Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: YTO Construction Pty Ltd v Innovative Civil Pty Ltd [2018] NSWSC 1354 Hearing dates: 5, 6, 13 July 2018 Date of orders: 16 August 2018 Decision date: 10 August 2018 Jurisdiction: Equity - Technology and Construction List Before: Rein J Decision: See [22], [27]-[28], [31], [33]
Catchwords: CIVIL PROCEDURE – Pleadings – Fraud – Where Plaintiff claimed that a determination made following an adjudication (“the Determination”) was obtained in circumstances of fraud and sought to have the Determination set aside – Where Plaintiff advanced a different case to that articulated in its List Statement – Onus on the party alleging fraud to strictly articulate its claim – Consideration of the application of “pleadings” in the Technology and Construction List of the Supreme Court; HELD: Plaintiff failed to establish, in accordance with the onus placed upon it, that the Determination was obtained fraudulently by reason of the matters articulated in its List Statement, and the other grounds asserted had not been articulated in the List Statement. Legislation Cited: Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW)
Evidence Act 1995 (NSW)Cases Cited: Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336
Commercial Union Assurance Company of Australia Ltd v Ferrcom Pty Ltd and Anor (1991) 22 NSWLR 389
Probuild Constructions (Aust) Pty Ltd v DDI Group Pty Ltd (2017) 95 NSWLR 82
Probuild Constructions (Aust) Pty Ltd v Shade Systems Pty Ltd (2018) 351 ALR 225
Quarter Enterprises Pty Ltd and Anor v Allardyce Lumber Company Ltd and Anor (2014) 85 NSWLR 404
Savage and Ors v Lunn and Ors [1998] NSWCA 203
Spiliotopoulos v National Australia Bank Limited [2017] NSWSC 971Category: Principal judgment Parties: YTO Construction Pty Ltd (Plaintiff)
Innovative Civil Pty Ltd (First Defendant)
Jennifer Wyatt (Second Defendant)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
I. G. Roberts SC and L. Shipway (Plaintiff)
M. Christie SC and D. Hume (First Defendant)
Philip J. Pollack Lawyer (Plaintiff)
CCS Legal Pty Limited (First Defendant)
File Number(s): 2018/00097840 Publication restriction: Nil
Reasons for Judgment
-
The Plaintiff, YTO Construction Pty Ltd (“YTO”), was the principal contractor for a commercial/residential development in Ashfield, New South Wales. It entered into a subcontract for civil works with the Defendant, Innovative Civil Pty Ltd (“Innovative”), for $1.28 million.
-
Mr I. G. Roberts SC appears (with Mr Shipway) for YTO. Mr M. Christie SC appears (with Mr Hume) for Innovative.
-
One of Innovative’s tasks pursuant to the contract with YTO was to remove soil and waste from the site. To that end, Innovative entered into further subcontracts with several haulage contractors, one of which is known as Elkordi Earthworx Pty Ltd (“Elkordi”).
-
A dispute arose between YTO and Innovative which led to Innovative making a payment claim upon YTO within the meaning of the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW) (“the Act”). YTO disputed that it was obliged to pay the $1.5 million claimed and the dispute was the subject of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read YTO Construction Pty Ltd v Innovative Civil Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] NSWSC 1354
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues revolved around the plaintiff's ability to successfully plead fraud and whether the onus of proving the fraud was met. The court had to consider whether the plaintiff's allegations were sufficiently articulated in its List Statement and whether the plaintiff had discharged the onus of proof. The court also needed to assess the application of the rules regarding pleadings in the Technology and Construction List.
The court found that the plaintiff had failed to establish that the determination was obtained fraudulently in accordance with the matters articulated in its List Statement. The court held that the onus was on the party alleging fraud to strictly articulate its claim, and in this case, the plaintiff had not met this burden. Additionally, the other grounds of fraud asserted by the plaintiff had not been properly articulated in the List Statement. Consequently, the plaintiff's application to set aside the determination was dismissed.
The final orders of the court reflected the dismissal of the plaintiff's application, with the court ruling that the plaintiff had not discharged the onus of proving that the determination was obtained through fraud. The court also noted that the grounds of fraud not properly articulated in the List Statement could not be considered.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Plaintiff's case was initially set out in a List Statement where it specified certain grounds for alleging fraud. However, during the proceedings, the Plaintiff advanced a broader case that included additional allegations of fraud not originally stated in the List Statement. This broader case suggested that the fraud involved more extensive and complex misconduct by the Defendant. The Defendant contested the Plaintiff’s claims, arguing that the Plaintiff had not met the necessary standard of proof for establishing fraud and that the Plaintiff had not strictly adhered to the allegations articulated in the List Statement.
The matter was heard in the Technology and Construction List of the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The Plaintiff, YTO Construction, filed an application to set aside the Determination made in the adjudication, alleging fraud by the Defendant, Innovative Civil. The Plaintiff's application was contested by the Defendant, who argued that the Plaintiff had not met the required standard of proof for establishing fraud and had not strictly adhered to the allegations articulated in the List Statement. The court considered the application, taking into account the nature and content of the pleadings and the onus placed upon the Plaintiff to strictly articulate its claim of fraud. The court also considered the principles governing the application of “pleadings” in the Technology and Construction List of the Supreme Court.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the Plaintiff establish, in accordance with the onus placed upon it, that the Determination was obtained fraudulently by reason of the matters articulated in its List Statement?
2. Were the other grounds asserted by the Plaintiff for establishing fraud properly articulated in the List Statement or otherwise sufficient to meet the required standard of proof?
Held
1. The Plaintiff failed to establish, in accordance with the onus placed upon it, that the Determination was obtained fraudulently by reason of the matters articulated in its List Statement.
2. The other grounds asserted by the Plaintiff for establishing fraud had not been properly articulated in the List Statement or otherwise sufficient to meet the required standard of proof.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court began by examining the Plaintiff's primary contention that the Determination was obtained fraudulently. The Plaintiff had the onus to strictly articulate its claim as per the requirements of the Technology and Construction List of the Supreme Court. The Court noted that the Plaintiff's List Statement outlined specific allegations of fraud, and the Plaintiff was required to prove these allegations to succeed in its application. However, the Court found that the Plaintiff did not establish its case on the specific matters outlined in the List Statement. The Plaintiff had instead advanced a different case which was not aligned with the original allegations.
Further, the Court considered the other grounds of fraud alleged by the Plaintiff that were not included in the List Statement. The Plaintiff had the burden to prove any such grounds to the requisite standard. The Court determined that these additional grounds were neither properly articulated in the List Statement nor substantiated by the evidence provided. As such, the Plaintiff's application to set aside the Determination on the basis of fraud was dismissed. The Court emphasised the importance of strict adherence to pleadings in such matters, highlighting the principle that the party alleging fraud must clearly and precisely articulate their case to meet the onus of proof.