NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL
CITATION: Yallourn v Enron Australia (in liq) [2005] NSWCA 326
FILE NUMBER(S):
40163/05
HEARING DATE(S): 26 August 2005
JUDGMENT DATE: 20/09/2005
PARTIES:
Yallourn Electricity Ltd (Appellant)
Enron Australia Finance Pty Limited (in liquidation) (Respondent)
JUDGMENT OF: Giles JA Basten JA Campbell AJA
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Supreme Court
LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): SC 5942/04
LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER: Campbell J
COUNSEL:
A.C. Archibald QC/S.R. Horgan (Appellant)
D.J. Hammerschlag SC/V.F. Kerr (Respondent)
SOLICITORS:
Baker & McKenzie (Appellant)
Blake Dawson Waldron (Respondent)
CATCHWORDS:
CONTRACT - interpretation of ISDA Master Agreement - administrator and liquidator appointed - occurrence of event of default - whether party in default must pay outstanding amounts and interest on those amounts to trigger additional termination event - whether amounts other party required to pay to avoid the occurrence of an additional termination event include outstanding amounts and interest on those amounts - determination of period over which interest should be calculated upon occurrence of an early termination date
LEGISLATION CITED:
Industrial Relations Act 1988 (Cth)
DECISION:
(1) Appeal allowed in part and declarations 1-3 made in the Equity Division be varied to read as follows
"THE COURT DECLARES that -
On the proper construction of the contract entitled ISDA Master Agreement between Enron Australia Finance Pty Limited ("Enron") and Yallourn Electricity Ltd ("Yallourn") dated 10 August 2001 ("the Contract"), and in the events which have happened:
(1) the amount required to be paid by Enron for the purposes of Part 1(g) of the Schedule to the Contract, in order to satisfy all its payment obligations under section 2(a)(i) with respect to all transactions and to have no future payment obligations to Yallourn whether absolute or contingent under section 2(a)(i), is:
(a) each payment specified in each confirmation to be made by Enron which has not been paid,
and does not include:
(b) interest, if any, payable or which would in any circumstances be payable by Enron under section 2(e);
(2) the amount required to be paid by Yallourn to avoid the occurrence of an Additional Termination Event, after Enron has satisfied all of its payment and delivery obligations under Part 1(g) of the Schedule to the Contract, is
(a) each amount that would have become payable by Yallourn under section 2(a)(i), but for the operation of section 2(a)(iii), and which remains unpaid;
and does not include:
(b) interest which would have been payable under section 2(e) but for the operation of section 2(a)(iii);
(3) If:
(a) an Additional Termination Event, as described in Part 1(g) of the Schedule to the Contract, occurs in respect of which Enron is Party X and Yallourn is Party Y, and
(b) Enron gives a notice to Yallourn designating an Early Termination Date in accordance with section 6(b)(iv),
the Unpaid Amounts owing to Enron (the Defaulting Party), as referred to in section 6(e)(i)(3), comprise the aggregate of:
(a) each amount that would have become payable by Yallourn under section 2(a)(i), but for the operation of section 2(a)(iii), and…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Yallourn v Enron Australia (in Liq) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2005] NSWCA 326
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine three primary legal issues. Firstly, whether the amount Enron was required to pay to satisfy its payment obligations under section 2(a)(i) of the agreement, and to avoid a future payment obligation, included interest on those outstanding amounts. Secondly, the court had to determine the amount Yallourn was required to pay to avoid the occurrence of an additional termination event, after Enron had satisfied its obligations. This involved considering whether such payment by Yallourn should include interest. Thirdly, the court considered the calculation of "Unpaid Amounts" owing to Enron upon the designation of an Early Termination Date, specifically the period over which interest should be calculated.
The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal in part. It declared that for the purposes of satisfying Enron's payment obligations under Part 1(g) of the Schedule to the Contract, the amount required was each unpaid specified payment, and did not include interest. Conversely, the court declared that the amount Yallourn was required to pay to avoid an additional termination event was each amount that would have become payable but for the operation of section 2(a)(iii), and which remained unpaid, also excluding interest. Regarding the third issue, the court affirmed the primary judge's determination concerning the calculation of Unpaid Amounts owing to Enron, which included interest calculated from the date amounts were or would have been required to be paid to the Early Termination Date at a rate reflecting Yallourn's funding cost. Consequently, the court ordered that each party bear its own costs of the proceedings.
Orders
Orders of the court
(1) Appeal allowed in part and declarations 1-3 made in the Equity Division be varied to read as follows
"THE COURT DECLARES that -
On the proper construction of the contract entitled ISDA Master Agreement between Enron Australia Finance Pty Limited ("Enron") and Yallourn Electricity Ltd ("Yallourn") dated 10 August 2001 ("the Contract"), and in the events which have happened:
(1) the amount required to be paid by Enron for the purposes of Part 1(g) of the Schedule to the Contract, in order to satisfy all its payment obligations under section 2(a)(i) with respect to all transactions and to have no future payment obligations to Yallourn whether absolute or contingent under section 2(a)(i), is:
(a) each payment specified in each confirmation to be made by Enron which has not been paid,
and does not include:
(b) interest, if any, payable or which would in any circumstances be payable by Enron under section 2(e);
(2) the amount required to be paid by Yallourn to avoid the occurrence of an Additional Termination Event, after Enron has satisfied all of its payment and delivery obligations under Part 1(g) of the Schedule to the Contract, is
(a) each amount that would have become payable by Yallourn under section 2(a)(i), but for the operation of section 2(a)(iii), and which remains unpaid;
and does not include:
(b) interest which would have been payable under section 2(e) but for the operation of section 2(a)(iii);
(3) If:
(a) an Additional Termination Event, as described in Part 1(g) of the Schedule to the Contract, occurs in respect of which Enron is Party X and Yallourn is Party Y, and
(b) Enron gives a notice to Yallourn designating an Early Termination Date in accordance with section 6(b)(iv),
the Unpaid Amounts owing to Enron (the Defaulting Party), as referred to in section 6(e)(i)(3), comprise the aggregate of:
(a) each amount that would have become payable by Yallourn under section 2(a)(i), but for the operation of section 2(a)(iii), and which remains unpaid,
together with
(b) interest from (and including) the date such amounts were or would have been required to have been paid (but for the operation of section 2(a)(iii)) to (but excluding) such Early Termination Date at a rate per annum equal to the cost to Yallourn if it were to fund such amounts."
(2) Set aside order 4 (as to costs) made in the Equity Division
(3) Order that each party bear its own costs of the proceeding below and of the appeal
(4) Grant liberty to the parties to apply within 14 days in relation to the form of the Declarations.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Before leaving this issue, it is appropriate to note the difference between the language adopted in relation to payment obligations after early termination (with its express reference to interest payable on a hypothetical basis) and the terminology of cl 1(g) of the schedule, which makes no express reference to the payment of interest: see [11] above.Form of declarations The issues have been identified and addressed above in the chronological order in which they would arise in administering the contract. The declaration in relation to the first issue, as recorded in the minute of order made by the primary judge and entered on 20 April 2005 is declaration 2. The declaration affirms that Enron can satisfy the first limb of the requirements to trigger an additional termination event, pursuant to cl 1(g) of schedule 1, by paying outstanding transaction amounts, and without paying interest on those amounts. That declaration is, in my view, to appropriate effect and I would dismiss so much of the appeal as relates to that declaration. The second issue identified above, namely the payment which must be made by Yallourn to avoid an additional termination event occurring, is declaration 1 in the minute of order entered on 20 April 2005. I would uphold Yallourn’s appeal with respect to this declaration and would delete the words preceding par (a), namely -“the aggregate of:(a)”.I would also delete all words following par (a) so that the amount identified as payable by Yallourn is:“each amount that would have become payable by Yallourn Energy Pty Ltd under s 2(a)(i), but for s 2(a)(iii), and which remains unpaid.”The remainder of the chapeau of the declaration is appropriate, but, in identifying the contract in issue, should properly apply to each of the declarations. The attached order makes appropriate variations to give effect to that mechanical change. The effect of the first two orders is that no payments of interest are required to be made by either party for the purposes of cl 1(g) of the schedule. The Court was told that if Enron pays outstanding transaction payments owing to Yallourn, Yallourn will pay the total of the transaction payments owing to Enron. Whether, in that circumstance, Enron will take the first step required of it is not known. However, because the third issue was addressed by the primary judge and was, in my view, correctly determined by his Honour, it is sufficient to dismiss the appeal with respect to that aspect of his Honour’s judgment. The accompanying orders include minor variations to the form of the declaration made by his Honour to clarify its effect. Putting to one side the third issue, which was treated as of limited significance by both parties and which is likely to be of no practical significance, each party has been successful in relation to one of the declarations sought with respect to the operation of cl 1(g) of the schedule. That result should, on the views set out above, have obtained before the primary judge. In these circumstances, the appropriate order with respect to costs is to set aside his Honour’s order that Yallourn pay Enron’s costs and order that each party bear its own costs both of the appeal and in the Court below.