Yara Ab v Minister for Industry, Science and Technology

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Yara AB v Minister for Industry, Science and Technology [2022] FCA 847

File number: NSD 1003 of 2020
Judgment of: WIGNEY J
Date of judgment: 21 July 2022
Catchwords:

TAXATION – imposition of ‘dumping duty’ under s 8 of Customs Tariff (Anti-Dumping) Act 1975 (Cth) – application for judicial review of respondent’s declaration under s 269TG of Customs Act 1901 (Cth) affirming the publication of a dumping duty notice for ammonium nitrate exported to Australia – applicant exported ammonium nitrate to Australia from Sweden – Australian manufacturers of ammonium nitrate applied under s 269TB of Customs Act 1901 (Cth) for publication of a dumping duty notice over exports – investigation commenced by Anti-Dumping Commission to assess extent of injury to the Australian industry caused by exports – Commission produced report to respondent per s 269TEA of Customs Act 1901 (Cth) recommending the publication of a dumping duty notice in respect of ammonium nitrate exports – application for review of the Commissioner’s decision by the Anti-Dumping Review Panel made per s 269ZZE of Customs Act 1901 (Cth) – Review Panel required Commission to conduct reinvestigation – Review Panel conducted review of Commissioner’s decision on “reviewable grounds” pursuant to s 269ZZG of Customs Act 1901 (Cth) – Review Panel recommended the respondent affirm decision to publish dumping duty notice as the “correct or preferable decision”

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – judicial review application relied on s 5 of Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) and s 39B of Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) – whether Commission misconstrued “because of that” causation requirement or adopted erroneous approach to “material injury” in s 269TG(1) of Customs Act 1901 (Cth) – whether respondent’s decision misconstrued s 269TAE(2C) of Customs Act 1901 (Cth) to permit cumulative assessment of the “effect of those goods” – applicant argued relevant decision-makers did not consider normal ebb and flow of business when assessing injury – nature of review to be conducted by Review Panel – Review Panel argued to have not determined decision “in like manner” as the respondent as statutorily required – application dismissed

Legislation:

Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) ss 5(1), 5(2)

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 39B

Customs Act 1901 (Cth) ss 269SM, 269SM(1), 269SM(2), 269SM(3), 269SM(9), 269SMG, 269SN, 269T, 269T(2), 269T(3), 269T(4), 269TACB, 269TAE, 269TAE(1), 269TAE(2), 269TAE(2A), 269TAE(2AA), 269TAE(2C), 269TAE(3), 269TA, 269TA(1), 269TBA, 269TB, 269TC, 269TC(4), 269TD, 269TDAA, 269TDA, 269TE(2), 269TEA, 269TEA(1), 269TEA(3), 269TEA(5), 269TG, 269TG(1), 269TG(2), 269ZZ(1), 269ZZA(1), 269ZZC, 269ZZE, 269ZZE(1), 269ZZE(2), 269ZZG(1), 269ZZG(2), 269ZZG(5), 269ZZH, 269ZZH(5), 269ZZHA(2), 269ZZI, 269ZZJ, 269ZZK(1), 269ZZK(3), 269ZZK(4), 269ZZK(4A), 269ZZK(5), 269ZZK(6), 269ZZL, 269ZZL(1), 269ZZL(3), 269ZZM(1), 269ZZM(1A), 269ZZM(3), 269ZZM(4)

Customs Tariff (Anti-Dumping) Act 1975 (Cth) ss 8, 8(2), 8(3)

Cases cited:

Collector of Customs v Pozzolanic Enterprises Pty Ltd (1993) 43 FCR 280; [1993] FCA 322

ICI Australia Operations Pty Ltd v Fraser (1992) 34 FCR 564; [1991] FCA 128

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZMDS (2010) 240 CLR 611; [2010] HCA 16

Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Yara Ab v Minister for Industry, Science and Technology and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 847
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Yara Ab, an exporter of ammonium nitrate, sought judicial review of the Minister for Industry, Science and Technology’s decision to affirm the publication of a dumping duty notice over ammonium nitrate exports from Sweden, China, and Thailand. The Minister's decision followed a recommendation from the Anti-Dumping Review Panel (Review Panel) after the Anti-Dumping Commission (Commission) conducted an investigation into the potential injury to Australian manufacturers caused by the dumped imports. The legal issues in the case primarily revolved around whether the Commissioner and the Review Panel misconstrued statutory provisions in determining that material injury had been caused by the dumped imports, and whether the Review Panel appropriately exercised its statutory functions in reviewing the Commissioner's decision.

The court found that the Commissioner and Review Panel correctly applied the statutory causation requirement under section 269TG(1) and (2) of the Customs Act 1901 (Cth), which necessitates a finding that material injury was caused "because of that" the dumped imports. The court also found that the Review Panel did not err in its approach to assessing material injury, despite Yara's arguments that the Review Panel failed to consider normal business fluctuations or corresponding benefits to Australian industry. The Review Panel was required to review the Commissioner’s decision on "reviewable grounds," a standard which the court held the Review Panel appropriately applied. Furthermore, the court held that the Review Panel correctly determined the decision "in like manner" as the respondent, as required by section 269ZZ(1) of the Customs Act, thereby rejecting Yara's argument that the Review Panel had adopted an incorrect standard of review.

As a result, the court dismissed Yara's application for judicial review and ordered that the application be dismissed with costs. This outcome upheld the Minister's decision to affirm the publication of the dumping duty notice, maintaining the liability for a special customs duty on the importation of the dumped ammonium nitrate into Australia.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed with costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Yara contended that the Commissioner, the Review Panel, and the Minister made three errors of law in finding that material injury had been, or was being, caused to the Australian industry by the dumping of ammonium nitrate. The first error was said to be that the finding was not based on facts, but rather was based merely on allegations, conjecture or remote possibilities contrary to s 269TAE(2AA) of the Customs Act and the 2012 Ministerial Direction. The second error was said to be that, contrary to s 269TAE(2A) of the Customs Act, the Commissioner and the Review Panel failed to consider whether any injury to the Australian industry had been, or was being, caused by a factor which could not be attributed to the exportation of ammonium nitrate from Sweden, China and Thailand. The third error was said to be that, in making the finding, the Commissioner and the Review Panel failed to consider or account for any corresponding benefit to Australian industry counterparties.Facts, not allegations, conjecture or remote possibilities – s 269TAE(2AA) As for the first alleged error, Yara’s contention that the finding of material injury was based merely on allegations, conjecture or remote possibilities was to a large extent based on the fact that the Commissioner’s analysis of the seven relevant contract negotiations included two negotiations (examples 5 and 6) where no contracts were concluded. Yara argued that the Commissioner’s analysis of those two contracts involved conjecture that contracts would have been formed at the “undumped” price. The difficulty with Yara’s argument, however, is that it would be fairer to characterise the Commissioner’s reasoning concerning examples 5 and 6 as involving inferences, based on the evidence, as opposed to merely allegations, conjecture or remote possibilities. The Commissioner’s reasoning in relation to example 5 was as follows (ADCR at section 9.2.1):[Queensland Nitrates] provided information in relation to its bid to supply a customer with ammonium nitrate over a 12 month period.This customer approached [Queensland Nitrates] in the investigation period, and [Queensland Nitrates] provided an offer to this customer, which was subsequently rejected.[Queensland Nitrates] claims that the potential customer advised that it is able to source ammonium nitrate at a lower price from overseas. No evidence was provided to support this claim. The Commission notes, however, that this customer is an importer of the goods from one of the subject countries. An examination of verified data from the importer shows that, following [Queensland Nitrates’] unsuccessful offer, this customer ordered the goods from one of the countries the subject of this investigation.The Commission found that the price at which the customer sourced the goods from the subject country undercut [Queensland Nitrates’] price offer. The Commission assessed whether [Queensland Nitrates’] price offer would have been more price competitive in the absence of dumping. The Commission’s approach to this assessment is outlined in section 9.2.2 of this chapter.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The publication of a notice under s 269TG(1) and (2) “creates a liability under the Dumping Duty Act, in relation to any goods to which the notice extends, to pay a special duty of customs on their importation into Australia and, pending assessment of that special duty, to pay interim duty”: s 269SM(2) of the Customs Act. Subsections 8(2) and (3) of the Dumping Duty Act provide as follows:(2) There is imposed, and there must be collected and paid, on goods:(a)to which this section applies by virtue of a notice under subsection 269TG(1) or (2) of the Customs Act; and(b)in relation to which the amount of the export price is less than the amount of the normal value;a special duty of Customs, to be known as dumping duty, calculated in accordance with subsection (6).(3)Pending final assessment of the dumping duty payable on goods the subject of a notice under subsection 269TG(1) or (2) of the Customs Act, an interim dumping duty is payable on those goods.The statutory scheme in relation to decisions about dumping duty notices The statutory scheme in pt XVB of the Customs Act in relation to decisions about dumping duty notices is lengthy, convoluted and highly prescriptive. Relevantly, and by way of overview, divs 1, 2 and 3 of pt XVB of the Customs Act “deal with the preliminary and procedural matters leading to a Ministerial decision to publish or not to publish a dumping duty notice”: s 269SM(3) of the Customs Act. Division 1A establishes the Anti-Dumping Commission and empowers the Commissioner of the Anti-Dumping Commission to “do all things necessary or convenient to be done for or in connection with the performance of his or her functions”: s 269SMG of the Customs Act. Divisions 8 and 9 establish an independent review panel, the Anti-Dumping Review Panel, and provide for the Panel to review a range of Ministerial decisions (including, relevantly, decisions to publish or not publish dumping duty notices), as well as a range of decisions made by the Commissioner: s 269SM(9) of the Customs Act. It is necessary to delve into the detail of the provisions in divs 1, 2, 8 and 9 of pt XVB of the Customs Act in order to consider Yara’s challenge to the Minister’s decision to issue the dumping duty notice in question. Division 1 – factors and criteria Division 1 “provides the basis for determining various factors … necessary to decide whether dumping … has occurred”, “sets out the criteria for the use of those factors in so deciding” and “provides the basis for determining whether dumping … is causing material injury to Australian industry”: s 269SN of the Customs Act. The provision in Division 1 that is central to a number of Yara’s review grounds is s 269TAE, which deals with the question, relevant to the operation of s 269TG(1) and (2), of whether material injury to an Australian industry has been or is being caused because of any circumstance in relation to the exportation of goods to Australia. Subsection 269TAE(1) of the Customs Act contains a non-exhaustive list of considerations that the Minister may have regard to in determining that issue. It is in the following terms: (1)In determining, for the purposes of section 269TG or 269TJ, whether material injury to an Australian industry has been or is being caused or is threatened or would or might have been caused, or whether the establishment of an Australian industry has been materially hindered, because of any circumstances in relation to the exportation of goods to Australia from the country of export, the Minister may, without limiting the generality of that section but subject to subsections (2A) to (2C), have regard to:(aa)if the determination is being made for the purposes of section 269TG—the size of the dumping margin, or of each of the dumping margins, worked out in respect of goods of that kind that have been exported to Australia and dumped; and(ab)if the determination is being made for the purposes of section 269TJ—particulars of any countervailable subsidy received in respect of goods of that kind that have been exported to Australia; and(a)the quantity of goods of that kind that, during a particular period, have been or are likely to be exported to Australia from the country of export; and(b)any increase or likely increase, during a particular period, in the quantity of goods of that kind exported to Australia from the country of export; and(c)any change or likely change, during a particular period, in the proportion that:(i)the quantity of goods of that kind exported to Australia from the country of export and sold or consumed in Australia; or(ii)the quantity of goods of that kind, or like goods, produced or manufactured in the Australian industry and sold or consumed in Australia;bears to the quantity of goods of that kind, or like goods, sold or consumed in Australia; and(d)the export price that has been or is likely to be paid by importers for goods of that kind exported to Australia from the country of export; and(e) the difference between:(i)the price that has been or is likely to be paid for goods of that kind, or like goods, produced or manufactured in the Australian industry and sold in Australia; and(ii)the price that has been or is likely to be paid for goods of that kind exported to Australia from the country of export and sold in Australia; and(f)the effect that the exportation of goods of that kind to Australia from the country of export in those circumstances has had or is likely to have on the price paid for goods of that kind, or like goods, produced or manufactured in the Australian industry and sold in Australia; and(g)any effect that the exportation of goods of that kind to Australia from the country of export in those circumstances has had or is likely to have on the relevant economic factors in relation to the Australian industry; and(h)if the determination is being made for the purposes of section 269TJ and the goods are agricultural products—whether the exportation of goods of that kind to Australia from the country of export in those circumstances has given or is likely to give rise to a need for financial or other support, or an increase in financial or other support, for the Australian industry from the Commonwealth Government.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ground 5 of Yara’s Application is that procedures that were required by law to be observed in connection with the making of the Minister’s decision were not observed, and/or the Review Panel and the Minister failed to carry out their statutory functions in connection with the decision. The essence of the submission advanced in support of this was that the Review Panel adopted the incorrect “standard of review” and did not determine matters in like manner as if it were the Minister, as required by s 269ZZ(1) of the Customs Act. Rather, it determined whether the approach taken by the Commission was “reasonable”. This error by the Review Panel was said to, in turn, infect the Minister’s decision. CONSIDERATION OF REVIEW GROUNDS Yara’s arguments in support of its review grounds focussed primarily on the Review Panel’s reasons and findings. In making the decision in question, the Minister accepted the Review Panel’s reasons and findings, as well as the Review Panel’s recommendation to affirm the original decision to publish the dumping duty notice. Some of the review grounds also hinge on aspects of the Commissioner’s reasons and findings which, for the most part, were found by the Review Panel to be reasonable, and not erroneous as Yara had contended. Ground 1 – erroneous construction of s 269TG(1)(b) and (2)(b) of the Customs Act The question to be determined in respect of this review ground is whether the Review Panel adopted an erroneous construction of the causation requirement in s 269TG(1)(b) and (2)(b) of the Customs Act. The causation requirement in s 269TG(1) and (2) arises from the words “because of that” in both those provisions. In the case of s 269TG(1), the relevant causation requirement is, in substance, that the Minister is satisfied that material injury to an Australian industry producing like goods has been or is being caused by the fact that the amount of the export price of the goods is less than the amount of the normal value of the goods. In the case of s 269TG(2), the relevant causation requirement is, in substance, that the Minister is satisfied that material injury to an Australian industry producing like goods has been or is being caused by the fact that the amount of the export price of the goods that may be exported to Australia in the future may (as in the present case) be less than the normal value of the goods. There could be no doubt that both the Commission and the Review Panel proceeded on the basis that they could only recommend that a dumping duty notice be issued under s 269TG(1) or (2) if they were satisfied that there was dumping (the export price of the goods exported to Australia was less than the amount of the normal value of the goods) and “because of that”, relevantly, material injury to an Australian industry had been, or was being, caused or threatened. Yara did not contend otherwise. Yara’s arguments in relation to ground 1 focussed on the basis upon which both the Commissioner and the Review Panel found that they were satisfied that the causation requirement had been made out in the case of the dumped ammonium nitrate. It is nevertheless necessary to give some attention to the manner in which both the Commission and the Review Panel approached the question of causation.