Zhang v Canterbury City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales

          CITATION:
Zhang v Canterbury City Council [1999] NSWLEC 209
          PARTIES
APPLICANT/RESPONDENT:
Julie Zhang
RESPONDENT/APPELLANT:
Canterbury City Council
          NUMBER:
10748 of 1998 and 10749 of 1998
          CORAM:
Talbot J
          KEY ISSUES:
Section 56A Appeal :- failure to give real consideration to DCP - onus of proof - time limited consent to enable assessment of impact
          LEGISLATION CITED:
Land and Environment Court Act 1979 s 56A
          DATES OF HEARING:
09/06/1999
          DATE OF JUDGMENT DELIVERY:

09/08/1999
          LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:


APPLICANT/RESPONDENT:
Mr P W Larkin (Barrister)

SOLICITORS:
Steven Klinger

RESPONDENT/APPELLANT:
Mr W R Davison SC

SOLICITORS:
Pike Pike and Fenwick


    JUDGMENT:

    IN THE LAND AND Matter No. 10748-9 of 1998
    ENVIRONMENT COURT Coram: Talbot J
    OF NEW SOUTH WALES Decision Date: 8 September 1999

    Julie Zhang
    Applicant/Respondent
    v
    Canterbury City Council

    Respondent/Appellant

    REASONS FOR JUDGMENT


    1. In a reserved judgment dated 11 March 1999, Commissioner Brown upheld an appeal against the refusal of a development application for the use of part of a building at the rear of 303 Beamish Street, Campsie as a brothel.

    2. The council, represented by Mr Davison SC, has appealed against the Commissioner’s decision pursuant to s 56A of the Land and Environment Court Act 1979.

    The Commissioner’s judgment

    3. Having identified the site and described the building and the location of the brothel within it, the Commissioner described the environs of the land, including the St Philips Uniting Church immediately to the east of the subject site. He referred to a church building and two community halls.

    4. A chronological history provided by the Commissioner shows that development consent to use the premises for “Body Massage and Relaxation Centre” was granted for 12 months on 8 July 1996 and extension of the use, including a brothel, had been under consideration since the expiration of that consent.

    5. It was acknowledged that DCP 23 applied and the Commissioner set out the general objectives as well as the objectives and standards contained in cl 4. DCP 23 is directed to the control of development legalised by State Parliament under the Disorderly Houses (Amendment) Act 1995.

    6. In particular cl 4 of DCP 23 provides “(a) brothel should not be located adjoining or within 200 m walking distance of any place of worship, school, community facility, childcare centre, hospital, rail station, bus stop, taxi stand, or any place regularly frequented by children for recreational or cultural pursuits” .

    7. The aim of this standard can be identified by reference to the stated objective to ensure that brothels are located at a reasonable distance from residential occupancies and other sensitive land uses.

    8. There is a note to the DCP which indicates that if there are circumstances when it is not relevant to comply with the locational standard, applicants must provide a written submission detailing the reasons why this standard should be varied.

    9. The Commissioner made the following observation at p 9 of the judgment:-
          While the Council’s case was based, to a large…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Zhang v Canterbury City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] NSWLEC 209
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Julie Zhang, the applicant, sought development consent from the Canterbury City Council for the use of part of a building at 303 Beamish Street, Campsie, as a brothel. The Council refused the application on the basis of its incompatibility with the Development Control Plan (DCP) 23. The applicant appealed to the Land and Environment Court (LEC), which upheld the appeal and allowed the development with a 12-month time limit. The Council has appealed the LEC’s decision.

The key issues in this appeal revolve around the interpretation and application of the DCP 23, the onus of proof, and the conditions under which time-limited consent can be granted. The Council argued that the LEC failed to give proper consideration to the DCP, misapplied relevant case law, and incorrectly placed the onus of proof on the Council. Furthermore, the Council contended that the LEC erred in granting a time-limited approval without properly considering the likely impacts of the development and the suitability of the site.

The Court found that the LEC erred in its consideration of the DCP 23. The Court held that the Commissioner failed to give proper, genuine, and realistic consideration to the DCP, particularly its requirement for separation from other sensitive uses. The Court also found that the Commissioner misapplied the relevant case law by requiring the Council to demonstrate the severity of the impact rather than requiring the applicant to provide reasons for varying the standard. The Court further determined that the Commissioner incorrectly placed the onus of proof on the Council rather than the applicant. Lastly, the Court held that the LEC erred in granting a time-limited approval without properly considering the likely impacts of the development and the suitability of the site.

The appeal is upheld, and the matter is remitted to the Commissioner for determination in accordance with the Court’s decision. The Canterbury City Council is entitled to an order for costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established