Yun yun AI Baby camera Co Ltd v Sim2 Multimedia S.P.A

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Sim2 Multimedia S.P.A to application under reg 17A.48C of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth) by Yun yun AI Baby camera Co Ltd for cessation of protection of Protected International Trade Mark number 1609772 (International Registration number 1194106) (classes 9 and 11) - CUBO - in the name of SIM2 Multimedia S.P.A.

Delegate: Benjamin Goldsworthy
Representation: Opponent: Griffith Hack
Applicant: Pipers Intellectual Property
Decision: 2023 ATMO 1
Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – application under reg 17A.48C of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth) for cessation of protection for goods in class 9 – no evidence of use of the trade mark – exercise of Registrar’s discretion not appropriate – protection of trade mark to cease in respect of class 9

Background

  1. This matter concerns an application (‘Removal Application’) under reg 17A.48C of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth)[1] for cessation of protection for non-use of the following protected international trade mark (‘IRDA’) 1609772 for CUBO (‘Trade Mark’) in the name of SIM2 MULTIMEDIA S.P.A (‘Removal Opponent’). Other relevant details of the Trade Mark follow:

    Priority Date (Convention): 18 October 2013

    Filing Date: 30 October 2013

    Specification: Class 9: Apparatus for recording, transmission or reproduction of sound or images; magnetic data carriers, recording discs; compact discs, DVDs and other digital recording media; mechanisms for coin-operated apparatus; cash registers, calculating machines, data processing equipment and computers; computer software; fire-extinguishing apparatus

    Class 11: Apparatus for heating, steam generating, cooking, refrigerating, drying, ventilating

    [1] All references in this decision to sections are to sections in the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (‘Act’) and all references to regulations are to regulations in the Trade Mark Regulations 1995 (Cth) (‘Regulations’).

  2. On 18 March 2021 Yun yun AI Baby camera Co Ltd (‘Removal Applicant’) filed the Removal Application with this office. It seeks cessation of protection for non-use of the Trade Mark for all of the goods in class 9.

  3. The Removal Application was advertised for opposition purposes on 19 March 2021. The Removal Opponent filed a notice of intention to oppose on 13 May 2021 and a statement of grounds and particulars (‘SGP’) on 8 June 2021.

  4. The Removal Applicant filed a notice of intention to defend the Removal Application on 10 August 2021. The Removal Opponent filed evidence in support (‘EIS’) of its opposition on 15 November 2021. The Removal Applicant did not file evidence in answer.

  5. Both parties requested to be heard via written submissions and a nominal hearing date was scheduled for 29 August 2022. The Removal Opponent provided written submissions on 12 August 2022 and the Removal Applicant filed its written submissions on 22 August 2022. The matter was later allocated to me to decide in my capacity as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks.

    Evidence

  6. The Removal Opponent provided a single declaration in evidence which was dated 8 November 2021 and made by Maurizio Cini (‘Cini Declaration’). The Cini…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Yun yun AI Baby camera Co Ltd v Sim2 Multimedia S.P.A and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ATMO 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Yunyun AI Baby Camera Co Ltd (the Removal Applicant) seeking the cessation of protection for Sim2 Multimedia S.P.A's (the Removal Opponent) trade mark in respect of goods in Class 9. The application was brought under regulation 17A.48C of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth), alleging non-use of the trade mark. The decision was made by Benjamin Goldsworthy, a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks.

The primary legal issue before the delegate was whether the Removal Opponent had provided sufficient evidence to demonstrate use of the trade mark in Australia for goods in Class 9, thereby justifying the exercise of discretion to allow the trade mark to remain on the Register. The delegate also considered a preliminary issue regarding the admissibility of certain evidence filed by the Removal Opponent.

In reaching his decision, the delegate considered the evidence provided by the Removal Opponent, which included a declaration from its administrator, invoices from a related entity to a distributor named Living Edge, and screen captures from the Living Edge website. The delegate found that while there was a reasonably clear link between the goods referred to in the invoices and the images on the website, the overall evidence did not sufficiently demonstrate use of the trade mark. The delegate noted that the Removal Opponent offered only bare assertions regarding the relevant factors for exercising discretion and failed to satisfy him that it was reasonable to do so.

Consequently, the delegate declined to exercise his discretion to allow the trade mark to remain on the Register for the specified goods in Class 9. The delegate directed that the specification of goods be amended to remove the Class 9 items. The Removal Opponent was also ordered to pay the Removal Applicant's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Both parties requested to be heard via written submissions and a nominal hearing date was scheduled for 29 August 2022. The Removal Opponent provided written submissions on 12 August 2022 and the Removal Applicant filed its written submissions on 22 August 2022. The matter was later allocated to me to decide in my capacity as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks.Evidence The Removal Opponent provided a single declaration in evidence which was dated 8 November 2021 and made by Maurizio Cini (‘Cini Declaration’). The Cini Declaration describes Mr Cini as the ‘Sole Administrator of the [Removal] Opponent’.[2] The declaration also provides a brief history of the Removal Opponent and two annexures being, copies of invoices dated 2019-2020 (‘Annexure 1’) and screen captures of websites (‘Annexure 2’). [2] Cini Declaration [1]. The declaration and evidence of the Removal Opponent contains nothing directed to the corporate structure of the Removal Opponent and any related entities, other than a statement that business is conducted via ‘sister companies’.[3][3] Cini Declaration, [6]. The Cini Declaration mentions a ‘distributor’ business named ‘Living Edge’ without any further specific details about that relationship other than Living Edge being responsible for the advertising and promotion of certain goods offered under the Trade Mark in Australia.[4] Living Edge appears to operate showrooms across various Australian capital cities.[5] [4] Cini Declaration, [17].[5] Cini Declaration, [18]. The two annexures to the declaration concern potential use of the Trade Mark. Annexure 1 is a series of partly bilingual and partly untranslated invoices, mostly in Italian but with some English.[6] The invoices are from SIM2 BV International S.R.L to Living Edge (Aust) Pty Ltd. Annexure 2 is a series of screen captures from the websites ‘livingedge.com.au’ (‘Living Edge website’) and ‘mondopiero.com.au’. Some screen captures are dated 9 November 2021, the remainder are undated. The screen captures show radios bearing the words ‘radio.cubo’ worked into its handle.[6] Usually, it will be a requirement that a document be filed as a document that is a translation of the original document into English and meet various other requirements. See reg 21.2. I have not raised an issue with these being untranslated as the product code and description ‘radio’ provides sufficient information to engage with the evidence.Preliminary issue The Removal Opponent in its submissions has attempted to more directly link the invoices (which do not actually contain the word ‘CUBO’) in Annexure 1 of the Cini Declaration to the use of the Trade Mark shown in the screen captures of the Living Edge website in Annexure 2 of the Cini Declaration. In response, the Removal Applicant has asserted that this constitutes evidence filed out of time and should not be considered by me.[7] It is unnecessary to decide this question because the screen captures in the Cini Declaration display, clearly, at the bottom of the page, a URL. The URL contains prominently the same product code as that shown on the invoices. Accordingly, there is a reasonably clear link between goods referred to in the invoices and the pictures of the radio on the Living Edge website. Therefore, I need not rely on any evidence out of time, to the extent it is such, to make findings that link the goods likely sold under the invoices.[7] Applicant’s Submissions, [20]-[21].The relevant statutory provisions

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Removal Opponent offers only bare assertions about these factors. Balancing the relevant considerations and noting the evidence, the Removal Opponent has failed to satisfy me that it is reasonable to exercise the discretion not to remove the Trade Mark for some or any of the class 9 goods. I decline to exercise the discretion.Decision and costs The Removal Opponent has not rebutted the allegation of non-use, and I am not satisfied that it is reasonable to exercise the Registrar’s discretion to allow the Trade Mark to remain on the Register in respect of the class 9 goods. Accordingly, I direct that one month from the date of this decision the specification of goods be amended as follows (removed goods are struckthrough):Class 9: Apparatus for recording, transmission or reproduction of sound or images; magnetic data carriers, recording discs; compact discs, DVDs and other digital recording media; mechanisms for coin-operated apparatus; cash registers, calculating machines, data processing equipment and computers; computer software; fire-extinguishing apparatus Class 11: Apparatus for heating, steam generating, cooking, refrigerating, drying, ventilating Both parties request an award of costs. The general rule is that costs will follow the event. I award costs against the Removal Opponent in accordance with s 221, in the amounts set out in Schedule 8 of the Regulations.Benjamin GoldsworthyHearing OfficerOppositions and HearingsTrade Marks and Designs4 January 2023

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established