Yacoub v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Yacoub v Commissioner of Taxation [2012] FCA 678

Citation: Yacoub v Commissioner of Taxation [2012] FCA 678
Parties:

MADELINE YACOUB v COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION

MAROUN YACOUB V COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION

File number(s): NSD 1600 of 2011
NSD 1601 of 2011
Judge: JAGOT J
Date of judgment: 29 June 2012
Catchwords: TAXATION – whether applicants liable for GST – whether business arrangements constituted a partnership – whether business arrangements a non-entity joint venture
Legislation: A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax) Act 1999 (Cth)
Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth)
Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth)
Cases cited:

A.R.M. Constructions Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1987) 87 ATC 4790
Amadio Pty Ltd v Henderson (1998) 81 FCR 149
Avon Downs Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1949) 78 CLR 353
Birtchnell v Equity Trustees, Executors & Agency Co Ltd (1929) 42 CLR 384
Fenston v Johnston (1940) 23 TC 29
Momentum Productions Pty Ltd v Lewarne (2009) 174 FCR 268; [2009] FCAFC 30
National Insurance Company of New Zealand Limited v Bray [1934] NZLR 67
United Dominions Corporation Ltd v Brian Pty Ltd (1985) 157 CLR 1
Whywait Pty Ltd v Davison [1997] 1 QdR 225

Lindley & Banks on Partnership (19th ed, Sweet & Maxwell Ltd, 2010)

Date of hearing: 12 June 2012
Date of last submissions: 27 June 2012
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 48
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr J Hyde Page
Solicitor for the Applicant: Munro Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr B C Kasep
Solicitor for the Respondent: TressCox Lawyers

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1600 of 2011

BETWEEN:

MADELINE YACOUB
Applicant

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
Respondent

JUDGE:

JAGOT J

DATE OF ORDER:

29 JUNE 2012

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Proceeding NSD 1600 of 2011 in the Federal Court of Australia be dismissed.

Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1601 of 2011

BETWEEN:

MAROUN YACOUB
Applicant

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
Respondent

JUDGE:

JAGOT J

DATE OF ORDER:

29 JUNE 2012

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Proceeding NSD 1601 of 2011 in the Federal Court of Australia be dismissed.

Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1600 of 2011

BETWEEN:

MADELINE YACOUB
Applicant

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
Respondent

JUDGE:

JAGOT J

DATE:

29 JUNE 2012

PLACE:

SYDNEY

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1601 of 2011

BETWEEN:

MAROUN YACOUB
Applicant

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
Respondent

JUDGE:

JAGOT J

DATE:

29 JUNE 2012

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

THE PROCEEDINGS

  1. The issue in these proceedings is whether the applicants are liable to pay goods and services…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Yacoub v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 678
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Yacoub v Commissioner of Taxation, the applicants, a husband and wife team of self-employed contract builders, sought to challenge the Commissioner of Taxation's decision to hold them liable for unpaid GST. The applicants argued that their business arrangements did not constitute a partnership and should have been recognised as a non-entity joint venture. The primary legal issues revolved around determining the nature of the business arrangements and whether the applicants were liable for the unpaid GST. The court had to examine the factual context and the terms of the Syndicate Agreement to discern whether the arrangement constituted a partnership or a non-entity joint venture.

The court found that the applicants' arrangements did not amount to a partnership because the agreement explicitly excluded the existence of a partnership. Instead, the court assessed whether the arrangements constituted a non-entity joint venture. After examining the terms of the agreement, the court concluded that the arrangements were indeed a joint venture, albeit a non-entity one. The court held that the Commissioner should have recognised the applicants' arrangements as a non-entity joint venture, which meant that the applicants were not liable for the unpaid GST.

The court dismissed the Commissioner's proceeding, finding in favour of the applicants. The decision hinged on the proper characterisation of the business arrangements and the subsequent implications for GST liability. The court's reasoning underscored the importance of the factual context and the terms of the agreement in determining the nature of the business relationship.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Proceeding NSD 1600 of 2011 in the Federal Court of Australia be dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

1. Proceeding NSD 1601 of 2011 in the Federal Court of Australia be dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The GST Act also provides for deregistration of entities. Section 25-60(1) provides that:The Commissioner must decide the date on which the cancellation of your *registration under subsection 25-55(1) or (2) or section 25-57 takes effect. That date may be any day occurring before, on or after the day on which the Commissioner makes the decision.THE FACTS Since 1997 the applicants, who are husband and wife, have been involved in the building industry as self-employed contract builders. They carried out their work through a registered partnership known as the M&M Yacoub Partnership. Mr Yacoub did the building work and Mrs Yacoub’s role was largely administrative. The M&M Yacoub Partnership did contract building work for EJ’s Constructions Pty Ltd (EJ’s). After the completion of one job in 2002 EJ’s owed the M&M Yacoub Partnership $700,000. Mr Yacoub was worried that the money would not be paid. The principal of EJ’s, Mr Elias, offered the Yacoubs a share in a new development at Lydford Street, Wentworthville. The development involved the acquisition and redevelopment for 30 villas on four properties. The four properties were acquired by EJ’s as to 75% as tenants in common with the applicants as joint tenants as to 25% as tenants in common. Despite obtaining development consent for the development in 2004 the work could not commence because of financing issues. In the meantime in 2005, and without legal assistance, the applicants and EJ’s entered into an agreement styled the Syndicate Agreement. The Syndicate Agreement included the following provisions:RECITALS:A. The parties hereto have agreed to constitute a syndicate for the purpose of Acquiring and developing real estate situated at and known as Lots 56-59 DP 12067,39-45 Lydbrook Street, Wentworthville NSW 2145. The erection thereon of a strata title building comprising 30 Units upon and subject to the terms and conditions appearing in this agreement.B. The parties agreed to place 103 Coleman st Merrylands, owned by Maroun and Madeline Yacoub, as a security to Capital FinanceC. The parties agreed to increase Maroun and Madeline Yacoub share by a further 25% of the project. When Part B is completed, Maroun and Madeline Yacoub will own 50% of the project and EJ’s construction the other 50%.…1. DEFINITIONS AND INTERPRETATION1.1 In this agreement the context permitting:…“Development” means the obtaining of development and building approval for residential strata title lots and the construction of those strata lots and all matters incidental thereto.“lots means the strata lots arising from registration of the strata plan.“property” means the property situated at 39-45 Lydbrook street, Wentworthville NSW 2145 being more particularly described as Lot 56-59 DP 12067. This property has an approved DA from Parramatta City Council, DA Number IE/0153/03 and determined 5/03/2004.“Strata Plan” means the strata plan of sub-division for the Property to be finalised by a surveyor and registered at the land title office during or immediately after the construction of the project.…2. PURPOSE2.1 The parties hereto (hereinafter called “The Syndicate Members”) shall Constitute a Syndicate under the style “The Lydbrook street Wentworthville Syndicate (hereinafter referred to as “the Syndicate”)2.2 The parties hereto agree to co-operate in every reasonable respect for the purpose of undertaking the development on the property and then registering the Strata Plan and transferring the Lots to the various parties. The parties will at all times throughout the term of this Agreement, act towards each other and comply with their obligations under this Agreement with the utmost good faith.2.3 It is agreed by and between the Syndicate Members hereto that the objects of the Syndicate are as follows:(a) To purchase the property(b) To demolish the fixtures and improvements presently erected on the property;(c) To appoint Mark Yacoub Builders Licence No 68592c as builder.(d) To each have a one 30th (1/30) share or a multiple thereof in the Property and development.(e) To prepare and register a Strata Plan in respect to the Development.(f) By way of partition at the completion of the Development and at the time registration of the Strata Plan the parties agree to each join in the transfer of Lots to be determined as hereinafter provided.3. EXCLUSION OF PARTNERSHIP3.1 No partnership shall exist between the parties and nothing contained in this agreement shall be construed as creating a partnership.4. DEVELOPMENT AND MANAGEMENT4.1 The parties shall act in good faith and co-operate with each other and devote their best endeavours to ensure that the Development is completed with all due diligence as soon as possible.4.2 The parties agree that the cost of the acquisition of the land and the cost Associated with that acquisition attributable to each Lot as approved by Capital Finance and contributed by the referred syndicate member at previous time shall be as set out in the Second Schedule annexed hereto.4.3 The parties hereto appoint Mark Yacoub as the Syndicate Manager and subject to this Agreement he shall manage the Development and keep all parties informed of all relevant activity in relation to the Development.…4.5 The Syndicate Members agree to pay the amounts specified in Schedule 2 on demand by the Syndicate Manager. The Members acknowledge that payment of these amounts upon demand is critical to the Syndicate purpose and should any demand for payment not be satisfied and met within seven (7) days then the defaulting Syndicate Member’s interest in the Syndicate and the Property shall be forfeited to the Syndicate Manager. The Syndicate Members hereby appoint the Syndicate Manager’s their Attorney to execute any Transfer of other document which may be necessary to vest the Syndicate Members interest in this Agreement and the Property in the Syndicate Manager upon a Syndicate Member’s default. Any moneys which have been paid by the Syndicate member in default will be refunded to that Syndicate Member less any and all reasonable costs incurred by the Syndicate Manager as a result of the Syndicate Member’s default.4.6 the Syndicate Members will each be liable and responsible for the cost of the acquisition of the Property and the building costs of the Development will be met by borrowings and the Syndicate Manager will arrange for financing for the building costs of the Development with the interest to be capitalised. The Syndicate Members agree to do all necessary matters, acts and things and sign any Mortgages or other documents necessary to secure the financing. The Syndicate Members agree that upon registration of the Strata Plan the financing of the Development costs will need to be repaid and all Syndicate Members agree with time being of the essence that within twenty-one (21) days of registration of the Strata Plan they will each be responsible for repayment of the financing for the Development costs in accordance with their respective interests in the Development and the Syndicate Members acknowledge and agree that they will need to be responsible for repayment of their portion of the Development financing either from a sale of their Lot or using their Lot as security to raise their share of the Development financing costs. The cost to be repayed to Capital Finance shall be 1/30 th (one thirtieth) of the Total loan and capitalised interest as calculated by Capital Finance.4.7 Upon confirmation of payment to Capital Finance as described in the previous item 4.6, the syndicate member will receive the title for that particular unit and can manage with it or transfer it to another buyer.4.8 The parties agree to sign all necessary documents and do all necessary Acts, matters and things to prepare and register a Strata Plan in respect of the Development at the conclusion of the building works. The parties will pay to the Syndicate Manager when requested each party’s share of the costs of preparation and registration of the Strata Plan.4.9 Upon registration of the Strata Plan the parties agree to sign all necessary transfers and other documents necessary to effect a partition so that each party receives the lot allocated to him in Schedule 2 before mentioned. In the event that any lot is valued at a greater value than any other lot in the development then the party entitled to that lot shall pay any stamp duty attributable to that lot having a greater value.4.10 The parties agree that they will bear their respective potions of council rates, water rates and land tax on the property from the date of completion of the property until the partition hereinbefore referred to is effected. The parties shall pay their respective share of outgoings in proportion to their respective interest in the development and they shall pay their share of outgoings to the Syndicate Manager upon demand by the Syndicate Manager.…13.PARTY’S INDEMNITIES13.1 The parties acknowledge that under the Mortgage advance which they have obtained pursuant to Clause 4.6 that each of the parties will have a joint and several liabilities under the Mortgage to the Mortgagee notwithstanding that the parties interests in the development are unequal. Notwithstanding the provisions of the Mortgage the parties agree between themselves that they shall only be liable for that part of the borrowing and Mortgage advance as is equal to their interests in the development as set ort in Schedule 1. Should any party pay more than their share towards the borrowings or otherwise then as set out in Schedule 1, then that party is entitled to require the other party or parties to contribute towards the excessive payment and the other parties agree to indemnify and keep indemnified the party who has paid the extra amount for the over payment.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 444-30 of Sch 1 to the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) (Taxation Administration Act) relevantly provides that:(1)Obligations that are imposed under this Schedule or an *indirect tax law on a partnership are imposed on each partner, but may be discharged by any of the partners. (2)The partners are jointly and severally liable to pay any amount that is payable under this Schedule or an *indirect tax law by the partnership. Accordingly, if, as the Commissioner contends, Myej Lydbrook was a partnership then the applicants are liable for the unpaid GST. If, as the applicants contend, Myej Lydbrook was not a partnership or the Commissioner should have been satisfied that Myej Lydbrook was a non-entity joint venture at all times or at some time then the applicants are not liable or at least not wholly liable for the unpaid GST. To determine the legal character of the arrangements involving Myej Lydbrook it is necessary to describe the factual context. The GST Act also provides for deregistration of entities. Section 25-60(1) provides that:The Commissioner must decide the date on which the cancellation of your *registration under subsection 25-55(1) or (2) or section 25-57 takes effect. That date may be any day occurring before, on or after the day on which the Commissioner makes the decision.THE FACTS Since 1997 the applicants, who are husband and wife, have been involved in the building industry as self-employed contract builders. They carried out their work through a registered partnership known as the M&M Yacoub Partnership. Mr Yacoub did the building work and Mrs Yacoub’s role was largely administrative. The M&M Yacoub Partnership did contract building work for EJ’s Constructions Pty Ltd (EJ’s). After the completion of one job in 2002 EJ’s owed the M&M Yacoub Partnership $700,000. Mr Yacoub was worried that the money would not be paid. The principal of EJ’s, Mr Elias, offered the Yacoubs a share in a new development at Lydford Street, Wentworthville. The development involved the acquisition and redevelopment for 30 villas on four properties. The four properties were acquired by EJ’s as to 75% as tenants in common with the applicants as joint tenants as to 25% as tenants in common. Despite obtaining development consent for the development in 2004 the work could not commence because of financing issues. In the meantime in 2005, and without legal assistance, the applicants and EJ’s entered into an agreement styled the Syndicate Agreement. The Syndicate Agreement included the following provisions:RECITALS:A. The parties hereto have agreed to constitute a syndicate for the purpose of Acquiring and developing real estate situated at and known as Lots 56-59 DP 12067,39-45 Lydbrook Street, Wentworthville NSW 2145. The erection thereon of a strata title building comprising 30 Units upon and subject to the terms and conditions appearing in this agreement.B. The parties agreed to place 103 Coleman st Merrylands, owned by Maroun and Madeline Yacoub, as a security to Capital FinanceC. The parties agreed to increase Maroun and Madeline Yacoub share by a further 25% of the project. When Part B is completed, Maroun and Madeline Yacoub will own 50% of the project and EJ’s construction the other 50%.…1. DEFINITIONS AND INTERPRETATION1.1 In this agreement the context permitting:…“Development” means the obtaining of development and building approval for residential strata title lots and the construction of those strata lots and all matters incidental thereto.“lots means the strata lots arising from registration of the strata plan.“property” means the property situated at 39-45 Lydbrook street, Wentworthville NSW 2145 being more particularly described as Lot 56-59 DP 12067. This property has an approved DA from Parramatta City Council, DA Number IE/0153/03 and determined 5/03/2004.“Strata Plan” means the strata plan of sub-division for the Property to be finalised by a surveyor and registered at the land title office during or immediately after the construction of the project.…2. PURPOSE2.1 The parties hereto (hereinafter called “The Syndicate Members”) shall Constitute a Syndicate under the style “The Lydbrook street Wentworthville Syndicate (hereinafter referred to as “the Syndicate”)2.2 The parties hereto agree to co-operate in every reasonable respect for the purpose of undertaking the development on the property and then registering the Strata Plan and transferring the Lots to the various parties. The parties will at all times throughout the term of this Agreement, act towards each other and comply with their obligations under this Agreement with the utmost good faith.2.3 It is agreed by and between the Syndicate Members hereto that the objects of the Syndicate are as follows:(a) To purchase the property(b) To demolish the fixtures and improvements presently erected on the property;(c) To appoint Mark Yacoub Builders Licence No 68592c as builder.(d) To each have a one 30th (1/30) share or a multiple thereof in the Property and development.(e) To prepare and register a Strata Plan in respect to the Development.(f) By way of partition at the completion of the Development and at the time registration of the Strata Plan the parties agree to each join in the transfer of Lots to be determined as hereinafter provided.3. EXCLUSION OF PARTNERSHIP3.1 No partnership shall exist between the parties and nothing contained in this agreement shall be construed as creating a partnership.4. DEVELOPMENT AND MANAGEMENT4.1 The parties shall act in good faith and co-operate with each other and devote their best endeavours to ensure that the Development is completed with all due diligence as soon as possible.4.2 The parties agree that the cost of the acquisition of the land and the cost Associated with that acquisition attributable to each Lot as approved by Capital Finance and contributed by the referred syndicate member at previous time shall be as set out in the Second Schedule annexed hereto.4.3 The parties hereto appoint Mark Yacoub as the Syndicate Manager and subject to this Agreement he shall manage the Development and keep all parties informed of all relevant activity in relation to the Development.…4.5 The Syndicate Members agree to pay the amounts specified in Schedule 2 on demand by the Syndicate Manager. The Members acknowledge that payment of these amounts upon demand is critical to the Syndicate purpose and should any demand for payment not be satisfied and met within seven (7) days then the defaulting Syndicate Member’s interest in the Syndicate and the Property shall be forfeited to the Syndicate Manager. The Syndicate Members hereby appoint the Syndicate Manager’s their Attorney to execute any Transfer of other document which may be necessary to vest the Syndicate Members interest in this Agreement and the Property in the Syndicate Manager upon a Syndicate Member’s default. Any moneys which have been paid by the Syndicate member in default will be refunded to that Syndicate Member less any and all reasonable costs incurred by the Syndicate Manager as a result of the Syndicate Member’s default.4.6 the Syndicate Members will each be liable and responsible for the cost of the acquisition of the Property and the building costs of the Development will be met by borrowings and the Syndicate Manager will arrange for financing for the building costs of the Development with the interest to be capitalised. The Syndicate Members agree to do all necessary matters, acts and things and sign any Mortgages or other documents necessary to secure the financing. The Syndicate Members agree that upon registration of the Strata Plan the financing of the Development costs will need to be repaid and all Syndicate Members agree with time being of the essence that within twenty-one (21) days of registration of the Strata Plan they will each be responsible for repayment of the financing for the Development costs in accordance with their respective interests in the Development and the Syndicate Members acknowledge and agree that they will need to be responsible for repayment of their portion of the Development financing either from a sale of their Lot or using their Lot as security to raise their share of the Development financing costs. The cost to be repayed to Capital Finance shall be 1/30 th (one thirtieth) of the Total loan and capitalised interest as calculated by Capital Finance.4.7 Upon confirmation of payment to Capital Finance as described in the previous item 4.6, the syndicate member will receive the title for that particular unit and can manage with it or transfer it to another buyer.4.8 The parties agree to sign all necessary documents and do all necessary Acts, matters and things to prepare and register a Strata Plan in respect of the Development at the conclusion of the building works. The parties will pay to the Syndicate Manager when requested each party’s share of the costs of preparation and registration of the Strata Plan.4.9 Upon registration of the Strata Plan the parties agree to sign all necessary transfers and other documents necessary to effect a partition so that each party receives the lot allocated to him in Schedule 2 before mentioned. In the event that any lot is valued at a greater value than any other lot in the development then the party entitled to that lot shall pay any stamp duty attributable to that lot having a greater value.4.10 The parties agree that they will bear their respective potions of council rates, water rates and land tax on the property from the date of completion of the property until the partition hereinbefore referred to is effected. The parties shall pay their respective share of outgoings in proportion to their respective interest in the development and they shall pay their share of outgoings to the Syndicate Manager upon demand by the Syndicate Manager.…13.PARTY’S INDEMNITIES13.1 The parties acknowledge that under the Mortgage advance which they have obtained pursuant to Clause 4.6 that each of the parties will have a joint and several liabilities under the Mortgage to the Mortgagee notwithstanding that the parties interests in the development are unequal. Notwithstanding the provisions of the Mortgage the parties agree between themselves that they shall only be liable for that part of the borrowing and Mortgage advance as is equal to their interests in the development as set ort in Schedule 1. Should any party pay more than their share towards the borrowings or otherwise then as set out in Schedule 1, then that party is entitled to require the other party or parties to contribute towards the excessive payment and the other parties agree to indemnify and keep indemnified the party who has paid the extra amount for the over payment.