judge did not err in applying the open justice principle and allowing access to the affidavits. The Court held that the open justice principle is a normative principle rather than a legal rule and that it must be balanced against other principles of justice which protect the interests of parties to litigation. In this case, the Court found that the open justice principle did apply, and the primary judge did not err in granting access to the affidavits after considering all relevant matters.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the open justice principle applies to affidavits used in closed court proceedings.
2. Whether the primary judge erred in determining that the open justice principle did not preclude the granting of access to the affidavits.
3. Whether the primary judge erred in relying on statements of principle concerning the application of the open justice principle where that principle had no application to the proceedings or the affidavits.
4. Whether the primary judge failed to consider relevant matters when deciding whether to grant access to the affidavits.
5. Whether the primary judge erred in finding that the appellant was not at risk of any future prosecution.

Held
1. The court concluded that the open justice principle applied to the affidavits used in the closed court proceedings, despite the fact that they were not used or deployed in open court. The appeal against this conclusion was dismissed.
2. The court determined that the primary judge did not err in finding that the open justice principle did not preclude the granting of access to the affidavits. The appeal against this conclusion was dismissed.
3. The court found that the primary judge did not err in relying on statements of principle concerning the application of the open justice principle, even though the principle had no direct application to the proceedings or the affidavits. The appeal against this conclusion was dismissed.
4. The court concluded that the primary judge did not fail to consider relevant matters when deciding whether to grant access to the affidavits. The appeal against this conclusion was dismissed.
5. The court determined that the primary judge did not err in finding that the appellant was not at risk of any future prosecution. The appeal against this conclusion was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the appeal against the decision of the primary judge who granted access to two affidavits used in closed court proceedings under the Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act 2003 (ACT) (COCA Act). The primary judge had made the order permitting access to the affidavits after the underlying proceedings had been resolved by agreement and on a without admissions basis between the ACT Director of Public Prosecutions and the appellant. The court found that the appeal should be dismissed with costs and that the pseudonym orders made by McCallum CJ should be discharged.

The court first considered whether the open justice principle applied to affidavits used in closed court proceedings. The court found that the open justice principle is a normative principle which applies to court proceedings and the principle does not disappear merely because a court is closed. The court held that the open justice principle remained applicable to the affidavits used in closed court proceedings and that the primary judge did not err in applying the principle when determining the application for access to the affidavits.

The court then considered whether the primary judge erred in determining that the open justice principle did not preclude the granting of access to the affidavits. The court found that the primary judge had not erred in her determination as the open justice principle was applicable to the circumstances of the case. The court also found that the primary judge had not erred in relying on statements of principle concerning the application of the open justice principle where that principle had application to the proceedings or the affidavits.

Next, the court considered whether the primary judge failed to consider relevant matters when deciding whether to grant access to the affidavits. The court found that the primary judge had considered all relevant matters as discussed above, including the particular nature of COCA Act proceedings as was underlined by the DPP to be "unique". The court also found that the primary judge had considered the various matters identified by the appellant and had given appropriate weight to each of them in determining the application for access to the affidavits.

Finally, the court considered whether the primary judge erred in finding that the appellant was not at risk of any future prosecution. The court found that the primary judge had not erred in her finding as there was only a theoretical possibility of prosecutions elsewhere without specifically identifying or developing prejudice in that regard.

In conclusion, the court found that the primary judge had not erred in applying the open justice principle, in determining that the principle did not preclude the granting of access to the affidavits, in considering relevant matters when deciding whether to grant access to the affidavits, and in finding that the appellant was not at risk of any future prosecution. Therefore, the appeal should be dismissed with costs and the pseudonym orders made by McCallum CJ should be discharged.