XWPX and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

XWPX and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2020] AATA 546 (16 March 2020)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2018/6244

Re:XWPX

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndVMPW

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:The Hon. John Pascoe AC CVO, Deputy President

Date:16 March 2020

Place:Sydney

The decision of the Social Services and Child Support Division dated 2 October 2018 is affirmed.

..............................[sgd].........................................

The Hon. John Pascoe AC CVO, Deputy President

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

CATCHWORDS

CHILD SUPPORT – review of decision of Social Services and Child Support Division –  percentage of care – where father claimed the child lived entirely with him for the relevant period – where father claimed special circumstances for not lodging an objection to the care percentage determination – decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) – ss 49, 50

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) – s 87AA

CASES

Child Support Registrar v MQMV & Ors [2019] FCA 1171

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Child Support Policy Guide

REASONS FOR DECISION

The Hon. John Pascoe AC CVO, Deputy President

16 March 2020

Background

  1. The Applicant and the Other Party are the parents of their child aged 15, who is the subject of this Application. They are also the parents of another older son, ‘R’.

  2. The matter before the Tribunal has a long history as follows.

  3. An administrative assessment of child support commenced on 25 November 2009, based on the Other Party having 100% care of the child.

  4. On 11 April 2017, the Applicant notified the Registrar that she had care of 90% from 11 March 2017.

  5. On 29 April 2017, the existing percentage of care was revoked and a new percentage of care determination was made such that care was 90% to the Applicant and 10% to the Other Party with effect from 11 March 2017.

  6. On 16 November 2017, the Other Party notified the Registrar that actual care was 0% to the parents as the child had been residing with his older brother from 15 September 2017. The Applicant disputed this and claimed the child was still living under her roof.

  7. On 10 January 2018, the Other Party notified the Registrar that he had 100% care of the child from 8 December 2017.

  8. On 7 February 2018, the Registrar made a decision not to change the percentage of care and rejected the Other Party’s claim that the parents each had 0% care of the child from 15 September 2017.

  9. In respect of the Other Party’s subsequent claim that he had 100% care of the child from 8 December 2017, the Applicant disputed this and maintained that the child did not leave her care until 15 February 2018.

  10. On 16 March 2018, the Registrar made…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read XWPX and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 546
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review of a child support decision, brought before the Hon. John Pascoe AC CVO, Deputy President. The dispute centred on the percentage of care for a child between the applicant mother and the respondent father for the period from 8 December 2017 to 15 February 2018. The applicant claimed to be the primary carer during this time, with the child spending only occasional time with the father and periods away from both parents. The respondent father contended that the child lived entirely with him for the relevant period.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was to determine the correct percentage of care for the child during the specified period. This involved assessing the credibility and weight of the evidence presented by both parties regarding the child's living arrangements. A secondary issue, arising from the Federal Court decision in *Child Support Registrar v MQMV & Ors* [2019] FCA 1171, concerned the Tribunal's jurisdiction to consider whether a care percentage decision could have effect from a date earlier than that previously permitted by the Child Support Registrar.

The Tribunal gave greater weight to the evidence of the respondent father, finding his testimony to be less inconsistent and corroborated by witness R and documentary evidence concerning the child's schooling and efforts to address his behaviour. The applicant's evidence was found to be vague regarding the child's absences and her attempts to locate him, and her actions following significant behavioural issues, such as the child trashing her home, were not demonstrative of a consistent pattern of care. The Tribunal noted the child's progression to school and an apprenticeship while living with the father, indicating a positive turnaround. Consequently, the Tribunal concluded that the applicant had no pattern of care during the relevant period and that the respondent father had 100% care.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision regarding the percentage of care. The issue of special circumstances preventing the timely lodging of an objection, as outlined in section 87AA of the *Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988* (Cth), was also considered in light of the *MQMV* decision. However, the Tribunal's finding that the respondent father had 100% care meant that the applicant had not established the necessary basis for an earlier date of effect for any objection.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns a dispute regarding the percentage of care attributed to each parent for a child, as well as the timing of an objection to the care percentage determination. The Applicant, who had primary care of the child up until 15 February 2018, claimed the child lived entirely with her during the relevant period. However, she could not provide a precise account of the number of nights the child spent away from her home, nor did she demonstrate any significant effort to ascertain where he was during those periods. The Applicant also highlighted that the child had committed several offences, including stealing her car, and had caused damage to her property, leading to her eviction. Despite these issues, she did not provide any evidence of attempts to modify the child's behaviour or offer support to him.

The Other Party, who claimed 100% care of the child from 8 December 2017 onwards, provided evidence that the child had returned to school and was currently undertaking an apprenticeship. His evidence was supported by witness statements and correspondence related to the child's school enrolment. The Tribunal found the Other Party's evidence to be more consistent and reliable, leading to the conclusion that he had 100% care of the child from 8 December 2017 to the present.

The dispute also involved the timing of the objection to the care percentage determination. The Other Party claimed special circumstances prevented him from lodging the objection within the required timeframe. The Tribunal considered various factors, including whether the extension of the objection period would prejudice the Applicant or if the Other Party had rested on his rights. Ultimately, the Tribunal decided to affirm the percentage of care determination and did not extend the objection period.

This case before the tribunal is a review of a decision made by the Social Services and Child Support Division regarding the percentage of care for a child. The father had objected to the determination of the care percentage, claiming that the child lived entirely with him during the relevant period and that there were special circumstances preventing him from lodging an objection within the required timeframe. The matter came before the tribunal as a second review of the child support decision. The tribunal considered the evidence provided by both parents, as well as relevant policy documents and prior decisions. The tribunal was required to determine whether the father's claim of special circumstances was valid and if the date of effect of the objection decision could be applied from an earlier date. The tribunal's decision affirmed the percentage of care determination, finding that the father had 100% care of the child during the relevant period. This decision follows the guidelines set out in the Child Support Policy Document and the Child Support Guide, as well as the relevant sections of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In determining the matter, the Tribunal has also had regard to the Child Support Policy Document (2.2 – 4.1.8) which provides guidance in determinations of child support. EvidenceThe Applicant The Applicant gave evidence that from 8 December 2017 until 15 February 2018 she was the primary carer for the child. She stated that during the period in question the child spent occasional time with his father. She also gave evidence that there were periods of time where he was not with either parent, including times where no one knew where he was. The Applicant said that as it was school holidays he was often staying elsewhere, including on camping trips with friends. She was unable to recall how many nights the child spent away from her home. The Applicant said that she had given the child money for train fares but had no record of any such payments. The Applicant said that she had taken the child to the police station on 5 February 2018 in accordance with the requirements of a notice of caution issued by the police on 23 January 2018, a copy of which was before the Tribunal. The Applicant gave evidence that the child had appeared before the courts on a number of occasions for various offences including stealing her car. She also gave evidence that the child had “trashed” her house in October 2017 and that as a result she had been required to vacate her rented premises. There had been numerous incidents at the house involving the child around that time, including fights on the street outside. The Applicant said that the child had lived with her intermittently during the period up until 15 February 2018, when she says he left following an ultimatum that she’d given him regarding his behaviour. The Applicant gave evidence that all correspondence in relation to the child breaking the law, court appearances and requirements to attend the police station were sent to her home. In addition to her oral evidence, the Applicant provided written statements to the Tribunal. She also provided a number of letters from family, friends and medical practitioners, all of which stated either that in their knowledge the child was living with her or that she had informed them that the child was living with her throughout the relevant period. This material was of limited evidentiary value as the majority of it relied on observations made by the Applicant to a third party. For example, the Applicant’s mother stated:From the constant distressed phone calls, regarding police involvement with law breaking, court appearances, and disrespectful behaviour towards her, that I had from [the Applicant] during the period of time in question, I know that [the child’s] full time address was with [the Applicant]. She had no reason to invent the incidents each time since she was truly distressed about [the child’s] actions. She was required to appear in court regarding incidents [the child] was involved in outside her house and while he lived at her house. Her psychologist stated that:I have been [the Applicant’s] treating psychologist over the past 7 years. From referring to my notes I can confirm that [the Applicant] has discussed with me issues regarding her son, [the child], including that he was living with her full time between March 2017 and February 2018.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Further guidance is provided in the Child Support Guide at p. 67 as follows:Objection decision to apply from an earlier dateThe care percentage objection decision may have effect from an earlier day if the Registrar is satisfied that there are special circumstances that prevented the person from lodging their objection within the required timeframe (section 87AA(2)). The Registrar must first be satisfied that special circumstances exist, and then the Registrar has discretion as to whether to extend the period in which to lodge the objection, in order for the objection decision to have effect from the earlier date.Special circumstancesIn considering special circumstances the Registrar will look at the particular circumstances of the applicant. The applicant must show that their particular circumstances prevented them from lodging an objection within the required timeframe. They must explain why there was a delay in lodging the objection and that the circumstances are sufficiently special for the applicant to receive the benefit of an extension to the period in which to lodge an objection, in order for the objection decision to have effect from an earlier date. Some examples of special circumstances may include:·the parent was seriously ill or had an accident that stopped them from lodging an objection·the parent suffered a personal trauma such as a death in the family or a natural disaster that caused damage to the parent's property·the parent had communication difficulties, including isolation, illiteracy or poor English-language skills·the parent reasonably relied upon inaccurate or misleading information.If the Registrar is satisfied that special circumstances exist, the Registrar will then consider whether it is appropriate to exercise the discretion to extend the period in which to lodge the objection (section 87AA(2)). The Registrar will consider if:·the decision to extend the period in which to lodge the objection will prejudice the other parent. For example, will the extension that results in an earlier date of effect for the objection decision create a significant overpayment or significant arrears of child support?·the applicant rested on their rights. For example, did the applicant make any efforts to lodge the objection earlier, communicate to DHS that the decision was being contested or raised their concerns in other ways - for example, a complaint to DHS or the Ombudsman?If the Registrar makes a determination under section 87AA(2) to extend the period in which to lodge the objection, then the objection is considered to have been received within the prescribed timeframe. The objection decision will then replace the original care percentage decision from the first day that original decision had effect. This issue arose at the hearing as a result of the decision of the Federal Court of Australia in Child Support Registrar v MQMV & Ors [2019] FCA 1171. Previously, the CSR had claimed the Tribunal had no jurisdiction to consider whether a date earlier than 15 May 2019 could apply.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

R said that the father had raised both him and his brother single-handedly from the age of seven or eight.Consideration The Child Support Policy Document (30-32) gives guidance to the Tribunal in making a decision where there is a lack of clarity as to who has the care of the child. In this case it is not entirely clear as to the number of nights the child spent with the Applicant or the Other Party, and the number of nights spent away from both. However, I give greater weight to the evidence of the Other Party in this regard. There were fewer inconsistencies in his evidence and it was corroborated by witness R. In relation to the Applicant’s evidence I was concerned by her statements as to the child being away a lot or most of the time because it was school holidays, without really being able to put a figure on the number of days or give evidence of any real attempt to find out where he was. Further, the evidence as to the child coming to her house (and perhaps staying the previous night) when he was to get money from her seemed to indicate his visits were sporadic in nature and related particularly to getting money from her. I was also concerned that she said she had given him an ultimatum to leave on 15 February 2018 as a result of him stealing her car. She did not appear to have taken any action after the child trashed her house causing her to be given notice to vacate the property, and there was no evidence as to what the damage entailed and whether it would have affected the child’s ability to live in the house. Apart from accompanying the child to court or the police station, the Applicant could give no evidence of any attempt to change the child’s behaviour or assist him to get his life back together. At the time the child was 14 years old and clearly needing parental guidance. There was no evidence of any pattern of care. I give weight to the Other Party’s evidence which is supported by the email dated 30 January 2018 in relation to his involvement in registering the child at school and the reasons for doing so. I also give weight to his evidence as to his efforts to turn the child’s life around and to get him off drugs. I note the evidence that the child had returned to school and that he had progressed to an apprenticeship which he is currently undertaking. It was not disputed that the child has continued to live with the father since 8 December 2017. Accordingly, having regard to all of the evidence I am of the opinion that the Applicant had no pattern of care for the child during the relevant period and that the Other Party had 100% care of the child during the period from 8 December 2017 to present. His evidence was corroborated by witness R and the e-mails in relation to his schooling The decision in regards to the percentage of care is affirmed.Date of Effect This issue is governed by section 87AA of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth), which states as follow:(1) If: (a)a person lodges, under section 80A, an objection to a care percentage decision; and(b)the objection is lodged more than 28 days or, if the person is a resident of a reciprocating jurisdiction, 90 days after notice of the care percentage decision was served; and(c)the Registrar decides (the review decision), under section 87, to allow the objection in a way that has the effect of varying the determination to which the care percentage decision relates, or substituting a new determination;the date of effect of the review decision is the day on which the person lodged the objection.(2) If the Registrar is satisfied that there are special circumstances that prevented the person from lodging the objection within the period referred to in paragraph (1)(b), the Registrar may determine that subsection (1) applies as if: (a) in a case where the person is a resident of a reciprocating jurisdiction--the reference to 90 days in that paragraph were a reference to such longer period as the Registrar determines to be appropriate; or (b) otherwise--the reference to 28 days in that paragraph were a reference to such longer period as the Registrar determines to be appropriate.