Yap v Australian Securities and Investments Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Yap v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2013] FCA 334

Citation: Yap v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2013] FCA 334
Parties: YAP CHENG SEE, ARCOLA PTY LTD and WESTPOINT HOLDINGS PTY LTD v AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION, ESANDA FINANCE LTD, ANZ BANK, WESTPAC BANK, BANK OF SINGAPORE, COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRALIA, CURTIN UNIVERSITY OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA, GRANICH & ASSOCIATES, BAILIFF (WA), REGISTRAR OF TITLES and REGISTRAR OF TITLES
File number: WAD 86 of 2013
Judge: BARKER J
Date of judgment: 11 April 2013
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for leave to issue a proceeding – whether proceeding would not be an abuse of process – whether there is prima facie ground for the proceeding
Legislation:

Corporations Law s 574

Federal Court Rules 1979 (Cth) O 21 r 1(b), O 21 r 2, O 21 r 5(1), O 21 r 5(2)

Cases cited: Cheng See Yap v Cheshire Holdings Pty Ltd [2007] WASCA 50
Cheshire Holdings Pty Ltd v Yap Cheng See (unreported, Supreme Court of Western Australia, Steytler J, 22 November 1995)
Chong v Cheshire Securities Pty Ltd [2001] WASC 266
Esanda Finance Corporation Ltd v Yap Cheng See (unreported, District Court of Western Australia, Deputy Registrar Harman, 6 December 1994)
Granich & Associates v Yap [2004] FCA 1567
Re Attorney-General (Cth); Ex parte Skyring (1996) 135 ALR 129
Re Cheshire Securities Pty Ltd; Ex Parte Chong [2003] WASC 132
Re Yap Cheng See; Cheshire Holdings Pty Ltd (unreported, Supreme Court of Western Australia, Sanderson M, 11 July 1997)
See v Commonwealth Bank of Australia (unreported, Full Court of the Supreme Court of Western Australia, Murray and Templeman JJ, 10 September 1998)
See v Esanda Finance Corporation Ltd (unreported, Full Court of the Supreme Court of Western Australia, Kennedy, Franklyn and Ipp JJ, 9 April 1998)
See v Granich and Associates [2008] FMCA 27
Yap Cheng See v Challenge Bank Ltd (unreported, Supreme Court of Western Australia, Parker J, 12 December 1997)
Yap Cheng See v Cheshire Holdings Pty Ltd (unreported, Supreme Court of Western Australia, Kennedy, Franklyn and Ipp JJ, 9 April 1998)
Yap Cheng See v Commonwealth Bank (District Court of Western Australia, Gunning DCJ, 7 October 1996)
Yap Cheng See v Esanda Finance Corporation Ltd (unreported, District Court of Western Australia, Principal Registrar Harding, 8 November 1995)
Yap v Australian Securities & Investments Commission [2000] WASC 159
Yap v Australian Securities & Investments Commission [2008] FCA 534
Yap v Australian Securities & Investments Commission [2009] FCA 831
Yap v Australian Securities & Investments Commission [2009] FCA 1159
Yap v Granich & Associates [2005] FCA 309
Yap v Granich Partners [2008] FCA 1380
Date of hearing: Determined on the papers
Place: Perth
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 37

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

WAD 86 of 2013

BETWEEN:

YAP CHENG SEE
First Applicant

ARCOLA PTY LTD
Second Applicant

WESTPOINT HOLDINGS PTY LTD
Third Applicant

AND:

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION
First…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Yap v Australian Securities and Investments Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 334
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Yap sought leave to issue a proceeding against several respondents including the Australian Securities and Investments Commission, various banks, a university, and a law firm. The application was to be considered by McKerracher J in the Federal Court of Australia, following an earlier order by French J that leave was required for such a proceeding. The proposed proceeding sought extensive relief including reinstatement of a company, compensation for wrongful deregistration, reimbursement of income, and damages for alleged breaches of fiduciary duty and contract. The court had to determine if the proceeding was an abuse of process and if there was a prima facie ground for it.

The court examined the nature of the claims and found them to be essentially identical to those raised in previous proceedings before French J, McKerracher J, and Gilmour J. These claims had been repeatedly litigated and rejected. The court also noted that the annexures provided by Yap did not constitute new evidence that would support a prima facie case. The court concluded that the proceeding was an abuse of process and lacked a prima facie ground, given the repetitive nature of the claims and the previous rejections by other judges.

Accordingly, the court refused Yap leave to issue the proceeding. The decision was based on the understanding that allowing the proceeding would not only be a waste of judicial resources but also an abuse of the court process. The court emphasized the importance of vigilance in such applications, ensuring that past rejections of similar claims should not be lightly disregarded. The refusal of leave to proceed was a measure to prevent the unnecessary repetition of litigation.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Having regarded the applicants’ proposed claims against the respondents and the evidence identified, the Court considers the proposed proceeding is an abuse of process and that there is no prima facie ground for it. Accordingly, the Court refuses leave to Mrs Yap to issue the proceeding.BACKGROUND Mrs Yap seeks leave to issue a proceeding against the Australian Securities and Investments Commission, Esanda Finance Ltd, ANZ Bank, Westpac Bank, Bank of Singapore, Commonwealth Bank of Australia, Curtin University of Western Australia, Granich & Associates, the Bailiff (WA) and the Registrar of Titles (the first to tenth respondents respectively). Mrs Yap, is a director of the second and third applicants and a former director of Cheshire Securities Pty Ltd (Cheshire). Leave for Mrs Yap to proceed is required pursuant to an order of French J (as his Honour then was) made under O 21, r 1(b) of the Federal Court Rules 1979 (Cth) (previous Federal Court Rules) in Yap v Australian Securities & Investments Commission [2008] FCA 534. Pursuant to O 21, r 5(2), I have determined the application for leave without an oral hearing. If leave is granted, Mrs Yap and the other applicants would seek the following relief:1.1st Respondent to reinstate CHESHIRE SECURITIES PTY LTD ACN 009 264 082 to the register of Companies and to compensate the company accordingly for its wrongful deregistration on 20 June 2000 as the Court sees just.2.2nd Respondent to reimburse CHESHIRE SECURITIES PTY LTD all income receivable from its 50-years Leasehold property from 17 November 1988 based on CPI with interest at rate prescribe by the Court and* to pay 1st Applicant damages as the Court sees just for its mortgagee sale of Lot 1978 for $130,000 on or about 31 May 1991 without the right of doing so and* to pay 1st Applicant damages and compensation for the sale of No 449 Canning Highway Melville on 5 November 1993 for $142,000 by 9th Respondent pursuant to writ of FiFa215/93 issued by M Ellison pursuant to DC1536/89 P Vivante & Co Pty Ltd vs CS Yap concocted by M Ellison pursuant to its agreement with their client.3.3rd Respondent to pay 2nd Applicant all rentals receivable on 58 58A 58B & 60 2nd Avenue Rossmoyne from 17 November 1988 till Judgment with interest based on CPI at rate prescribed by the Court.4.4th Respondent to pay 1st Applicant rentals receivable for the three Units on Lot 896/No. 235 Preston Point Rd Bicton from 25 May 1988 till Judgment with interest based on CPI at rate prescribed by the Court and* to Pay 1st Applicant damages for selling short Lot 896/No. 235 Preston Point Rd Bicton to Friendly Hldgs Pty Ltd for $240,000 on 10.8.88 while her auction bid for $265,000 extant balance of $238,500 to be settled on or before 30.8.88.5.5th Respondent to pay Cheshire Securities Pty Ltd damages as the Court sees just for acting in breach of fiduciary duty and contract to the company.6.6th Respondent to pay 1st Applicant all rentals from the 2 Townhouses and the original house on Lot 26/No. 254 Preston Point Rd Bicton based on CPI and interest at rate prescribed by the Court and damages in breach of agreement.7.7th Respondent to reinstate Cheshire Securities Pty Ltd’s 50-years LEASE executed on 11.8.88 and to pay the company damages as the Court sees just for acting in breach of agreement.8.8th Respondent to pay 1st Applicant damages as the Court sees just for acting negligently on her behalf in DC1536/89 P Vivante & Co Pty Ltd vs CS Yap that resulted in the sale of her home 449 Canning Highway Melville on 5.11.93 by 9th Respondent pursuant to writ of FiFa215/93 issued by M Ellison pursuant to DC1536/89 P Vivante & Co Pty Ltd vs CS Yap perpetrated by M Ellison pursuant to 2nd Respondent’s agreement with their client.9.9th Respondent to pay 1st Applicant $142,000 for wrongful sale of her home 449 Canning Highway Melville as in 8.10.10th Respondent to revert back the Titles to the rightful owners:a) Lot 896/No. 235 Preston Point Rd Bicton being Swan Loc. 70 Lot 896 on plan 3948 Vol. 1742 Folio 925 to Ms Yap Cheng See of No. 57 Whaleback Avenue Parkwood WA 6147.b) No. 254 Preston Point Rd Bicton being Swan Loc. 70 Lot 26 on Diagram 15167 Vol. 1129 Folio 68 to Ms Yap Cheng See of No. 57 Whaleback Avenue Parkwood WA 6147.c) Swan Loc. 1978 CT Vol 1794 Folio 145 to Ms Yap Cheng See of No. 57 Whaleback Avenue Parkwood WA 6147.d) No. 449 Canning Highway Melville being Swan Loc. 73 Lot 6 on Diagram 5694 CT Vol. 1590 Folio 117 to Ms Yap Cheng See of No. 57 Whaleback Avenue Parkwood WA 6147.e) No. 140 Charles St W Perth being portion of Perth Town Lot Y260 Lot 100 on Diagram 42401 CT Vol 1337 Folio 399 to Westpoint Hldgs Pty Ltd of No. 57 Whaleback Avenue Parkwood WA 6147.f) Lot 337 on plan 4392 CT Vol. 1733 Folio 274 and Lot 14 on Diagram 23627 CT Vol. 1218 Folio 962 to Arcola Pty Ltd of No. 57 Whaleback Avenue Parkwood WA 6147.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Furthermore, it is difficult to see what relevance, if any, the three annexures which purport to present new evidence have. In my view, the annexures certainly do not provide new evidence such as would provide a prima facie ground for the proposed proceeding. (In fact, one of the annexures, annexure CSY2, is not even “fresh evidence”: see Yap v Australian Securities & Investments Commission [2009] FCA 1159 at [16].)CONCLUSION I appreciate the manner in which Mrs Yap has comprehensively presented her application. I am not satisfied, however, that the proposed proceeding is not an abuse of process and nor am I satisfied that there is prima facie ground for the proceeding. Accordingly, leave to issue the proceeding is refused.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Finally, the proposed proceeding is essentially identical in terms of the claims and respondents to the proceeding instituted before French J in Yap v Australian Securities & Investments Commission [2008] FCA 534, and, following the order of French J pursuant to O 21, r 1(b) of the previous Federal Court Rules, the subject of the proposed proceedings before McKerracher J in Yap v Australian Securities & Investments Commission [2009] FCA 831 and Gilmour J in Yap v Australian Securities & Investments Commission [2009] FCA 1159. Indeed, one only needs to look at the relief claimed or sought to be claimed in these proceedings to appreciate this: cf Yap v Australian Securities & Investments Commission [2008] FCA 534 at [1]; Yap v Australian Securities & Investments Commission [2009] FCA 831 at [6].CONSIDERATION Pursuant to O 21, r 5(1) of the previous Federal Court Rules, a person against whom the Court has made an order under O 21, r 1 may only be granted leave to institute a proceeding if the Court is satisfied that:(a) the proceeding is not an abuse of process; and(b) there is prima facie ground for the proceeding. In assessing whether the conditions in O 21, r 5(1) are satisfied I am conscious of Kirby J’s caution in Re Attorney-General (Cth); Ex parte Skyring (1996) 135 ALR 129 at 31-32 that, in applications such as these:… it is always important for every judge to keep an open mind in case a person who has been rejected by courts in the past may have, hidden amongst the verbiage of his or her arguments, a point which has not been previously seen and which may have merit. Vigilance, and not impatience, are specially required where that person is not legally represented.Secondly, it is regarded as a serious thing in this country to keep a person out of the courts. The rule of law requires that, ordinarily, a person should have access to the courts in order to invoke their jurisdiction. As is evident from the analysis in the previous section, Mrs Yap is attempting to issue an essentially identical proceeding to which was issued or attempted variously before French J, McKerracher J and Gilmour J, and to litigate claims which have been the subject of numerous past proceedings. However, in Yap v Australian Securities & Investments Commission [2008] FCA 534, at [12], French J stated that in his opinion the “application has no reasonable prospect of success. It is on the face of it an abuse of process. It seeks to relitigate issues that have been litigated over many years.” In a similar vein, in Yap v Australian Securities & Investments Commission [2009] FCA 831, at [7], McKerracher J commented that each of the claims that the applicants sought to ventilate “has been previously pursued or alternatively depends upon other claims which have previously been pursued, sometimes on numerous occasions and in all cases those claims have been rejected”. Finally, in Yap v Australian Securities & Investments Commission [2009] FCA 1159, at [19]-[20], Gilmour J stated that:19… Mrs Yap could never in a proceeding such as this, in effect, appeal against judgments earlier made whether in this Court or other courts. That, in my view, is the thrust of the proposed application.20In my opinion, the proposed proceedings are an abuse of process.